M1011 - Revenge of the Space Mutants - Game Thread

[summit_fever]

I have an internal pH of 9.2 and an external of 1.1

Underrated comment right here lol

I enjoyed it, my flatmates gave me some weird looks though

Hey Nephthys. Why did you fail to lynch one of xorxes or damo?

[xorxes]

Gun to head my current guess would be bozo, worcej and summit

summit tying it instead of securing my lynch if that's the case would be kind of odd.

[foodcoats]

how about neph claiming he'd like to lynch damo or xorxes and failing to do either?

how about neph claiming he'd like to lynch damo or xorxes and failing to do either?

None of these things are as interesting to me as you explaining why those four posts led you to believe damo was scummy, but never felt the need to quote them yesterday or explain to other townies how and why damo was scum, but were important enough for you to decide, with only a few minutes remaining in the day, that damo should be lynched over xorxes, despite you documenting two scumreads against xorxes.

I'm listening.

lol. I saw rivera move. I moved. ask chaqa about my end of vote rationality. I moved off demon after scumming him as cop in the last game.

Are you saying it was just a gut reaction? Or did you think rdr was onto something and put your faith in him?

[Nephthys]

I think that the argument that one of the damo voters may be scum is interesting. But I'm going to ##vote Neph because that was Chaqa's first vote, and Chaqa's first vote last game proved to be accurate. Also because of the end vote, and because there's not much more to go on at this point.

xorxes, if Nephthys were to be lynched and flip scum, what do you believe that would tell us about Chaqa's alignment?

If Neph flips town, what will that mean about Chaqa?

What do you take it to mean that Chaqa's vote on dargorygel in M55 stayed there for more than 24 hours, whereas here Chaqa has already voted twice more?

I don't think it would tell us much about Chaqa either way, other than confirm whether he is a good or bad litmus test.

I don't make anything out of him switching votes for now either. Probably more towny than scummy, but not by a large margin.

Dislike this. It means that his original post was merely to get a vote on the board.

There is nothing to be gained from his test and thre's no repercussions

[Nephthys]

Now to determine whether xorx would be so flippant in misremembering a past game if he were scum. Hmm.

If we go down into a rabbit hole of misremembering = scum imma cry

@bozo please use recent experience to strongly discourage this

[summit_fever]

None of these things are as interesting to me as you explaining why those four posts led you to believe damo was scummy, but never felt the need to quote them yesterday or explain to other townies how and why damo was scum, but were important enough for you to decide, with only a few minutes remaining in the day, that damo should be lynched over xorxes, despite you documenting two scumreads against xorxes.

I'm listening.

lol. I saw rivera move. I moved. ask chaqa about my end of vote rationality. I moved off demon after scumming him as cop in the last game.

Are you saying it was just a gut reaction? Or did you think rdr was onto something and put your faith in him?

a lot of gut involved. I wasn't that interested in lynching xorxes day 1 off of a very early neph vote. I still agree with you his iso is very defensive (imo) and that surprised me. I had the scum feels on damo and I was absolutely curious to see how emc and neph would respond.

I didn't cause the tie. Neph and EMC did.

[Nephthys]

First 10 pages
T
- Chaqa/Kgray/Food
S
- Xorx/Damo/Tom

[Nephthys]

I want to bring attention to Neph still voting end on worcej too. Seems a bit... low effort?

Haha just a little, I was gonna hit the same vibe as last game

I just really wasn't into it as much as I was

And I don't actually enjoy constantly pissing people off

[Nephthys]

Just reading the food vs xorx and it makes me uncomfortable.

For the start of the last game I was really sad that food was only limply pushing people everywhere. Here he's 180d and I don't like it

[foodcoats]

lol. I saw rivera move. I moved. ask chaqa about my end of vote rationality. I moved off demon after scumming him as cop in the last game.

Are you saying it was just a gut reaction? Or did you think rdr was onto something and put your faith in him?

a lot of gut involved. I wasn't that interested in lynching xorxes day 1 off of a very early neph vote. I still agree with you his iso is very defensive (imo) and that surprised me. I had the scum feels on damo and I was absolutely curious to see how emc and neph would respond.

