M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Vecna]

Look Vecna, I don't have some vendetta against you. I want to lynch you cause you look like scum to me.

If you look back the logic and reasoning has changed and evolved throughout the game.

Almost everyone else has done stuff that has changed my reads and my lists have reflected that.

Nohing you have done has made me want to. There is no valid explanation for why a town you would do significant amounts of what you've done

There is though......there is

But I cant blame you if youre town (well neither if youre scum ofcourse).

The problem probably rests in the fact im disappointed I couldnt produce awesome results with the role I was given, and I might have been in too try-hard mode to make up for it ever since.

Also, role madness affects playstyles. Much more mech-focussed analysis is needed.

Anyways, enough excuses.

[Nephthys]

Ok Vecna

here's your chance to change my mind.

Make a read list

Include everyone left and give me some reaosns.

Chuck out the most logical scumteam you can find

[Jamiet99uk]

@Vecna:

It appears you believed the Lie Detector had super broad, possibly game-breaking powers.

What led you to assume the role worked in the way you did?

Was it Damo?

[Vecna]

Just the way it was claimed by Tem?

He claimed a role, but left out the most important part about the limitations

[Vecna]

Ill get you your readslist later Neph. im not really in the mindset now

[xorxes]

Just the way it was claimed by Tem?

He claimed a role, but left out the most important part about the limitations

I think he explained it more or less correctly. What he left out was saying which messages had been checked.

[xorxes]

Confirmed:
BismarckAlive: Town JOAT (Protective 2x, Killing, Investigative 2x, Roleblock)
kgray: Town Motion Detector (Investigative)
TheMarche: Town Bus Driver (Protective)
Donny Dude: Town Tracker (Investigative)
emc: Third Party Universal Backup -> Town Tracker (Investigative)
flash: Town Watcher (Investigative)
DemonRHK: Mafia Street Doctor (Protective)
rdrivera: Third Party Lead Inquisitor (Killing?)
brainbomb: Town Doctor (Protective)
Sarah/Temasek: Town Lie Detector (Investigative)

Claims:
foodcoats: Lightning Rod (Roleblock)
Chaqa: Neighborizer (N/A)
Vecna: Paranoid Gun Owner (Killing)
Jamie: "Town Protective" (Protective)
summit_feve​r: Alignment Cop (Investigative)
Nephthys: Jailer (Roleblock)
F​oxcastle/Squigs: Vengeful (Killing)

Others:
bozo
damo
dargorygel/BunnyGo
xorxes

[Jamiet99uk]

Why does my claim get put in scare quotes.

Especially by you, Xorxes. You know what my full role is.

[xorxes]

Why does my claim get put in scare quotes.

Especially by you, Xorxes. You know what my full role is.

I inherited it from bozo's list, it doesn't mean anything, just that it is not the exact name of the role.

[Jamiet99uk]

Ok.

Massclaim tomorrow then, yes?

[Nephthys]

Ok.

Massclaim tomorrow then, yes?

Of course

[xorxes]

D1
Donny Dude (13) bozotheclown Nephthys Vecna Jamiet99uk Foxcastle dargorygel DemonRHK damo666 TheMarche flash2015 xorxes summit_fever foodcoats
SarahK24 (4) rdrivera2005 e.m.c^42 Chaqa kgray
dargorygel (1) SarahK24
TheMarche (1) brainbomb
summit_fever (1) Donny Dude
Chaqa (1) BismarckAlive

D2
BismarckAlive (10) kgray rdrivera2005 summit_fever foodcoats* brainbomb Chaqa e.m.c^42 bozotheclown DemonRHK Vecna
e.m.c^42 (9) dargorygel xorxes flash2015 TheMarche Foxcastle Nephthys Jamiet99uk BismarckAlive damo666
bozotheclown (1) SarahK24

D3
DemonRHK (9) xorxes bozotheclown Squigs44 BunnyGo rdrivera2005 DemonRHK brainbomb Vecna foodcoats
Nephthys (6) Jamiet99uk Chaqa flash2015 e.m.c^42 summit_fever Nephthys
brainbomb (1) damo666
Non-votes: SarahK24


D4
rdrivera2005 (11) xorxes* Nephthys bozotheclown* BunnyGo summit_fever damo666* foodcoats Chaqa* brainbomb* Vecna* Squigs44*
Unvote (1) Temasek22
foodcoats (1) Jamiet99uk

D5
Temasek22 (9) Squigs44 Vecna damo666 summit_fever Jamiet99uk BunnyGo Chaqa foodcoats Nephthys
Squigs44 (3) xorxes bozotheclown Temasek22

[xorxes]

If Chaqa is not mafia, every mafia was voting for Donny on D1.

[xorxes]

D2 was TvT, probably they split 2-2 if there was four of them.

[Chaqa]

IMO mafia likely 3-1 or 4-0 on Bismarck to keep the mislynch viable?

[Chaqa]

Ah thst doesn’t work actually

Blegh

[xorxes]

D3 and D4 had claims, so not terribly informative how wagons ended.

D5 if Squigs is scum, all scum were probably on Tem making sure he was lynched.

If Squigs is town... I would expect scum would have preferred to lynch him so as to get both him and Tem in one shot. There was a lot of resistance to that, so I think that's more indication that Squigs is scum.

[xorxes]

D3 actually scum knew the guilty was legit, so very likely all scum were on RHK.

D4 everyone was on board with my claim except for Jamie, but scum would have been very happy with my find anyway.

[Chaqa]

Squigs/Bunny/food?

[Chaqa]

Vecna also possible