MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

I would like to think I'm this good, but everyone else would say otherwise ;p

This good as scum? Are you trying to tell me something

Considering I've been gone and done jack shit so far, yeah, I'm kind of wondering what you're basing the read off of :D

Which post(s) caused it, and why?

Honestly I think the bar is really low and you’re not lurking and I’m impressed by that

[ghug]

I’m getting tired of you dismissing me by saying you’re getting tired. I knew you’d point that out. But I feel like you usually have stronger reads you harp on. Like one or two people you tend to pick on. Don’t fault me for trying to find scum - why are you so sure I’m town anyway

Also Literally no one is scum reading you so why are you so sensitive about like the three comments I’ve made @ you

I'm at least lightly scum reading ghug. I can't put my finger on it completely but day one landing on bunny with a goodnight vote then never moving calls for a deeper look. Especially since he was also getting on people for voting for Bismarck for no perceived reason.

Went back and read and it was a meeting vote not a goodnight vote for the record.

I had been jokevoting bo and wanted my vote back on my actual scumread before I left.

[ghug]

This good as scum? Are you trying to tell me something

Considering I've been gone and done jack shit so far, yeah, I'm kind of wondering what you're basing the read off of :D

Which post(s) caused it, and why?

Honestly I think the bar is really low and you’re not lurking and I’m impressed by that

Why can't you treat me like this?

[seth24c]

I'm at least lightly scum reading ghug. I can't put my finger on it completely but day one landing on bunny with a goodnight vote then never moving calls for a deeper look. Especially since he was also getting on people for voting for Bismarck for no perceived reason.

Went back and read and it was a meeting vote not a goodnight vote for the record.

I had been jokevoting bo and wanted my vote back on my actual scumread before I left.

So you hit your biggest scumread with this vote on page 10?

##VOTE bunny for disappearing after his godawful start

[Durga]

Considering I've been gone and done jack shit so far, yeah, I'm kind of wondering what you're basing the read off of :D

Which post(s) caused it, and why?

Honestly I think the bar is really low and you’re not lurking and I’m impressed by that

Why can't you treat me like this?

Okay fine. Calm down, a bit of pressure from me isn’t going to get you auto killed.

I will ignore you for now.

[ghug]

Went back and read and it was a meeting vote not a goodnight vote for the record.

I had been jokevoting bo and wanted my vote back on my actual scumread before I left.

So you hit your biggest scumread with this vote on page 10?

##VOTE bunny for disappearing after his godawful start

Yep

[seth24c]

I had been jokevoting bo and wanted my vote back on my actual scumread before I left.

So you hit your biggest scumread with this vote on page 10?

##VOTE bunny for disappearing after his godawful start

Yep

So do you believe there was scum on bunny's wagon?

[ghug]

So you hit your biggest scumread with this vote on page 10?

Yep

So do you believe there was scum on bunny's wagon?

If it was really town v town, which I think is probably the most likely at this point, I'd expect one or two scum to be on the two main wagons and the rest fucking off on the side, especially since I townread Durga and damo, who are the only people I can see really being saved by the main wagons. I don't share your opinion that scum are more likely to have been on Bunny than Bismarck.

[e.m.c^42]

Alright, something came up, I will be back in 8 hours, just missing 4 or so pages until caught up.

Summit seems town but more...succinctly bland. Haven't seen any of his clever observations yet, but it's possible I've just missed it.

Damo went from his usual calm manner to rather pissed, but overall I don't think it's something that holds up for any sort of scumread.

Vecna is oddly chipper, and haven't a clue whether it's because certain old players are back or what else. Might be testing something, almost certainly is implying some shit but I'm too oblivious to see lol

[seth24c]

Yep

So do you believe there was scum on bunny's wagon?

If it was really town v town, which I think is probably the most likely at this point, I'd expect one or two scum to be on the two main wagons and the rest fucking off on the side, especially since I townread Durga and damo, who are the only people I can see really being saved by the main wagons. I don't share your opinion that scum are more likely to have been on Bunny than Bismarck.

I agree that it seems at this point to have probably been town v town and I also agree with the potential for 1-2 scum on the leading wagons. I also townread durga and damo. Which is interesting because the first vote on the bis wagon was bunny (who later moved his vote elsewhere), second was damo who I also townread, third was flash to make it 4 bunny v 3 bis (no reason for scum to do this right?, forth was bozo (another one who I townread) to make it a leading wagon, and fifth was summit, and then myself.