I didn't cause the tie. Neph and EMC did.

So what I am hearing is that you had shady vibes from both xorxes and damo, but figured it was strategically preferable to err on the side of xorxes as he would be more beneficial to town.

Do you think damo and xorxes might both be scum?

[bozotheclown]

@bozo, what was/is your read of damo? It is clear that you preferred to lynch me over him, but given the risk of a tie, were you strongly opposed to a damo lynch, or were you just ok with the risk of a tie given there was still a chance of lynching me?

I did not have a significant read of damo and I was OK risking a tie. However, at EOD, damo did not appear to be online and had not posted for over half and hour, so it seemed to me damo was about to get lynched.

[summit_fever]

Are you saying it was just a gut reaction? Or did you think rdr was onto something and put your faith in him?

a lot of gut involved. I wasn't that interested in lynching xorxes day 1 off of a very early neph vote. I still agree with you his iso is very defensive (imo) and that surprised me. I had the scum feels on damo and I was absolutely curious to see how emc and neph would respond.

I didn't cause the tie. Neph and EMC did.

So what I am hearing is that you had shady vibes from both xorxes and damo, but figured it was strategically preferable to err on the side of xorxes as he would be more beneficial to town.

Do you think damo and xorxes might both be scum?

Is it possible? sure. Xorxes seemed resigned to his fate. I'd say a bit vanilla townish. Perhaps he was waiting for the move and found an opportunity to save himself.

I'm more interested in the fact I don't believe worcej's claim that he took a shot at emc and I don't understand why nephthys claimed he wanted to lynch xorxes or damo and did neither.

[Nephthys]

Your Kgray read is really funny.

This

[summit_fever]

Your Kgray read is really funny.

This

Look in the mirror

[xorxes]

@bozo, what was/is your read of damo? It is clear that you preferred to lynch me over him, but given the risk of a tie, were you strongly opposed to a damo lynch, or were you just ok with the risk of a tie given there was still a chance of lynching me?

I did not have a significant read of damo and I was OK risking a tie. However, at EOD, damo did not appear to be online and had not posted for over half and hour, so it seemed to me damo was about to get lynched.

Do you have a read of him now, after what happened?

[Nephthys]

DAY ONE FINAL VOTE COUNT

damo666(5) - kgray, Tom Bombadil, rdrivera2005, Summit_fever, xorxes
xorxes(5) - foodcoats, bozotheclown, worcej, Chaqa, Damo666
worcej(1) - Nephthys(End)

EMC failed to vote and will be replaced out (I have subs available).

If this appears inaccurate, PM me within the next three minutes.

Otherwise KEEP HOLDING.

TLDR we have 8 super proud people here....

D1 getting a lynch is important...

[foodcoats]

a lot of gut involved. I wasn't that interested in lynching xorxes day 1 off of a very early neph vote. I still agree with you his iso is very defensive (imo) and that surprised me. I had the scum feels on damo and I was absolutely curious to see how emc and neph would respond.

I didn't cause the tie. Neph and EMC did.

So what I am hearing is that you had shady vibes from both xorxes and damo, but figured it was strategically preferable to err on the side of xorxes as he would be more beneficial to town.

Do you think damo and xorxes might both be scum?

Is it possible? sure. Xorxes seemed resigned to his fate. I'd say a bit vanilla townish. Perhaps he was waiting for the move and found an opportunity to save himself.

I'm more interested in the fact I don't believe worcej's claim that he took a shot at emc and I don't understand why nephthys claimed he wanted to lynch xorxes or damo and did neither.

Thanks for bearing with my questions.

I'm interested to see what Nephthys does today, as well.

[Nephthys]

I disagree with worcej. I would always tie to save myself as town.

I think Neph coming in ten mintues before deadline and then not voting one of the wagons is less than pathetic.

So you'd rather I vote based on no reading?

Just curious

[Tom Bombadil]

says the ony guy who didn't end up on either wagon

[Nephthys]

##vote nephthys

9 minutes to go and he's cracking about forgetting the game and takes off.

I mean I had teaching but sure