M1011 - Revenge of the Space Mutants - Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

Ok, talk to me then. Who is your scum team and why?

[BunnyGo]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

Ok, talk to me then. Who is your scum team and why?

Are they using daychat to coordinate their movement?

[BunnyGo]

##Vote kgray for now. The lady gray protests too much. And is too upset about being accused. She asks no questions, and tells only lies.

I should know, I've read nearly half her ISO! Look at me I'm reeding. Yay for trying!

[bozotheclown]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

I was really pointing out that it looked suspicious Chaqa would not acknowledge it was a joke, but I did also point out that your first response was to agree with him:

Yeah, even I find it strange that xorx continues to think kgray played as scum. Wtf is going on?

Also, I believe it was a joke now. That doesn’t seem atypical for xorxes to post a dry joke with no indication

When you said that you "believe it was a joke now", it indicated that there was a time you did not think it was a joke. The "even I find it strange" part of the first post shows that you were generally defending xorxes. How is the first post not consistent with not think it was a joke, as Chaqa did?

[BunnyGo]

Wait...didn't worcej try to shoot EMC? How did that turn EMC into Vecna and not kill him? Mafia goon much? ##VOTE VECNA!

[bozotheclown]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

I did look at the "facts" that are available, and it looks likely you or kgray are scum, because I doubt damo's entire D1 wagon was town, whether he is town or scum. I think it is more likely you are scum than kgray, but maybe you could convince me kgray is scum.

[BunnyGo]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

I did look at the "facts" that are available, and it looks likely you or kgray are scum, because I doubt damo's entire D1 wagon was town, whether he is town or scum. I think it is more likely you are scum than kgray, but maybe you could convince me kgray is scum.

What about summit?

[BunnyGo]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

I did look at the "facts" that are available, and it looks likely you or kgray are scum, because I doubt damo's entire D1 wagon was town, whether he is town or scum. I think it is more likely you are scum than kgray, but maybe you could convince me kgray is scum.

Also, if it was T v T why not get a mislynch?

[BunnyGo]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

I did look at the "facts" that are available, and it looks likely you or kgray are scum, because I doubt damo's entire D1 wagon was town, whether he is town or scum. I think it is more likely you are scum than kgray, but maybe you could convince me kgray is scum.

What about summit?

Whoops. Daddy's dead? But then how was I born?

[bozotheclown]

Did you not see acknowledged that I didn't understand it was a joke? I said that I believed it was in xorxes character to make a dry joke I'm not sure how you could possibly think I was agreeing with Chaqa that he didn't believe it was a joke.

You must have missed that in all the posts where I was defending xorxes, who you said I was pocketing, and yet now are saying that I was with Chaqa shading xorx.

This is frustrating. You are trying to find any reason to scumread me instead of actually looking at the facts and coming to a conclusion. You are starting with the conclusion that I must be scum and are fabricating evidence to get you there.

I did look at the "facts" that are available, and it looks likely you or kgray are scum, because I doubt damo's entire D1 wagon was town, whether he is town or scum. I think it is more likely you are scum than kgray, but maybe you could convince me kgray is scum.

Also, if it was T v T why not get a mislynch?

I do not think it was town vs. town, but either way scum had a good chance of getting a mislynch of xorxes until rdrivera and summit voted for damo. After that, I think scum (other than possibly damo) did not want to vote to tie the vote, then damo tied the vote in the last minute.

[bozotheclown]

There was absolutely no indication of a joke.

You've been stating outright falsehoods or being nonsensical all game.

You're actively distracting town and not playing at all like I expect of you.

Obviously I was suspecting xorxes D1, but this over the top confident scum read by Chaqa does not look likely to be coming from town.

[bozotheclown]

Agreed. ##Vote damo

Bus damo some more?

Lol. Yes. That’s the only explanation. If damo and I were scum with a day chat, I’d be telling him to bus me, not the other way around. Damo is a better deep threat than I am.

It later occurred to me that you could be the JOAT, and keeping the double vote protected is important.

[bozotheclown]

If the scum team is damo, Chaqa, and Tom, it would make sense that Tom is the JOAT, continuing to bus damo while Chaqa pushed for a mislynch.

[bozotheclown]

To put that into context, it was like my third or fourth game playing mafia, and the first and only time I had been mafia. I was an ideal deep threat. We talked about it in the scumchat.

Nowadays I get killed early, so I'm much less ideal. So yes, it would stand to make way more sense for other scum to bus me.

I would like to point this out again since Tom ignored my response to it. Tom explained his bussing D1 in M29 as something decided in scum chat, which was not open until N1.

[bozotheclown]

7 players voted for damo D1, but Tom and Chaqa were the only players to leave damo's wagon and return to it, which I believe is a good indication of bussing.

[bozotheclown]

kgray ending D1 voting for damo then not voting for him at all D2 is concerning. If I am wrong about damo/Chaqa/Tom, kgray is a possibility.

[bozotheclown]

This Neph wagon doesn't make a ton of sense to me.

Particularily coming to a conclusion that his lack of vote was scummy D1. If anything, the only scenario where scum!Neph doesn't break the tie there is if it was scum vs scum. Everybody would understand a player breaking a tie.

Its also totally in character for Neph to forget about a deadline like that - or have a lazy D1.

I think damo is still the best lynch. Decent chance of hitting scum and allows us to understand D1 better.

I do not think the part about what is in character for Nephthys is accurate. What games were you basing this assessment on?

[bozotheclown]

When damo votes xorxes (assuming he's here), we'll be at 5-5...

EMC isn't likely to come back.

Neph is catching up.

This is weird

Flash wagon on emc?

Eh, I'm fine with either of these current wagons. Why?

I know Chaqa said he was busy at EOD, but if he had time to make these 2 posts, he had time to vote for damo to prevent the tie he was anticipating if he was really OK with either wagon.

[damo666]

no

Why was damo so strongly suspected day 1?

It started with this:

I am policy voting the lowest poster until everyone has fulfilled their quota and will use reverse alphabetical to break ties

##vote Xorxes

What a silly catalyst for a wagon.

[bozotheclown]

Since it is mylo, I think it would be a good idea for everyone to give their best guess at the entire scum team.

bozo: damo, Chaqa, Tom