MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[summit_fever]

Leave it to webdip for everybody to drunk post on the weekdays.

Not me this time

Durga, if you're still around can you read Worcej's end of day 2? Is that as bad as it looks?

[TrPrado]

The way he's pushing people is giving me a strong vibe that's he's just making things up and/or going for low hanging fruit like "emc NEVER votes this early in the day!!"

Holy shit! You're prescient. Probably the improper use of the word, but you nailed it.

That was some fast, fast work to end the day.

Fast?

[TrPrado]

This is not how townslips work

What do you mean?

Scum would be paying way more attention. Someone just coming in and voting for someone who left the game has to be town

Not sure why there's a wagon on me, but I'm heading out. Kill scum EMC pls

This post is very interesting now.

What do you consider interesting about it?

[seth24c]

What do you mean?

Scum would be paying way more attention. Someone just coming in and voting for someone who left the game has to be town

Not sure why there's a wagon on me, but I'm heading out. Kill scum EMC pls

This post is very interesting now.

What do you find interesting about it?

I'm not too sure why Chaqa decided to come to my defense. I would think, and I'll have to look at the time of post compared to vote record on the bot, that if the wagon started to swing to them, they would have tried to push more on me.

Well I was probably overstating it when I said very interesting. It’s another post of his to analyze to see what he was trying to accomplish. He does appear to be defending you at this point even thought he ends up voting you near the end to save himself. As with many of the rest of his posts he also tried to push emc as a wagon. That’s confusing to me that the emc push is such a common thread in his posts. I know emc said they are buddies but doesn’t there have to be more to it?

[seth24c]

What do you mean?

Scum would be paying way more attention. Someone just coming in and voting for someone who left the game has to be town

Not sure why there's a wagon on me, but I'm heading out. Kill scum EMC pls

This post is very interesting now.

What do you consider interesting about it?

See my post responding to HB.

[TrPrado]

Well that was a great turnout! Even when I went to bed I was feeling hopeful, and I was right! And chaqa... was chaqa. That's a very Chaqa thing to do. I'm a little annoyed that flash was outed, as we all are, but I can see where he's coming from, he was in a tough position at the end there and wanted to ensure his safety. And I have no clue why the heck yoyo came back, as is the case for the GMs apparently. I am the officially sanctioned player though, so ignore him and devote all your attention to me. When I'm active that is, I'll be out for a large chunk of the day and don't really be active again until about the same time I subbed yesterday.

Okay! I will devote my attention by asking you if you have any substantive thoughts about any of the players in the game.

[damo666]

So would tonight be a good one for the Desperado to act? WHo, out of this bunch, might be the best player to visit?

Durga TrPrado e.m.c^42 bozotheclown damo666 Foxcastle seth24c rdrivera2005

These were the other players on the Chaqa wagon aside from Vecna (1st vote) and Summit (2nd vote). Flash was in that list of players who voted for Chaqa but they are presumably town.

Or is it too early for the Desperado?

Why are you speculating what the Desperado might do (if they exist) and why are you limiting it to Chaqa voters?

[rdrivera2005]

Leave it to webdip for everybody to drunk post on the weekdays.

Not me this time

Durga, if you're still around can you read Worcej's end of day 2? Is that as bad as it looks?

Considering only the VCA, three people could have tried to save Chaqa: Fox, me and Worcej. I know I didn't. Fox looks a bit better because he was voting Flash earlier. Worcej looks the worst
The question is: scum would try to save Chaqa or not? If I was scum I would probably just stay away, so this is another good place to look, people who just freeze when Chaqa wagon get going.

