M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Vecna]

@Nephthys: I think you MUST jail BunnyGo tonight as it gives us the best chance of jailing the scum lawyer/JOAT with lawyering abilities. This gives town the best possible chance to get a good scan, as we need to jail the lawyer for summit's scan to be viable.

If you trust the QT to be town, this is not a very good suggestion. Damo is just as likely to be the lawyer (more imo, but thats up for debate) - and we can still get useful information from Bunny if he actually IS town here. We also have other ways to verify at least bunnies role, and id like to see what he digs up here.

[foodcoats]

@Nephthys: I think you MUST jail BunnyGo tonight as it gives us the best chance of jailing the scum lawyer/JOAT with lawyering abilities. This gives town the best possible chance to get a good scan, as we need to jail the lawyer for summit's scan to be viable.

If you trust the QT to be town, this is not a very good suggestion. Damo is just as likely to be the lawyer (more imo, but thats up for debate) - and we can still get useful information from Bunny if he actually IS town here. We also have other ways to verify at least bunnies role, and id like to see what he digs up here.

I think the way the redirect was used, when we did not yet know with certainty that there is a lawyer, makes it very, very likely that Bunny is the lawyer. It prevented Bunny from being roleblocked.

[Vecna]

Well, guess you better start hunting in your QT now then, because Bunny seems pretty confident he can produce Xorxes' role on the spot

[Chaqa]

Bunny is probably mafia JOAT who had a 1x Role Cop/Thief ability.

Damo is probably mafia Lawyer

[Chaqa]

Damo was probably Lawyering himself all game until he was scanned and then lawyer Squigs to protect against potential scans.

Bunny was redirected from so mafia could figure out just WTF xorxes' role is and if they are safe from it.

[Vecna]

Thats a possibility I guess.

I still think the jailkeeper is also a great fit on the scum team with what we know now, but a JOAT with different roles to figure out the setup makes sense as well.

[BunnyGo]

Well, guess you better start hunting in your QT now then, because Bunny seems pretty confident he can produce Xorxes' role on the spot

I’ve already used enough coded language that xorxes and foodc (and Chaq if he bothered to read) could see I know it. There’s a reason xorxes didn’t want it revealed. I’m willing and able, but would like to do it after a mass claim has been decided or not. But I can do as close to EON as I can. That’s 5 PM here and kids demand dinner and attention so no promises. If you don’t mind it an hour ahead of EON, I can do that. If we want to hammer night and have me be the last hammer, I can do that.

[Vecna]

Regardless, the outcome for night actions should be the same.

Neph should jail Damo and someone should wifom some action on Damo to confirm that actually happened.

[Chaqa]

Bunny 100% knows what xorx role is/how it works, FWIW.

I just happen to think it's because he's a scum role cop or something.

There's other possibilities like scumJoat!Food, as I said, but I'm not going to make wild theories before seeing what happens tonight.

[foodcoats]

Well, guess you better start hunting in your QT now then, because Bunny seems pretty confident he can produce Xorxes' role on the spot

As Chaqa has pointed out, there is no good reason to assume that Bunny knowing xorxes' role implicates the QT or clears Bunny. It is much simpler to assume there is a Mafia Role Cop or Power Thief.

[foodcoats]

Well, guess you better start hunting in your QT now then, because Bunny seems pretty confident he can produce Xorxes' role on the spot

As Chaqa has pointed out, there is no good reason to assume that Bunny knowing xorxes' role implicates the QT or clears Bunny. It is much simpler to assume there is a Mafia Role Cop or Power Thief.

Furthermore, Vecna, why would you think there is scum in the QT when you believe Neph and damo are the two remaining scum?

[BunnyGo]

Since all agree I’ve demonstrated sufficient knowledge of xorxes role. I’ll not post it before EON.

[Vecna]

Well, guess you better start hunting in your QT now then, because Bunny seems pretty confident he can produce Xorxes' role on the spot

As Chaqa has pointed out, there is no good reason to assume that Bunny knowing xorxes' role implicates the QT or clears Bunny. It is much simpler to assume there is a Mafia Role Cop or Power Thief.

Furthermore, Vecna, why would you think there is scum in the QT when you believe Neph and damo are the two remaining scum?

I was talking from your pov, but a simple rolecop/rolethief on scum is indeed a fine explanation as well.

Anyways, we'll see what happens. Whether neph is scum or town he's not going to listen to my suggestions regardless so we'll just sort through the outcome.

[Vecna]

Nice job on the fakeclaim at any rate if you are scum bunny, it probably wouldve worked on me

[BunnyGo]

Nice job on the fakeclaim at any rate if you are scum bunny, it probably wouldve worked on me

It’s not fake. And I don’t know why you’re letting Chaq manipulate you.

[Chaqa]

Well, guess you better start hunting in your QT now then, because Bunny seems pretty confident he can produce Xorxes' role on the spot

As Chaqa has pointed out, there is no good reason to assume that Bunny knowing xorxes' role implicates the QT or clears Bunny. It is much simpler to assume there is a Mafia Role Cop or Power Thief.

Furthermore, Vecna, why would you think there is scum in the QT when you believe Neph and damo are the two remaining scum?

This is an interesting catch, but may just be in-line with his tunneling tinfoil all game.

[Chaqa]

Since all agree I’ve demonstrated sufficient knowledge of xorxes role. I’ll not post it before EON.

Make sure you post it AT EoN, not AFTER EON.

If you do not post anything at EoN, I will be suspicious.

[Chaqa]

Nice job on the fakeclaim at any rate if you are scum bunny, it probably wouldve worked on me

It’s not fake. And I don’t know why you’re letting Chaq manipulate you.

where's my table flip gif

[BunnyGo]

Since all agree I’ve demonstrated sufficient knowledge of xorxes role. I’ll not post it before EON.

Make sure you post it AT EoN, not AFTER EON.

If you do not post anything at EoN, I will be suspicious.

Why post it? You know I know. Posting only diminishes my scan and xorxes scan. I think you’re just making sh*t up now that doesn’t make sense.

[foodcoats]

Since all agree I’ve demonstrated sufficient knowledge of xorxes role. I’ll not post it before EON.

Make sure you post it AT EoN, not AFTER EON.

If you do not post anything at EoN, I will be suspicious.

Why post it? You know I know. Posting only diminishes my scan and xorxes scan. I think you’re just making sh*t up now that doesn’t make sense.

Bunny, you HAVE to post it because it proves your claim. I am still willing to be persuaded you are not scum, but if you do not post it, you are obvscum.

Chaqa spoke too broadly. You have actually not specified certain elements that are key to proving you actually took xorxes' action. You need to do that. xorxes is basically guaranteed to die tonight - scum still have lawyering, presumably, so they will kill xorxes before summit. So there's no fear of outing him.