MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bozotheclown]

I find it hard to reason why three scum would land on the same wagon. Unless they were certain it would have held traction. I guess if it had worked then it would have directed a lot of questioning towards them of why they killed another VT. I suppose the risk in the play comes from knowing the next day they would have to bus one of the team.

Of course they didn’t expect to lose ghug at night either so that really changed things.

Probably would make them look worse by jumping on a last-minute wagon.

Who’s got the shittier-looking D2 EoDs?

If there were 2 mafia already voting for you, it might explain why Chaqa avoided your wagon at EOD until it was his only chance of saving himself.

[seth24c]

Wow what a clutch call damo! Nicely done!

[TrPrado]

Oh also someone should look into bo. He made a comment that I thought was really weird before, and now it's even worse. He said something like if you look into my conversation with ghug that you'd be able to figure out our alignments but that he was too lazy to do so? Which I couldn't understand why he would say that or what he meant. But with ghug flipping scum it's a lot more sus.

Although, imagine this scum team: bo+Chaqa+ghug+vecna

I would die laughing. Even if it's just the first three + one random

It was in one of his big walls of text so I really had to look

I’m kind of annoyed that I just woke up in the middle of the night, decided to read up on this thread because I hate myself, and found nothing more than a page and a half of ghug shitposting

Is there anything about it that is AI to you?

As I recall no, but if you want to sift through the casual flirting I’d say his conversations with Durga could probably reveal both of their alignments if you really dug.

I don't get it as an answer to the question worcej asked either. It's pretty clear he asked whether bo thought ghug shitposting at all was AI, but bo seemed to interpret it as anything WITHIN the shitposting that could be AI. Does that make sense? Is that how it reads to anyone else?

[bozotheclown]

Okay - hold on. So, witch auto wins if our 2 PR's die right? So... We should kill for 3p? Not sure how to go about doing this

We have 3 PRs still alive. The mafia would lose also, so they should be motivated to keep damo alive since his power is used.

[TrPrado]

On a separate note: Bob's posts seem to be very long-winded ways of saying not much at all.

[bozotheclown]

I 100% think Durga is scum, but don't think anyone will agree with me at this point.

Do you have a case?

Two things
1. I'm a little pissed off that people are entertaining that I would bus two scum team members when everyone knows I don't bus. Stop wasting time. This is why y'all keep losing as town.

2. Put TrPrado on the 3rd party potential list. He's the perfect amount of null to be there.

Also, I hate 3ps. I just want to catch scum. This extra bullshit is so boring.

I do not believe worcej would really think that.

[seth24c]

I'd say the 4 remaining scum are within rdr, worcej, ghug, HB, seth, Bob, bo

I would say at least one* of the 2 remaining Maf and possibly both are in worcej, seth, bob, rdr [that order]

3p is prob HB or one of those

there may a deepscum but if so I think they win

I got 2 more days, let's get 2 of the remaining 3 in those 2 days.

Interesting. If seth is mafia he would have followed ghug onto Bunny and then on day 2 would have done some light bussing.

During day 1:

This is the second or third time you ask people about me. Do I need to go outside and check my bushes?

Youre free to spit your own opinion. In fact, im rather curious now.

I was less interested in you than what Ghug’s response was. I’m still learning the players so the interaction between you and Ghug earlier had caught my eye and I wanted to hear more from their side.

As far as I can tell Ghug wasn't involved in this exchange. Seth did you except ghug to respond to this?

You are right that ghug did not respond. After seeing the ghug-vecna interaction I wanted to see if I could get them talking more about each other. I wanted to hear from ghug in particular since vecna had initiated the first interaction. Once vecna responded defensively I figured that if either of them were scum they would be on guard and unlikely to indicate anything so I dropped it.

[bozotheclown]

Oh also someone should look into bo. He made a comment that I thought was really weird before, and now it's even worse. He said something like if you look into my conversation with ghug that you'd be able to figure out our alignments but that he was too lazy to do so? Which I couldn't understand why he would say that or what he meant. But with ghug flipping scum it's a lot more sus.

Although, imagine this scum team: bo+Chaqa+ghug+vecna

I would die laughing. Even if it's just the first three + one random

It was in one of his big walls of text so I really had to look

Is there anything about it that is AI to you?

As I recall no, but if you want to sift through the casual flirting I’d say his conversations with Durga could probably reveal both of their alignments if you really dug.

I don't get it as an answer to the question worcej asked either. It's pretty clear he asked whether bo thought ghug shitposting at all was AI, but bo seemed to interpret it as anything WITHIN the shitposting that could be AI. Does that make sense? Is that how it reads to anyone else?

I read it the way bo_sox did. I think what Durga was saying is suspicious is that he said both their alignments could probably be determined by it, yet he apparently had no interest in making that determination.

[seth24c]

Oh also someone should look into bo. He made a comment that I thought was really weird before, and now it's even worse. He said something like if you look into my conversation with ghug that you'd be able to figure out our alignments but that he was too lazy to do so? Which I couldn't understand why he would say that or what he meant. But with ghug flipping scum it's a lot more sus.

Although, imagine this scum team: bo+Chaqa+ghug+vecna

I would die laughing. Even if it's just the first three + one random

It was in one of his big walls of text so I really had to look

Is there anything about it that is AI to you?

As I recall no, but if you want to sift through the casual flirting I’d say his conversations with Durga could probably reveal both of their alignments if you really dug.

I don't get it as an answer to the question worcej asked either. It's pretty clear he asked whether bo thought ghug shitposting at all was AI, but bo seemed to interpret it as anything WITHIN the shitposting that could be AI. Does that make sense? Is that how it reads to anyone else?