[damo666]

This is where I'm at (and also is a summary for self)

Bis (emc) Emcs last few posts have swung this slot to weak town
Bozo medium town , seems to have gone a bit quiet
Bo unsure, pushing me soo weaktown
Durga beginning to think I was wrong - null+
Flash was townleaning, Vecna has pushed this to null
Fox strong town
Ghug medium strong town
HB the newby card becoming tiresome, 3p?
Rdr medium town (but he's good at seeming that) , treat with caution
Sarah (Chaqa) - insufficient data
Seth obvtown
Summit unsure, weaktown?
TrPrado dunno
Vecna obvtown
Worcej strong opening but not followed up, really dunno
Yoyo hope he flips scum

Updates following EOD2

EMC => probtown
Bozo remains medium town
Bo remains weaktown
Durga => strong town
Flash assume town
Fox still probtown but not quite as strong
Ghug plummets to null at best
HB not Mafia, vague 3p suspicion lingers
rdr down to null at best, scum possibility
Seth beginning to worry a bit about this slot, maybe weaktown rather than null
Summit => medium town
TrPrado => strong town
Vecna still town but slightly less obv
Worcej could be scum
Yoyo (bob) => null

I'd say the 4 remaining scum are within rdr, worcej, ghug, HB, seth, Bob, bo

[Vecna]

Leave it to webdip for everybody to drunk post on the weekdays.

Not me this time

Durga, if you're still around can you read Worcej's end of day 2? Is that as bad as it looks?

:)

[damo666]

The following slots have unfavourable voting both days

Bob
Bo
ghug
Ham
Worcej

[Vecna]

This is where I'm at (and also is a summary for self)

Bis (emc) Emcs last few posts have swung this slot to weak town
Bozo medium town , seems to have gone a bit quiet
Bo unsure, pushing me soo weaktown
Durga beginning to think I was wrong - null+
Flash was townleaning, Vecna has pushed this to null
Fox strong town
Ghug medium strong town
HB the newby card becoming tiresome, 3p?
Rdr medium town (but he's good at seeming that) , treat with caution
Sarah (Chaqa) - insufficient data
Seth obvtown
Summit unsure, weaktown?
TrPrado dunno
Vecna obvtown
Worcej strong opening but not followed up, really dunno
Yoyo hope he flips scum

Updates following EOD2

EMC => probtown
Bozo remains medium town
Bo remains weaktown
Durga => strong town
Flash assume town
Fox still probtown but not quite as strong
Ghug plummets to null at best
HB not Mafia, vague 3p suspicion lingers
rdr down to null at best, scum possibility
Seth beginning to worry a bit about this slot, maybe weaktown rather than null
Summit => medium town
TrPrado => strong town
Vecna still town but slightly less obv
Worcej could be scum
Yoyo (bob) => null

I'd say the 4 remaining scum are within rdr, worcej, ghug, HB, seth, Bob, bo

im "slightly less obv"?

Yeah, im gonna need that explanation

Also, how is flash not obvious? Why would he fakeclaim when he is up against a teammate (and their strongest role at that)

[Vecna]

Anyways, I propose we fully make the assumption that were playing against the witch, and play as such. I have a feeling were going to dumpster the mafia, but might have an uphill battle in finding the 3p before it is too late. 2 Pr's are dead (sorry flash), so if were facing the witch itll be sort of a race to find them before the remaining 4 PR's are revealed.

The PR's that might die if using their role: Complete holster for now, unless you really feel that you'll be up for lynch tomorrow due to your voting record/play today.

The other 2: Just keep hidden and gather results. No outing it for a while, please.

[damo666]

@vecna yes Flash is obvtown (I said assume which I thought stronger).

I weakened yours because I thought durga had a valid query oo you near eod2 however your most recent post is pretty strongtown EXCEPT you seem to be claiming VT thus narrowing the NK pool for N3 and beyond (unless you're bluffing, don't reveal!)

[Vecna]

what query?

[damo666]

Vecna why didyou vote chaqa and disappear. Why aren't you interested in pushing him more?

@vecna this

[damo666]

Also @Becca iyo is there anyone you think I can eliminate from my list of 7 possible scum? Anyone I sould have included and haven't?

[damo666]

Bloody phone.

Becca = Vecna

Sorry

[rdrivera2005]

Also @Becca iyo is there anyone you think I can eliminate from my list of 7 possible scum? Anyone I sould have included and haven't?

Why you didn't include Fox and Bozo?

[Vecna]

Vecna why didyou vote chaqa and disappear. Why aren't you interested in pushing him more?

@vecna this

And what happened after that?