Mafia 56: Scout Camp

[e.m.c^42]

For some reason I keep on feeling like xorxes hasn't really pushed or poked anyone this game. Does anyone else feel this or is this because I've only skimmed quickly most of D2

Did you manage to miss the two or three pages we went against each other?

Quite possibly! I shall go reread now before I say more odd things lol

[xorxes]

Remaining players:

PR
BismarckAlive
Jamiet99uk
e.m.c^42
flash2015
JF1981
TheFlyingBoat
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

VT
BobMcBob
bozotheclown
brainbomb
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

1 scum among PRs, 1 scum among VTs, 1 scum in either list.

The obvious choices for the Senior Patrol Leader are one of bozo/brain/worcej/emc, just so their action has a result that can be published without compromising more pairs. Probably the VTs rather than the PRs. The only con against scanning bozo/brain is that I already think they are both town, but not everyone seems to agree. Obviously don't scan TFB because they don't have a buddy yet.

That would leave:
BobMcBob
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

for Scoutmaster and cool guys (if these have a scan left). Someone should divide these six giving for example four to the scoutmaster and two to the cool guys. I think Vecna (once he sobers up) should do the division, given that nobody scumreads him. That way we don't accidentally scan the same people twice.

That's my suggestion anyway. Other ideas welcome.

[xorxes]

Remaining players:

PR
BismarckAlive
Jamiet99uk
e.m.c^42
flash2015
JF1981
TheFlyingBoat
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

VT
BobMcBob
bozotheclown
brainbomb
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

1 scum among PRs, 1 scum among VTs, 1 scum in either list.

The obvious choices for the Senior Patrol Leader are one of bozo/brain/worcej/emc, just so their action has a result that can be published without compromising more pairs. Probably the VTs rather than the PRs. The only con against scanning bozo/brain is that I already think they are both town, but not everyone seems to agree. Obviously don't scan TFB because they don't have a buddy yet.

That would leave:
BobMcBob
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

for Scoutmaster and cool guys (if these have a scan left). Someone should divide these six giving for example four to the scoutmaster and two to the cool guys. I think Vecna (once he sobers up) should do the division, given that nobody scumreads him. That way we don't accidentally scan the same people twice.

That's my suggestion anyway. Other ideas welcome.

Or maybe it is better not to coordinate anything, since that just gives scum a better chance of messing with the results. The risk of double-scanning should be pretty small anyway.

[brainbomb]

Nils Holgersson was a little boy who captured a Tomten and was cruel to it. So the tomten escaped and cursed Nils by making him very small. Nils had to flee his home and becomes a goose rider

[brainbomb]

its a Swedish childrens story I always loved. It was my way of telling vecna I enjoy him but I wanna turn him into a shrunken lil goose rider

[Jamiet99uk]

drinking in a pool

drinking at a wake

in a car

with the parents

while observing people fish

far away from home

and i got a medium sunburn

At a wake?

I am sorry. I hope it was a nice remembrance and I hope you're feeling okay.

[summit_fever]

drunk posting on laptop, so mucg better spelling than [hone

much understanding

##vote brainbomb

I vote this MVP or most valuable post

[summit_fever]

Getting a second PR and removing a potential scum?

Nervous?

no, just have my own opinion.
Summit may I ask why you believe Jamiet is not part of the scum team?

This is giving me such a strong Donny-summit-Jamie vibe.

zorkie has solved the cast we can all go home

[summit_fever]

Just a heads-up the bot didn't register donny dude's death.

Hope JF is resolved soon.

[Vecna]

waking up after sleeping only 4 hours sucks

[summit_fever]

ouch

[bozotheclown]

Remaining players:

PR
BismarckAlive
Jamiet99uk
e.m.c^42
flash2015
JF1981
TheFlyingBoat
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

VT
BobMcBob
bozotheclown
brainbomb
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

1 scum among PRs, 1 scum among VTs, 1 scum in either list.

The obvious choices for the Senior Patrol Leader are one of bozo/brain/worcej/emc, just so their action has a result that can be published without compromising more pairs. Probably the VTs rather than the PRs. The only con against scanning bozo/brain is that I already think they are both town, but not everyone seems to agree. Obviously don't scan TFB because they don't have a buddy yet.

That would leave:
BobMcBob
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

for Scoutmaster and cool guys (if these have a scan left). Someone should divide these six giving for example four to the scoutmaster and two to the cool guys. I think Vecna (once he sobers up) should do the division, given that nobody scumreads him. That way we don't accidentally scan the same people twice.

That's my suggestion anyway. Other ideas welcome.

