MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

And WHY did you randomly vote EMC

[summit_fever]

##vote chaqa

[Durga]

##vote chaqa

[summit_fever]

EMC is doing okay, if you want votes on him you're going to have to scum him, not bring up his reliability.

[Durga]

EMC is doing okay, if you want votes on him you're going to have to scum him, not bring up his reliability.

Also tell me why he votes emc NOW after I told him like an hour ago to make a case on his scum read instead of voting lazily someone he didn't scum read.

[Foxcastle]

Why Chaqa?

[seth24c]

I'm so sick of wavering, but I like Hamilton's day 2 iso, until:

##Vote Seth

Basing that vote on:
a) the apology post where Seth claims they got nervous from all the talk about the Bis wagon;
b) claim to being overwhelmed at the vote and being the deciding vote (why should that matter?);
c) reiterating the feeling of being "overwhelmed" in several posts; the decision to put a vote on Bis to, and I'm paraphrasing, "bring them into the game." The multiple apologizing seems trying to stretch the appearance of town too far.
d) protesting; Paraphrasing again, "I am not scum."

I don't like the case at all, but would scum!brian try to build a case on someone that nobody else is scumreading? There's no influence from anybody else in this vote. Would scumchat recommend he do that?

I just want to point out here that HB's post trying to build a case on me being scum was before I came back and posted and everyone started town reading me. Maybe he thought it was a good chance to make a push on a suspicious town player?

If seth were scum I don't think he'd be trying to build Mt. Everest in the thread. Especially without using the bot.

Probably not, unless scum team is on him to make it look good. No one's moved on to that wagon so they're safe as of now.

Does anybody understand this post?
[/quote]

Not sure what to think about this one.

[Durga]

I would like a bit more consolidation.

[Foxcastle]

A lot more consolidation, actually. ##VOTE FLASH

[TrPrado]

Right, but EMC has *VOTED* so early.

He wouldn't do this unless he was extremely motivated to stay alive, so he's scummy.

??? How does this mean emc is "extremely" motivated to stay alive?

The dude has never voted before just at EoD and has been modkilled several times for not voting. Trust me, this is out of character for him

But in a scum indicative way? The only pressure on him is your current vote, he has not been in danger all day, what do you mean by him being extremely motivated to stay alive?

[TrPrado]

##VOTE CHAQA I am fine with this

[summit_fever]

not many are around...

of HB/flash/Chaq I prefer chaqa.

[summit_fever]

Why Chaqa?

He had a blank slate with sarah's slot and really hasn't done much of anything. I know he doesn't have time but why just bash on emc when emc has brought something to the table?

[ghug]

Why'd people sour on HB? What's the argument for Chaqa?

[Foxcastle]

Why Chaqa?

He had a blank slate with sarah's slot and really hasn't done much of anything. I know he doesn't have time but why just bash on emc when emc has brought something to the table?

It seemed like you were more strongly scumreading worcej and Yoyo/Bob, and now this is your vote with 20 minutes to go?

[Durga]

Why Chaqa?

He had a blank slate with sarah's slot and really hasn't done much of anything. I know he doesn't have time but why just bash on emc when emc has brought something to the table?

It seemed like you were more strongly scumreading worcej and Yoyo/Bob, and now this is your vote with 20 minutes to go?

Yo Chaqa is probably scum. Who calls what HB said a townslip unless you know he's town?? that was so awkward

[summit_fever]

Why'd people sour on HB? What's the argument for Chaqa?

His iso is okay. I like the way he went in for a scumread that didn't agree with other people and tried to produce a case.

I'd be scumming him on a short post welcoming a sub into the game.

[Durga]

Vecna why didyou vote chaqa and disappear. Why aren't you interested in pushing him more?

[summit_fever]

Why Chaqa?

He had a blank slate with sarah's slot and really hasn't done much of anything. I know he doesn't have time but why just bash on emc when emc has brought something to the table?

It seemed like you were more strongly scumreading worcej and Yoyo/Bob, and now this is your vote with 20 minutes to go?

I can vote for worcej. I thought his start of day was good but he just dropped off again. Dude's got a young child though... If people want to consolidate on worcej I'll join.

[seth24c]

Why'd people sour on HB? What's the argument for Chaqa?

His iso is okay. I like the way he went in for a scumread that didn't agree with other people and tried to produce a case.

I'd be scumming him on a short post welcoming a sub into the game.

But at the time it did agree with other people. He posted that before people started town reading me. That wagon disappearing is super suspicious to me.