MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

Ghug at least tried to defend his Bunny vote...it feels like Vecna is just flailing around to create mis-kills. Vecna is scum this game.

The fact that Vecna is on your wagon right now makes me feel like you're right. I don't really get why he's voting you when he's had this weird hard on for rdr - I can't recall Vecna voting lurkers so much but my memory is also shit.

The other issue is that whenever Vecna posts I think "damn that's townie"

But his actions are really meh to me. Him voting you bc you've posted 4 times is meh to me.

You really are characterizing my reasoning in a way that I do not approve of.

Sorry, why are you voting flash then?

[ghug]

Agh I miss xorxes I just want to sheep someone smarter than me ((

Hi

Maybe in a lot of things but I'm afraid mafia is not one of them ghuggles

You leave for a year and nobody respects you anymore

[flash2015]

Yoyo’s wagon looks super scummy to me. Maybe he’s not scum. Or at least maybe Yoyo and Worcej aren’t scum together.

I agree that Yoyo's wagon looks sketchy...

[rdrivera2005]

Yoyo’s wagon looks super scummy to me. Maybe he’s not scum. Or at least maybe Yoyo and Worcej aren’t scum together.

I agree that Yoyo's wagon looks sketchy...

Who do you think is scum in Yoyo wagon?

[rdrivera2005]

Yoyo’s wagon looks super scummy to me. Maybe he’s not scum. Or at least maybe Yoyo and Worcej aren’t scum together.

I agree that Yoyo's wagon looks sketchy...

Who do you think is scum in Yoyo wagon?

Actually Bob wagon.

[Vecna]

Hi

Maybe in a lot of things but I'm afraid mafia is not one of them ghuggles

You leave for a year and nobody respects you anymore

I think you have some interesting rose-tinted glasses there about how we respected you before Ghuggles

[ghug]

Maybe in a lot of things but I'm afraid mafia is not one of them ghuggles

You leave for a year and nobody respects you anymore

I think you have some interesting rose-tinted glasses there about how we respected you before Ghuggles

Yeah but I didn't care when I was routinely winning games.

Flum still respects me and he's the GOAT, so I'll fall back on that.

[ghug]

I agree that Yoyo's wagon looks sketchy...

Who do you think is scum in Yoyo wagon?

Actually Bob wagon.

Worth noting that the bot is going to be pretty confusing if more people start voting Bob.

[seth24c]

From what I've read of ghug, venca, and worcej so far I would feel relatively comfortable voting for any of them. For now I will ##vote ghug since he is the one who gave me the bot link. Thanks

So this is largely because you believe there must be at least one scum on the Bunny wagon? So your ghug vote is completely a random choice from the three?

Well not completely at random. I had a weird feeling about ghug and venca both on day one. Still hasn’t completely gone away. Worcej I just can’t seem to read at all so I’m like I said I really want to see more from all three. I voted ghug because I felt I had the strongest scum feeling of him out of all three. Still strongly feel that either ghug or vecna one is scum. But my feeling that it’s more likely to be ghug is somewhat shifting. I need to go back and read vecna.

[Durga]

You leave for a year and nobody respects you anymore

I think you have some interesting rose-tinted glasses there about how we respected you before Ghuggles

Yeah but I didn't care when I was routinely winning games.

Flum still respects me and he's the GOAT, so I'll fall back on that.

I don't even know who you scum read here

[flash2015]

Who specifically looks scummy on it?

AKA would you like to vote for Prado with me?


@Prado since you're so fond at harping on people who don't directly answer your questions: you still haven't given me your thoughts on other people.

I really want to vote summit, but I would be fine seeing what happens if TrPrado gets in the running.

##VOTE TRPRADO

Was this anything more than a gut feel? I saw you put TrPrado in your scum bucket early on...but you haven't elaborated.

[bozotheclown]

EoD was really darn empty. I'm surprised. Was it because everybody thought it was an hour later? Regardless, I'm still struggling to work out who to vote for. Out of the closest wagons to me, I think there's a better case for flash than Tr, flash has been pretty absent and vague. (I mean yes you could argue I'm the same, but I just subbed off the back of someone who'd been missing for liket hree days, and I haven't had much time to read. I'll be back with a good bit more tomorrow if I'm still alive, promise). I'm not a huuuge fan of the flash wagon but I don't have anyone better to vote for and a decent chance of hitting scum or at worst a lurker is better than guaranteed town as far as I'm concerned.