It almost sounds like bo answers both to me. He first says that he doesn't recall it being AI for ghug. Then makes the remark that someone could determine both durga/ghug's alignment from digging into their conversation. Not really sure why he thinks that but it definitely seems like a lazy post..

[TrPrado]

Oh also someone should look into bo. He made a comment that I thought was really weird before, and now it's even worse. He said something like if you look into my conversation with ghug that you'd be able to figure out our alignments but that he was too lazy to do so? Which I couldn't understand why he would say that or what he meant. But with ghug flipping scum it's a lot more sus.

Although, imagine this scum team: bo+Chaqa+ghug+vecna

I would die laughing. Even if it's just the first three + one random

It was in one of his big walls of text so I really had to look

As I recall no, but if you want to sift through the casual flirting I’d say his conversations with Durga could probably reveal both of their alignments if you really dug.

I don't get it as an answer to the question worcej asked either. It's pretty clear he asked whether bo thought ghug shitposting at all was AI, but bo seemed to interpret it as anything WITHIN the shitposting that could be AI. Does that make sense? Is that how it reads to anyone else?

I read it the way bo_sox did. I think what Durga was saying is suspicious is that he said both their alignments could probably be determined by it, yet he apparently had no interest in making that determination.

Well, that too, but Durga had said that part herself. There's also the question of how do you get both from "ghug's flirting" and "ghug shitposting" which is a pretty one-sided characterization of the conversation.

[seth24c]

It seemed like you were more strongly scumreading worcej and Yoyo/Bob, and now this is your vote with 20 minutes to go?

I can vote for worcej. I thought his start of day was good but he just dropped off again. Dude's got a young child though... If people want to consolidate on worcej I'll join.

I'd go worcej over flash and Chaqa at this point.

This seems to look good for worcej.

[seth24c]

I'd go worcej over flash and Chaqa at this point.

Same here, not buying that what chaqa said about HB was a scum slip.

LOL great call Seth.

[seth24c]

Okay, things got pushed back by an hour, so I'm back until EoD.

Someone explain why they're voting for me?

And it's odd the worcej wagon evaporated in like one page, isn't it?

This is scummy as hell. Maybe it isn't a coin flip.

Rdr, when you saw this was so scummy of chaqa why did you wait until the wagon was a runaway to vote for him?

[bozotheclown]

I can vote for worcej. I thought his start of day was good but he just dropped off again. Dude's got a young child though... If people want to consolidate on worcej I'll join.

I'd go worcej over flash and Chaqa at this point.

This seems to look good for worcej.

Could be scum distancing.

[seth24c]

I'd go worcej over flash and Chaqa at this point.

This seems to look good for worcej.

Could be scum distancing.

That is true also. Guess it doesn't indicate much, especially as the 3p is also still out there.

[Vecna]

I'd say the 4 remaining scum are within rdr, worcej, ghug, HB, seth, Bob, bo

I would say at least one* of the 2 remaining Maf and possibly both are in worcej, seth, bob, rdr [that order]

3p is prob HB or one of those

there may a deepscum but if so I think they win

I got 2 more days, let's get 2 of the remaining 3 in those 2 days.

Interesting. If seth is mafia he would have followed ghug onto Bunny and then on day 2 would have done some light bussing.

During day 1:

This is the second or third time you ask people about me. Do I need to go outside and check my bushes?

Youre free to spit your own opinion. In fact, im rather curious now.

I was less interested in you than what Ghug’s response was. I’m still learning the players so the interaction between you and Ghug earlier had caught my eye and I wanted to hear more from their side.

As far as I can tell Ghug wasn't involved in this exchange. Seth did you except ghug to respond to this?

He was referring there to me asking Ghug why we never rolled scum together.

ill do a catchup of the very little that went on while I was asleep, but itll not look great on those people that nagged about that before, but did not come back to it now that he flipped.

[Vecna]

She may not have been the first scum on the bus. There is still the potential of Vecna and yourself if we are determining ‘first’

Well if anybody with experience with vecna's scumgame wants to chime in. I mean I'd consider that a beautiful performance. Chaqa too.

I think it is possible Vecna would bus there thinking it was unlikely Chaqa would be killed, but I doubt he would take that risk for so little gain.

Besides, it was pretty obvious we had a thing going where at least the three of us were following eachother to get that town-wagon going

[damo666]

I can vote for worcej. I thought his start of day was good but he just dropped off again. Dude's got a young child though... If people want to consolidate on worcej I'll join.

I'd go worcej over flash and Chaqa at this point.

This seems to look good for worcej.

This is good point (unless the 2 maf are precisely Seth and worcej)

[Vecna]

Okay - hold on. So, witch auto wins if our 2 PR's die right? So... We should kill for 3p? Not sure how to go about doing this

best to kill the remaining mafia.

if both mafia are dead, theres no way for 3p to kill the Pr's

[Vecna]

Oh also someone should look into bo. He made a comment that I thought was really weird before, and now it's even worse. He said something like if you look into my conversation with ghug that you'd be able to figure out our alignments but that he was too lazy to do so? Which I couldn't understand why he would say that or what he meant. But with ghug flipping scum it's a lot more sus.

Although, imagine this scum team: bo+Chaqa+ghug+vecna

I would die laughing. Even if it's just the first three + one random

I really hope thats not the case, because if those 3 are scum together im so eating a mislynch for all my "bo+chaqa+ghug = same person" shittalk lol