M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Forum rules
This is an area for forum games. Please note that to support mafia games players cannot edit their own posts in this forum. Off Topic threads will be relocated or deleted. Issues taking place in forum games should be dealt with by respective game GMs and escalated to the moderators only if absolutely necessary.
This is an area for forum games. Please note that to support mafia games players cannot edit their own posts in this forum. Off Topic threads will be relocated or deleted. Issues taking place in forum games should be dealt with by respective game GMs and escalated to the moderators only if absolutely necessary.
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
So let's revisit Nephs jails:
N1 - claims he targeted foodcoats but with LR no way to verify this so N/A
N2 - claims he targeted Xorx trying to protect him. While this is more towny than scummy, its also possible scum just thought Xorxes was a good PR (which it appears he was)
N3 - claims to have jailed Bunny with little reasoning, throwing out that he thought he would catch a NK from scum Bunny. This is kinda a weird target, not super scummy but the way he explained it was super super awkward.
N4 - claims to have jailed himself. As town i guess it self preserves but as scum it is a convenient way of not allowing town investigatives of scanning you. Both alignments possible, but scum has more upside here i think.
N5 - claims to have jailed Vecna because he thought Vecna was scum and would flex his ego by making the NK. As town this is just bad play. As scum, I'm not sure the exact reasoning here. If Vecna were scum, he could be covering up a potential scan on Vecna. If Vecna is town, then this is a way of wasting a jail, kinda like the Bunny jail.
Conclusion: It is possible to view Neph as either a suboptimal town jailor or an outside the box scum jailor. Needs more looking at, but I think I'm comfortable keeping my vote here for now
N1 - claims he targeted foodcoats but with LR no way to verify this so N/A
N2 - claims he targeted Xorx trying to protect him. While this is more towny than scummy, its also possible scum just thought Xorxes was a good PR (which it appears he was)
N3 - claims to have jailed Bunny with little reasoning, throwing out that he thought he would catch a NK from scum Bunny. This is kinda a weird target, not super scummy but the way he explained it was super super awkward.
N4 - claims to have jailed himself. As town i guess it self preserves but as scum it is a convenient way of not allowing town investigatives of scanning you. Both alignments possible, but scum has more upside here i think.
N5 - claims to have jailed Vecna because he thought Vecna was scum and would flex his ego by making the NK. As town this is just bad play. As scum, I'm not sure the exact reasoning here. If Vecna were scum, he could be covering up a potential scan on Vecna. If Vecna is town, then this is a way of wasting a jail, kinda like the Bunny jail.
Conclusion: It is possible to view Neph as either a suboptimal town jailor or an outside the box scum jailor. Needs more looking at, but I think I'm comfortable keeping my vote here for now
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
ok, any town person should actually be having the same thought as me here
What did we just learn?
What options does this give us?
These night actions are very telling, and there are some very different interesting ways to interpret all of this.
What did we just learn?
What options does this give us?
These night actions are very telling, and there are some very different interesting ways to interpret all of this.
- Chaqa
- Bronze Donator
- Posts: 14306
- Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 7:33 pm
- Location: Allentown, PA, USA
- Contact:
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Unless Neph is scummy which I’m really doubting
Bunny/Squigs/Vecna?
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
I have something. Let me think a bit whether I should say it here or in code.
- Chaqa
- Bronze Donator
- Posts: 14306
- Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 7:33 pm
- Location: Allentown, PA, USA
- Contact:
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Food confirmed the N1 jail and its consistent with the results brain, Jamie had as well as what EMC and flash saw with xorxes N2.Squigs44 wrote: ↑Mon May 11, 2020 9:30 pmSo let's revisit Nephs jails:
N1 - claims he targeted foodcoats but with LR no way to verify this so N/A
N2 - claims he targeted Xorx trying to protect him. While this is more towny than scummy, its also possible scum just thought Xorxes was a good PR (which it appears he was)
N3 - claims to have jailed Bunny with little reasoning, throwing out that he thought he would catch a NK from scum Bunny. This is kinda a weird target, not super scummy but the way he explained it was super super awkward.
N4 - claims to have jailed himself. As town i guess it self preserves but as scum it is a convenient way of not allowing town investigatives of scanning you. Both alignments possible, but scum has more upside here i think.
N5 - claims to have jailed Vecna because he thought Vecna was scum and would flex his ego by making the NK. As town this is just bad play. As scum, I'm not sure the exact reasoning here. If Vecna were scum, he could be covering up a potential scan on Vecna. If Vecna is town, then this is a way of wasting a jail, kinda like the Bunny jail.
Conclusion: It is possible to view Neph as either a suboptimal town jailor or an outside the box scum jailor. Needs more looking at, but I think I'm comfortable keeping my vote here for now
Neph is 100% jailed. Alignment TBD.
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
The only way I'm scum is if mafia have a lawyer and a redirector (or I'm godfather or some variation of this)
- Chaqa
- Bronze Donator
- Posts: 14306
- Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 7:33 pm
- Location: Allentown, PA, USA
- Contact:
- Chaqa
- Bronze Donator
- Posts: 14306
- Joined: Fri Sep 29, 2017 7:33 pm
- Location: Allentown, PA, USA
- Contact:
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
That’s what I just said?
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
How would scum know Jamie's protectee would die with Jamie? Unless he revealed that in Chaqa's QT. But then Vecna, you are not in that. Did the mole tell you in mafchat?Vecna wrote: ↑Mon May 11, 2020 9:14 pmjamiets role actually makes quite a lot of sense in the mechanical puzzle and the number of protectives.
Shame jamiet didnt leave behind a legacy to tell us what was discussed in the QT in regards to his ability usage.
BUT
this does mean that scum were intending to endgame us yesterday with a squigs lynch maybe? followed by a kill on jamiet and his protective target?
Before I go off again on how this incriminates the QT, lets hear it.
spill them beans
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Well, either it clears the QT or the scum leader did a really smart plan and hoped that someone would think of this interaction.
Itd be a pretty good wifom plan. Which I think you and chaqa -might- be capable of. Hmmm
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
yeah, given that chaqa just stated he knew he was targeting town and scum reads confirms they knew.
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Scum have a redirector. Theyre using it on Summit.
If scum knew Jamiets role, they couldve just redirected jamiet to summit and killed both
If scum knew Jamiets role, they couldve just redirected jamiet to summit and killed both
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Thinking here.
Scum have a redirector. They can make summit go to anyone. Why Squigs? Why not damo (who has already been scanned) seems like scum wanted the inno scan on squigs.
Therefore squigs is more likely scum
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
they couldve killed anyone they wanted alongside with jamiet.
In fact, they shouldve kept him alive here if they knew jamiet's role.
Unless the redirector is at serious risk of dying, and they just wanna wifom....but
In fact, they shouldve kept him alive here if they knew jamiet's role.
Unless the redirector is at serious risk of dying, and they just wanna wifom....but
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
Your conclusion might be correct, but the thought process is too simple
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
ofcourse if they had redirected jamiet to summit and killed both, it wouldve started a witch hunt in the QT
Re: M55: The Last Party - Game Thread
I probably shouldve kept this conclusion quiet for a while to see if Chaqa/xorxes/foodcoats wouldve ever come out with it.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], brainbomb, Chomps, Spartaculous