Something doesn't stand well here. 3rd vote on the wagon, then it's the lead.

##unvote

You are the one who put flash's wagon in the lead, what has changed?

[Durga]

How many miskills before it's game over for us?

[Vecna]

The fact that Vecna is on your wagon right now makes me feel like you're right. I don't really get why he's voting you when he's had this weird hard on for rdr - I can't recall Vecna voting lurkers so much but my memory is also shit.

The other issue is that whenever Vecna posts I think "damn that's townie"

But his actions are really meh to me. Him voting you bc you've posted 4 times is meh to me.

You really are characterizing my reasoning in a way that I do not approve of.

Sorry, why are you voting flash then?

I believe he's randomly just quoting stuff from a stretch of page 60-64, to appear to be participating and being active. There is no coherence, just to show us he is "caught up".

In those few posts he first sheeps Fox, saying he can go along with the meta wagon. Then the next post he asks Worcej for advice. Then the next post he sheeps Worcej's overdefensive attack on me.

He votes. He vanishes. But not before letting us know he is fully caught up.

But go ahead. Quiz him on stuff that happened this game. See if he actually has coherent reads. Prove me wrong if im so wrong, dont just judge the wagon because its "on a lurker". The lowest posters always have scum in them

[bozotheclown]

behold, a wild flash wagon has already appeared

Yes, that was my point, that most of the votes are now on low information slots.

Bozo, as you seems to be around and catch up, could you comment on Prado post about you townreading Yoyo for something he didn't do? (page 73, hard to quote on the cell).

i think you misinterpreted what TrPrado said and the quotes he included. Yoyoyozo was criticizing me for suggesting a mass claim could be beneficial, but he argued in favor of the hypo claims, and he was the one to specifically suggest it for the Weak Doctor.

[Durga]

You really are characterizing my reasoning in a way that I do not approve of.

Sorry, why are you voting flash then?

I believe he's randomly just quoting stuff from a stretch of page 60-64, to appear to be participating and being active. There is no coherence, just to show us he is "caught up".

In those few posts he first sheeps Fox, saying he can go along with the meta wagon. Then the next post he asks Worcej for advice. Then the next post he sheeps Worcej's overdefensive attack on me.

He votes. He vanishes. But not before letting us know he is fully caught up.

But go ahead. Quiz him on stuff that happened this game. See if he actually has coherent reads. Prove me wrong if im so wrong, dont just judge the wagon because its "on a lurker". The lowest posters always have scum in them

This is better. All I remembered was you saying he only posted 4 times.

@flash - thoughts on this?

[Vecna]

And now that the wagon of him gathers steam he magically appears again, and does the same "look im catching up thing".

And apparently im flailing just to get mislynches.

[Hamilton Brian]

EoD was really darn empty. I'm surprised. Was it because everybody thought it was an hour later? Regardless, I'm still struggling to work out who to vote for. Out of the closest wagons to me, I think there's a better case for flash than Tr, flash has been pretty absent and vague. (I mean yes you could argue I'm the same, but I just subbed off the back of someone who'd been missing for liket hree days, and I haven't had much time to read. I'll be back with a good bit more tomorrow if I'm still alive, promise). I'm not a huuuge fan of the flash wagon but I don't have anyone better to vote for and a decent chance of hitting scum or at worst a lurker is better than guaranteed town as far as I'm concerned.

Something doesn't stand well here. 3rd vote on the wagon, then it's the lead.

##unvote

You are the one who put flash's wagon in the lead, what has changed?

Just contrasting my original read of flash to re-reading Bob's vote. Don't like it.

[bozotheclown]

Yes, that was my point, that most of the votes are now on low information slots.

Bozo, as you seems to be around and catch up, could you comment on Prado post about you townreading Yoyo for something he didn't do? (page 73, hard to quote on the cell).

or scumreading me for something I didnt do, and commented on like 3 times, while you keep repeating the same argument...

What didn't you do?

[ghug]

I think you have some interesting rose-tinted glasses there about how we respected you before Ghuggles

Yeah but I didn't care when I was routinely winning games.

Flum still respects me and he's the GOAT, so I'll fall back on that.

I don't even know who you scum read here

Prado, Brian, kinda worcej, probably at least one of Vecna/bo/bozo. Feels like Yoyo's replacement triggered a lot of movement to flash, either because someone saw an opportunity to save him or because they thought pressure was going to drop off and wanted a new wagon to push.