I don't see a reason any of those players (aside from maybe flash) would be jumping on the Bismarck wagon as scum since the bunny wagon was already in full swing. It is very possible I may be missing something but I feel much more confident of finding scum on the bunny wagon.

[ghug]

So do you believe there was scum on bunny's wagon?

If it was really town v town, which I think is probably the most likely at this point, I'd expect one or two scum to be on the two main wagons and the rest fucking off on the side, especially since I townread Durga and damo, who are the only people I can see really being saved by the main wagons. I don't share your opinion that scum are more likely to have been on Bunny than Bismarck.

I agree that it seems at this point to have probably been town v town and I also agree with the potential for 1-2 scum on the leading wagons. I also townread durga and damo. Which is interesting because the first vote on the bis wagon was bunny (who later moved his vote elsewhere), second was damo who I also townread, third was flash to make it 4 bunny v 3 bis (no reason for scum to do this right?, forth was bozo (another one who I townread) to make it a leading wagon, and fifth was summit, and then myself.

I don't see a reason any of those players (aside from maybe flash) would be jumping on the Bismarck wagon as scum since the bunny wagon was already in full swing. It is very possible I may be missing something but I feel much more confident of finding scum on the bunny wagon.

Why would players be more inclined to join the bunny wagon than the Bismarck wagon?

I think if scum aren't feeling pressure to make something specific happen, they'll a) distance from their teammates and b) try to imitate town behavior. I don't see any reason flash or bozo wouldn't have voted Bismarck there as scum, and the rest I townread for independent reasons.

[ghug]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

[seth24c]

If it was really town v town, which I think is probably the most likely at this point, I'd expect one or two scum to be on the two main wagons and the rest fucking off on the side, especially since I townread Durga and damo, who are the only people I can see really being saved by the main wagons. I don't share your opinion that scum are more likely to have been on Bunny than Bismarck.

I agree that it seems at this point to have probably been town v town and I also agree with the potential for 1-2 scum on the leading wagons. I also townread durga and damo. Which is interesting because the first vote on the bis wagon was bunny (who later moved his vote elsewhere), second was damo who I also townread, third was flash to make it 4 bunny v 3 bis (no reason for scum to do this right?, forth was bozo (another one who I townread) to make it a leading wagon, and fifth was summit, and then myself.

I don't see a reason any of those players (aside from maybe flash) would be jumping on the Bismarck wagon as scum since the bunny wagon was already in full swing. It is very possible I may be missing something but I feel much more confident of finding scum on the bunny wagon.

Why would players be more inclined to join the bunny wagon than the Bismarck wagon?

I think if scum aren't feeling pressure to make something specific happen, they'll a) distance from their teammates and b) try to imitate town behavior. I don't see any reason flash or bozo wouldn't have voted Bismarck there as scum, and the rest I townread for independent reasons.

I will concede that it is possible that one of flash or bozo could have been scum who were distancing from their teammates and they didn't expect the bis wagon to grow to lead. But I still don't think that scum would have intentionally pushed the bis wagon into the lead on day one to draw attention to themselves when the bunny wagon was already in the lead.

[seth24c]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

Rom Combadill?

[ghug]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

Rom Combadill?

Combadil*

[Durga]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

Rom Combadill?

It would be like FoxCastle scum tier

[seth24c]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

Rom Combadill?

Combadil*

Hmm still not ringing any bells for me.. I'm signing off for the night, talk to you all tomorrow!

[ghug]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

Rom Combadill?

It would be like FoxCastle scum tier

I was gonna say wjessop originally.

The common theme here is that they were all my teammates though, so Seth is probably town.

[seth24c]

If Seth is scum, this is the best noob performance since Rom Combadill.

Rom Combadill?

It would be like FoxCastle scum tier

So much I don’t completely understand since I don’t know the players lol. I think I understand the context now though, thank you!

[summit_fever]

You are reading Prado and myself as scum, so you read our interactions as scum vs scum. Do you really think we'd "make up" and then hop on the same leading wagon?

I think Prado has been coming from a town perspective, though I don't know their game at all. I don't see Rivera as scum at all. Maybe Durga, but I'm still okay townreading her.

I thought Durga's "woe-is-me won't I ever townread you summit?" to be a little much and perhaps scum-motivated.

Pls explain why

Some sort of pocketing manoeuvre. Or just the booze.