MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[bozotheclown]

##VOTE bo

It's important that people actually comply.

This could have been a signal to bo_sox that he should make the statement.

[bozotheclown]

Who is this aimed at?

At you obviously. You stated you dont think the chaqa wagon formed naturally. I want specifics.

As lame as this answer may be, it is a toss up between Durga and you.

Durga has continued to rub me wrong with the numerous posts indicating not understanding something. It is almost a troupe at this point.

You just seem off as well. I don’t like the amount of sheeping you are doing and I would expect town!you to try to take charge, but I am not seeing it.

Durga was strongly pushing the Chaqa kill before flash's claim, I doubt you would suspect her if you were town.

[bozotheclown]

Sounds like a possible outcome from numerous players if Chaqa told them to do it in the N1 scum chat.

This makes no sense

Yes it does - if Chaqa literally told his team to bus him because his RL situation is rough, I would think they would have no concerns doing it to build town cred

Considering his role, I doubt he told him teammates to bus him.

[Hamilton Brian]

The following slots have unfavourable voting both days

Bob
Bo
ghug
Ham
Worcej

What is your definition of unfavorable?

Not town friendly

Ghug and worcej day 2 not so bad I guess.

Gettting in here. Please explain how my votes were not town friendly.

[Vecna]

For now, I'll ##Vote Hamilton Brian as I prefer him slightly over flash, in case I can't get back on to make another vote

Oh btw this was a thing that happened.

Chaqa doing the "im going offline thing" mightve meant he wanted to execute on HB?

This vote did put HB to 8 which is just shy of the 50% required

[Vecna]

What do you think of that worcej post Vecna? Is it deranged townie or out of touch scum?

im not quite sure

[Hamilton Brian]

How do you reflect on calling me out as Flash' teammate now Bo?

You + HB as scum together fits quite well with how Chaqa approached that EoD there....

"look at this post, it must be a HB townslip"

"oh shit, im a wagon now, itd look really awkward if I dont vote HB my counterwagon now"

What the what? You're off but I'd love to see your analysis.

[damo666]

Are you 3p damo?

I am not 3p.

[Hamilton Brian]

This vote did put HB to 8 which is just shy of the 50% required

Interesting ideas; I just reread the role but it really stood out about how important it is to make sure a GM is available.

[damo666]

What is your definition of unfavorable?

Not town friendly

Ghug and worcej day 2 not so bad I guess.

Gettting in here. Please explain how my votes were not town friendly.

No attempt to daykill

[damo666]

Unfavorable due to what? Important criteria to assess.

Also, yeah my D2 was bad, but I stand by my read. I still don’t feel that Chaqa’s wagon occurred naturally.

I've answered this already.

Post #?

I don’t recall seeing it or at the very least want to understand what you think quantifies as an answer.

2126

[Hamilton Brian]

@Durga, totally bungled the quote on the iPad so...

"Also summit, I remember feeling yikes about him but I'll read it later"

Did you get to this and any results?

Had more questions about, and for, summit but trying to multitask.

[Durga]

@Durga, totally bungled the quote on the iPad so...

"Also summit, I remember feeling yikes about him but I'll read it later"

Did you get to this and any results?

Had more questions about, and for, summit but trying to multitask.

Summit? If he's scum he's the best scum player I've ever encountered

[Hamilton Brian]

@Durga, totally bungled the quote on the iPad so...

"Also summit, I remember feeling yikes about him but I'll read it later"

Did you get to this and any results?

Had more questions about, and for, summit but trying to multitask.

Summit? If he's scum he's the best scum player I've ever encountered

So was your "yikes" a "I think he might be scum" or not? Just trying to clarify.

[Durga]

@Durga, totally bungled the quote on the iPad so...

"Also summit, I remember feeling yikes about him but I'll read it later"

Did you get to this and any results?

Had more questions about, and for, summit but trying to multitask.

Summit? If he's scum he's the best scum player I've ever encountered

So was your "yikes" a "I think he might be scum" or not? Just trying to clarify.

I honestly don't even remember when I said that let alone what I was yikes about

[Hamilton Brian]

No attempt to daykill

Offered my rationale on both days but especially D1. I don't like this "jump on a wagon because it's trending" thing. Jumping on flash to save myself would have been disingenuous.

[bozotheclown]

No attempt to daykill

Offered my rationale on both days but especially D1. I don't like this "jump on a wagon because it's trending" thing. Jumping on flash to save myself would have been disingenuous.

Not voting for flash looks good, not voting for Chaqa does not look at good.

[Hamilton Brian]

@worcej, you said earlier, as you voted for me, that you didn't like chaqa's wagon.

What didn't you like about it?

How did you connect to mine?

Why don't you think chaqa's wagon happened "naturally?"

[Durga]

Wait wait wait. Does mafia have a roleblock?

[Durga]

Woooow I'm reading the roles now and it's actually so shit for mafia to lose their best role without using it hahahaha there's no way this role was bussed