MAFIA LVIII (58) - WITCHFINDER GENERAL - GAME THREAD

[ghug]

##VOTE bo

It's important that people actually comply.

[bo_sox48]

Lol this is some juvenile shit

Anyone want to say something helpful like a page number I should be referring to or am I just gonna get railroaded for not knowing what you're talking about? If that's the case, I'll just see you guys some other time and we can chalk this one up as one of those "town is fucked" kinda games

[ghug]

Lol this is some juvenile shit

Anyone want to say something helpful like a page number I should be referring to or am I just gonna get railroaded for not knowing what you're talking about? If that's the case, I'll just see you guys some other time and we can chalk this one up as one of those "town is fucked" kinda games

Have you read the beginning of the game?

[bo_sox48]

Presumably once I comply with whatever this crap is you'll all go and policy someone else that hasn't complied with whatever this crap is and have no greater odds of hitting scum than if you flipped a coin, and the data will be wasted regardless, so either way this is probably one of those "town is fucked" kinda games lol

[bo_sox48]

Lol this is some juvenile shit

Anyone want to say something helpful like a page number I should be referring to or am I just gonna get railroaded for not knowing what you're talking about? If that's the case, I'll just see you guys some other time and we can chalk this one up as one of those "town is fucked" kinda games

Have you read the beginning of the game?

I've read from about page 15 on. I literally never read the beginning of a game.

[bo_sox48]

My role is in the list of Town Roles.

Please all post the above.

Is this what we're talking about?

Really lmao

[rdrivera2005]

Presumably once I comply with whatever this crap is you'll all go and policy someone else that hasn't complied with whatever this crap is and have no greater odds of hitting scum than if you flipped a coin, and the data will be wasted regardless, so either way this is probably one of those "town is fucked" kinda games lol

Just post:

I win when Mafia and Third Party are defeated.

And stop derailing the thread.

[rdrivera2005]

And I am starting to scumread Ghug after this exchange with bo . It's like he want to hit some trigger on Bo side, which doesn't look a towny thing to do at this point.

[dargorygel]

Vote Count 1.8
BismarckAlive (3) Damo, flash,bozo
Damo666 (3) bismarck, bo, durga
Durga (2) foxy, yoyo
BunnyGo (2) worcej, vecna
Yoyoyozo (2) Prado, rdr
Bo_sox48 (2) Bunnywent, ghug

If the day ended right now, BismarckAlive would no longer be alive.

Non Voters (WHO ARE IN DANGER OF BEING MODKILLED… and hurting the game… )
Hamilton Brian, Hellenic Riot, SarahK24, seth24c, summit_fever

Non Posters (or those who have not posted the minimum amount)
SarahK24, BismarckAlive

An hour and a half and 2 minutes left in today’s day.

[dargorygel]

Vote Count 1.8
BismarckAlive (3) Damo, flash,bozo
Damo666 (3) bismarck, bo, durga
Durga (2) foxy, yoyo
BunnyGo (2) worcej, vecna
Yoyoyozo (2) Prado, rdr
Bo_sox48 (2) Bunnywent, ghug

If the day ended right now, BismarckAlive would no longer be alive.

Non Voters (WHO ARE IN DANGER OF BEING MODKILLED… and hurting the game… )
Hamilton Brian, Hellenic Riot, SarahK24, seth24c, summit_fever

Non Posters (or those who have not posted the minimum amount)
SarahK24, BismarckAlive

An hour and a half and 2 minutes left in today’s day.

This is wrong... hold on

[dargorygel]

Vote Count 1.8
BismarckAlive (3) Damo, flash,bozo
Damo666 (3) bismarck, bo, durga
Durga (2) foxy, yoyo
BunnyGo (2) worcej, vecna
Yoyoyozo (2) Prado, rdr
Bo_sox48 (2) Bunnywent, ghug

If the day ended right now, no one would be daykilled.

Non Voters (WHO ARE IN DANGER OF BEING MODKILLED… and hurting the game… )
Hamilton Brian, Hellenic Riot, SarahK24, seth24c, summit_fever

Non Posters (or those who have not posted the minimum amount)
SarahK24, BismarckAlive

An hour and a half and 2 minutes left in today’s day.

[bo_sox48]

Oh, this is some mechanics bs. Got it.

I solemnly swear upon my mother's and my father's grave, the King James Bible, and all things that are holy that my role is in the list of town roles.

This is hilarious, thank you all for the laugh. I'm going back to work now.

[ghug]

Oh, this is some mechanics bs. Got it.

I solemnly swear upon my mother's and my father's grave, the King James Bible, and all things that are holy that my role is in the list of town roles.

This is hilarious, thank you all for the laugh. I'm going back to work now.

The one Rd listed please

[Durga]

What's with bo, why is he so upset by this

[bo_sox48]

Because being railroaded for not knowing what happened on page 1 is a new experience for me and I'm not a fan of it, especially when it completely detracts from other people doing scummy things.

I win when Mafia and Third Party are defeated.

Can we carry on or do I need to call my lawyer?

[ghug]

Cool. Since we're all here,anyone wanna kill bo for fun now?

[ghug]

And I am starting to scumread Ghug after this exchange with bo . It's like he want to hit some trigger on Bo side, which doesn't look a towny thing to do at this point.

Triggering people is good for town.

[Durga]

Cool. Since we're all here,anyone wanna kill bo for fun now?

Is angry!bo also scum!bo? What was he like in the last game?

[summit_fever]

In previous games, Worcej has been acerbic and hostile, even agreeing that he's playing like an asshole. In those games, he's been town. In a recent game when he didn't play that way, he was scum who managed to make it to the win in no small part because of his newfound congeniality. It's just 20 posts so far this game, but he hasn't abused or derided anyone enough for me to think it's town-worcej.

The issue I take with that is that it sets up such easy meta for worcej to follow. I don't think anyone legitimately sticks to the exact same meta that we claim to have on them as town or scum every single game; in fact, I can think of very few people who obviously indicate one way or another unintentionally.

What game was super nice worcej? I'm pretty sure he's always nice to me, but that's just because I've made him my minion. He thinks of me what I want him to think of me.

Bo failed to respond to Fox's second paragraph where Fox misremembered Ghug as scum in M57 (which would have been alongside Bo and Fox, who were both scum). Not sure if scum!bo would be so willing to ignore that.

[TrPrado]

Not liking the way Yoyo has interacted with some people, pretty sus, ##VOTE YOYO I will come back tomorrow to see if I still feel this way.

But arguing about which way of saying "I am town" is most viable when and how he did is kind of silly and feels like beating down dissent for the sake of looking helpful and pro-town.

This literally never happened lol. Please quote me where I agree which way of saying “I am town” is most viable

Sure

I also feel like the original statement would work, since the mafia lie detector saying their role is listed under town roles would be made in bad faith and knowingly inserts an untruth.

Lol this is the funniest post I’ve ever read in my memory of playing mafia. Especially if you’re being serious. I think it’s a pretty tricky thing and definitely would come back from the GM as a true statement, since they would know that their role is under both lists, it would not be a lie to say that it falls under one.

This is what caught my attention specifically in the context of:

My role is in the list of Town Roles.

I town read BunnyGo for that. Pretty creative way to not give potential mafia lie detector info while giving the possible town lie detector a way to become cop

You treating the original statement as praiseworthy. You went on to treat the statement has having obvious glaring holes and the way you present that and respond to someone saying it's fine makes it feel weird and unnatural for you not to have brought it up in the first place. This feels like more of an optics game than actually trying to be helpful or useful.