My suggestion is that the PRs not coordinate anything, and definitely do not do what Vecna says. xorxes saying nobody scum reads Vecna is suspect, I do not think that is true about D2 just because no one who participated in the survey put him in their top 4, and xorxes has no idea how Donny's flip affected everyone's reads.

[bozotheclown]

The most important thing is that all PRs claim their exact role before N2 is over, even if it requires claiming before EON. Any PR that does not claim by EON is going to look highly suspect and therefore will be at risk of getting mislynched.

[bozotheclown]

I think Vecna and xorxes came out of D2 looking suspicious for arguing against the PRs claiming D2, they seemed to think a mislynch was worth the Scoutmaster potentially getting one more scan, which would have been a bad trade for town.

[damo666]

Remaining players:

PR
BismarckAlive
Jamiet99uk
e.m.c^42
flash2015
JF1981
TheFlyingBoat
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

VT
BobMcBob
bozotheclown
brainbomb
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

1 scum among PRs, 1 scum among VTs, 1 scum in either list.

The obvious choices for the Senior Patrol Leader are one of bozo/brain/worcej/emc, just so their action has a result that can be published without compromising more pairs. Probably the VTs rather than the PRs. The only con against scanning bozo/brain is that I already think they are both town, but not everyone seems to agree. Obviously don't scan TFB because they don't have a buddy yet.

That would leave:
BobMcBob
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

for Scoutmaster and cool guys (if these have a scan left). Someone should divide these six giving for example four to the scoutmaster and two to the cool guys. I think Vecna (once he sobers up) should do the division, given that nobody scumreads him. That way we don't accidentally scan the same people twice.

That's my suggestion anyway. Other ideas welcome.

Or maybe it is better not to coordinate anything, since that just gives scum a better chance of messing with the results. The risk of double-scanning should be pretty small anyway.

I think non coordination better.

I missed TFB being solo. How do we know? Donny partner or self declared? And also obviously don't scan Bob.

[damo666]

@Squigs what is story on JF please

[bozotheclown]

Im having thoughts. The fact scum killed the no reveal guy either means he was a PR, or they were desperate enough to kill a VT to make us all get suspicious.

It might also mean they have had a chat with the guy so they would be certain noone was told the role there in secret.

I think we can assume he was a PR and the scum NKed him because 2 scum claimed PR.

They could not know which PR he was, so that would have been a gamble.

I think it's just as likely that he was VT and they killed him so we would not know for sure that three scum claimed VT.

I don't think we need to speculate on this much more, but every PR should claim their role at EON2, before we have more unknown deaths, and then we will probably figure it out. Scoutmaster has to claim anyway and that's the most important role.

Why would it have been a gamble for mafia to have a PR role hidden? It is much better for them to have a PR role hidden from everyone than for all the PRs to be able to claim their role. One of the mafia can just claim last and claim the missing PR role, and the only reason to suspect him is that he claimed last. Also, if TRC was a VT, that means there were 3 scum in the VTs. If that was the case, do you really think it was just as likely scum would kill a VT?

[bozotheclown]

Remaining players:

PR
BismarckAlive
Jamiet99uk
e.m.c^42
flash2015
JF1981
TheFlyingBoat
Vecna
worcej
xorxes

VT
BobMcBob
bozotheclown
brainbomb
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

1 scum among PRs, 1 scum among VTs, 1 scum in either list.

The obvious choices for the Senior Patrol Leader are one of bozo/brain/worcej/emc, just so their action has a result that can be published without compromising more pairs. Probably the VTs rather than the PRs. The only con against scanning bozo/brain is that I already think they are both town, but not everyone seems to agree. Obviously don't scan TFB because they don't have a buddy yet.

That would leave:
BobMcBob
damo666
Durga
Hellenic Riot
rdrivera2005
summit_fever

for Scoutmaster and cool guys (if these have a scan left). Someone should divide these six giving for example four to the scoutmaster and two to the cool guys. I think Vecna (once he sobers up) should do the division, given that nobody scumreads him. That way we don't accidentally scan the same people twice.

That's my suggestion anyway. Other ideas welcome.

Or maybe it is better not to coordinate anything, since that just gives scum a better chance of messing with the results. The risk of double-scanning should be pretty small anyway.

I think non coordination better.

I missed TFB being solo. How do we know? Donny partner or self declared? And also obviously don't scan Bob.

Donny claimed it, we do not have confirmation from TFB.

[bozotheclown]

If one PR does not claim by EON, and D3 claims a role that is not accounted for, he should be lynched immediately.

[damo666]

I HAVE A GUILTY PN BRAINBOMB

This has been surprisingly undisclosed.

Do we believe it?

I do.