Mafia 56: Scout Camp

[xorxes]

Dont be encouraging anymore claims please xorxes, not until EoN2

I agree that's better.

[xorxes]

scums already down 1 guy, trading scoutmaster for another scum seems great to me

Why do that when we can chance 2 scum? If scoutmaster scans another guilty tonight, we can potentially find 2 scum. Unless the scoutmaster is set to be lynched or they know they won't be on at EoN, it's worth the wait.

To be clear I am advocating catching 2 scum today by just letting it all out the bag

Why not one today and two tomorrow?

[BobMcBob]

Which just happen to be the two roles scum are most likely to claim

Yes because each of those roles is not directly cc-able without exposing both of them.

That was my concern when Bozo was demanding roleclaims at night.

Guess maybe this was the problem with the mass claim system.

If only someone spent all of D1 pointing this out... Oh wait...

Hmm, nobody tried that. I wonder why not? It would've really helped, because nobody's stubborn enough to not listen to actual logic while pushing an agenda that is bad for town. Also ##Vote bozo

[brainbomb]

##vote rdrivera

[xorxes]

The second part of the mass claim was for the PRs to claim if any scum claimed PR. I believe the optimal time to do that is now.

xorxes: TCG
Vecna:
flash:
emc:
TFB:
Bismarck:
JF:
Jamie: FAE or TCG
worcej: FAE
TRC: ?

Why claiming now is better then claiming at EON? We should focus today on VTs.

That would require all PRs to be online at exactly EON. It is better to do it before N2 EON, so we might as well do it now.

Everyone knows when they will be able to be online. As long as they do it before EON there's no rush.

[BobMcBob]

scums already down 1 guy, trading scoutmaster for another scum seems great to me

Why do that when we can chance 2 scum? If scoutmaster scans another guilty tonight, we can potentially find 2 scum. Unless the scoutmaster is set to be lynched or they know they won't be on at EoN, it's worth the wait.

There's zero chance we lynch the scoutmaster today. We're lynching among VTs, unless we have a third First Aids that wants a fight today.

Well okay, disregard that bit. But why should scoutmaster claim now when EoN tomorrow could provide a double scan?

[brainbomb]

If anyone roleswapped with their vt chat partner, we could accidcentally be lynching the scoutmaster

[rdrivera2005]

From the VT list, Bob is still the one giving me more scum vibes, but brain is coming close and so do Bozo. HR and Damo still have some credit from D1 lynch.

##vote Bob

[bozotheclown]

Why claiming now is better then claiming at EON? We should focus today on VTs.

That would require all PRs to be online at exactly EON. It is better to do it before N2 EON, so we might as well do it now.

Everyone knows when they will be able to be online. As long as they do it before EON there's no rush.

If everyone claims before EON, was is the point of waiting?

[Jamiet99uk]

If anyone roleswapped with their vt chat partner, we could accidcentally be lynching the scoutmaster

"Roleswap"?

What is this?

[brainbomb]

From the VT list, Bob is still the one giving me more scum vibes, but brain is coming close and so do Bozo. HR and Damo still have some credit from D1 lynch.

##vote Bob

you finally even dare to make a read on me only as I keep poking at you.

[Vecna]

Why claiming now is better then claiming at EON? We should focus today on VTs.

That would require all PRs to be online at exactly EON. It is better to do it before N2 EON, so we might as well do it now.

Everyone knows when they will be able to be online. As long as they do it before EON there's no rush.

honestly, id prefer it during day3 over earlier during N2. Their problem for making their claim look worse then, but its better than the alternative.

Thats also why Bozo is looking scummy as all hell here. There are 2 bloody cops hiding in our little group while the scum have a RB and a Kill. He's pretending that the advantage of knowing the PR's while were 100% lynching in the VT's is any added advantage at this point. There is none.

[brainbomb]

If anyone roleswapped with their vt chat partner, we could accidcentally be lynching the scoutmaster

"Roleswap"?

What is this?

Imagine a scenario where a VT and a PR really hit it off in their chat.
and the PR said, hey buddy they want us to massclaim im a PR.
Would you claim to be PR and stand in as a body double for me? kool k thanks bye'

[BobMcBob]

I mean, day2 has just started and apparently we already caught 2 scum, so bring on that maelstrom I guess

Which 2 scum have we caught? Guilty scan from scoutmaster and scum catch if all PRs claim exact roles? That doesn't quite add up.

[rdrivera2005]

If anyone roleswapped with their vt chat partner, we could accidcentally be lynching the scoutmaster

Why on Earth you keep making this kind of post with really unlikely scenarios instead of focusing on the VT claimants?

State your case on me by the way.

[bozotheclown]

Why do that when we can chance 2 scum? If scoutmaster scans another guilty tonight, we can potentially find 2 scum. Unless the scoutmaster is set to be lynched or they know they won't be on at EoN, it's worth the wait.

To be clear I am advocating catching 2 scum today by just letting it all out the bag

Why not one today and two tomorrow?

It is not worth waiting to have another PR get killed without revealing their role. Also, the mafia should have a good guess who the Scoutmaster is, and a very good chance of narrowing him down to 2 for the NK and RB.

[rdrivera2005]

That would require all PRs to be online at exactly EON. It is better to do it before N2 EON, so we might as well do it now.

Everyone knows when they will be able to be online. As long as they do it before EON there's no rush.

If everyone claims before EON, was is the point of waiting?

Giving the usefull PRs one more shot at least.

[Hellenic Riot]

My main issue with brain is the unexplained wagon that him and emc attempted to start on rdrivera D1; and I never got an answer from either of them about why they actually wanted it in the first place, so this seems like an excellent time to re-raise that point.

[brainbomb]

If anyone roleswapped with their vt chat partner, we could accidcentally be lynching the scoutmaster

Why on Earth you keep making this kind of post with really unlikely scenarios instead of focusing on the VT claimants?

State your case on me by the way.

the case is that you keep popping in with NAI crap, and then only just now did we finally get something resembling reads from you

[bozotheclown]

That would require all PRs to be online at exactly EON. It is better to do it before N2 EON, so we might as well do it now.

Everyone knows when they will be able to be online. As long as they do it before EON there's no rush.

honestly, id prefer it during day3 over earlier during N2. Their problem for making their claim look worse then, but its better than the alternative.

Thats also why Bozo is looking scummy as all hell here. There are 2 bloody cops hiding in our little group while the scum have a RB and a Kill. He's pretending that the advantage of knowing the PR's while were 100% lynching in the VT's is any added advantage at this point. There is none.

We do not want anther PR NKed without revealing for the best chance of identifying the scum in the PRs.