MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

The mafia likely has a lie detector and will use it to try to find 3p

[TrPrado]

The following slots have unfavourable voting both days

Bob
Bo
ghug
Ham
Worcej

Unfavorable due to what? Important criteria to assess.

Also, yeah my D2 was bad, but I stand by my read. I still don’t feel that Chaqa’s wagon occurred naturally.

Please elaborate. Who was unnatural on it and why?

[bozotheclown]

Wait wait wait. Does mafia have a roleblock?

I do not see anything about a mafia RB in the setup.

[TrPrado]

I think it is likely the early Chaqa voters are all town or 3P, I do not see why the mafia would want to start bussing Chaqa considering his role. Durga and emc in particular look good, Durga drove the kill of Chaqa, and emc's vote was critical in getting Chaqa. There may be a mafia in the last 4 Chaqa voters, but I currently town read those 4. Therefore, I would not be surprised if the entire Chaqa wagon is non-mafia. That leaves the "damo 5" as the top mafia suspects. Hamilton is probably town or 3P, he could have voted for flash before leaving to protect himself and Chaqa. I still say Yoyoyozo was town. That leaves bo_sox, ghug, and worcej as the most likely remaining mafia. Looking at their voting and interactions with each other and Chaqa, I do not see anything inconsistent with a Chaqa/bo_sox/ghug/worcej mafia team.

You wouldn’t be surprised if a group of 11 people were all town?

[bozotheclown]

I think it is likely the early Chaqa voters are all town or 3P, I do not see why the mafia would want to start bussing Chaqa considering his role. Durga and emc in particular look good, Durga drove the kill of Chaqa, and emc's vote was critical in getting Chaqa. There may be a mafia in the last 4 Chaqa voters, but I currently town read those 4. Therefore, I would not be surprised if the entire Chaqa wagon is non-mafia. That leaves the "damo 5" as the top mafia suspects. Hamilton is probably town or 3P, he could have voted for flash before leaving to protect himself and Chaqa. I still say Yoyoyozo was town. That leaves bo_sox, ghug, and worcej as the most likely remaining mafia. Looking at their voting and interactions with each other and Chaqa, I do not see anything inconsistent with a Chaqa/bo_sox/ghug/worcej mafia team.

You wouldn’t be surprised if a group of 11 people were all town?

I said non-mafia, not town. Chances are good the 3P was on the wagon. As I previously said, I think Foxcastle and rdrivera are the best possibilities for mafia on the wagon, but there might be no mafia.

[flash2015]

Wait wait wait. Does mafia have a roleblock?

I do not see anything about a mafia RB in the setup.

It was unclear in the main text he only mentioned the town roleblock, but then in a subsequent message Jamie T wrote:

"GM NOTE:

The MAFIA Nightkill and Roleblock in this game are factional. The kill is performed by a specific Mafia member, based on which Mafia member voted *most recently* for the kill target.

==PLEASE CONTINUE NOT POSTING=="

I am not sure if this was a boilerplate error or not.

[TrPrado]

Sounds like a possible outcome from numerous players if Chaqa told them to do it in the N1 scum chat.

This makes no sense

Yes it does - if Chaqa literally told his team to bus him because his RL situation is rough, I would think they would have no concerns doing it to build town cred

48 hours ahead of time and after he JUST subbed into the game?

[Durga]

Wait wait wait. Does mafia have a roleblock?

I do not see anything about a mafia RB in the setup.

It was unclear in the main text he only mentioned the town roleblock, but then in a subsequent message Jamie T wrote:

"GM NOTE:

The MAFIA Nightkill and Roleblock in this game are factional. The kill is performed by a specific Mafia member, based on which Mafia member voted *most recently* for the kill target.

==PLEASE CONTINUE NOT POSTING=="

I am not sure if this was a boilerplate error or not.

Damn factional rb is bullshit

[Foxcastle]

Today was the last day at the river house I’ve been staying at, so packing up and driving home, etc. I’m 10 pages behind and don’t expect to be caught up or back online before EON is called.

[damo666]

Assume Flash will be NK so ....

MD ghug

he will either be dead Mafia or a townclear if I die.

Dunno what if he's 3p. Guess we both survive.

[Jamiet99uk]

===============
NIGHT HAS ENDED
PLEASE HOLD

[Jamiet99uk]

END OF NIGHT TWO:

A great commotion from the castle could be heard during the night. Screams rang out, and it sounded like a fight was taking place inside. The villagers cowered in their homes, not daring to venture out until dawn broke. After a time there was more, demented screaming, perhaps from both male and female voices, as if those inside were losing their grip on sanity altogether.

When the light did return, the villagers discovered two bodies!

One belonged to the vicar many of them had accused of witchcraft, now hanging limply from the gibbet. But there was another, horribly mutilated as if hacked at repeatedly with an axe, although which was the fatal wound was hard to tell, so bloodied was his corpse. They rolled it over and gasped in amazement when they realised who it was!

"My God! The witchfinder himself!"

Flash2015 is dead - he was JOHN LOWES, the PRIEST!
Ghug is dead - he was MATTHEW HOPKINS, the TAMPERER!

DAY THREE HAS BEGUN
YOU MAY POST

[Durga]

LOOOOOL I FUCKING KNEW IT

[Durga]

yesss damo <3 a king

[Hamilton Brian]

Wow! Damo that was some call.

[damo666]

[damo666]

The fact he was MH is a bonus

[e.m.c^42]

Lmao that went well.

[summit_fever]

FINAL D1 VOTE COUNT:

BunnyGo (5) - worcej, Vecna, Hellenic Riot, ghug, Seth24c
BismarckAlive (4) - damo666, bozotheclown, summit_fever, Flash2015
damo666 (3) - BismarckAlive, bo_sox48, Durga
Yoyoyozo (3) - TrPrado, rdrivera2005, BunnyGo
Durga (2) - Foxcastle, Yoyoyozo
No‑Kill (1) - Hamilton Brian

Failed to vote: SarahK



Final D2 Votes:
Chaqa(11) - Vecna, summit_fever, Durga, TrPrado, e.m.c^42, flash2015, bozotheclown, damo666, Foxcastle, seth24c, rdrivera2005.
Hamilton Brian(3) - ghug, worcej, Chaqa
flash2015(2) - bo_sox48, BobMcBob
Unvote(1) - Hamilton Brian

[Vecna]

Hmmm, good news, but this puts us on a much much shorter clock suddenly to find the 3p