M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Nephthys]

But Id like to know what bozo thinks because damo is scum and bozo is good at this game.

So evidently you think Bozo is not scum

Correct, I posted that in my big reads list above.

hahhaahaha

[Nephthys]

Neph’s scheme should be set off sooner rather than later in the day, so he has time to say things.

Huh, what scheme?

I believe Neph is deliberately playing in a way that he knows people will find sus. Don't really have theories to why. Setting it off as in calling his "y'all ain't gonna vote for me" schtick.

And what would voting me prove?

[bozotheclown]

I reviewed the sign up thread, and in the first post you already had separate lists of roles for town and mafia, so I do not know why the controversy you are referencing has anything to do with you changing the setup from one that had non-alignment specific roles.

Yep, the only big controversy I find was the Chippee exclusion and it was painful to read all that.

Eh, well I can tell you it initially was supposed to a mimic of 41 cause I liked it so much.

I doubt you will believe this but before that I PMed brain to ask for his help to balance and Co-GM, he helped me balance and suggested that I make it semi-open/open. Subsequently you can see what came of that.

I can't find the message in my inbox so cant prove it unless brain remembers so do with it as you wish.

I still do not see why you brought up the ChippeRock "controversy" to explain why your setup changed. It seems like deflection to me.

##VOTE Nephthys

[Nephthys]

Yep, the only big controversy I find was the Chippee exclusion and it was painful to read all that.

Eh, well I can tell you it initially was supposed to a mimic of 41 cause I liked it so much.

I doubt you will believe this but before that I PMed brain to ask for his help to balance and Co-GM, he helped me balance and suggested that I make it semi-open/open. Subsequently you can see what came of that.

I can't find the message in my inbox so cant prove it unless brain remembers so do with it as you wish.

I still do not see why you brought up the ChippeRock "controversy" to explain why your setup changed. It seems like deflection to me.

##VOTE Nephthys

Because I know my setup changed and that was what stuck with me/

If you're best scum read comes from me mis-remembering a game from mid-last year then I'm more disappointed than everything

[Nephthys]

*anything

[xorxes]

I have never heard of a scum doctor, I think I would put that first. Neighborizer would be a power scum role if everyone assumes it must be town.

Any role would be a power scum role if everyone assumes it must be town.

[xorxes]

TBH, if the Jailer is town, they should claim, as it would really improve out knowledge. The fact this hasn't been discussed and we've had no roleblocks makes me think the Jailer is scum.

It's pretty clear alraedy who it is, and they were probably trying to roleblock me, but I won't out them if they don't want to claim.

Why would a town jailer want to roleblock you?

They wouldn't obviously (unless they thought I was scum). But I think we have a Mafia Jailor.

[xorxes]

So I assume DemonRHK is claiming he has a protective role, tried to protect someone, and received a message stating his target was "was not in need of my services".

Does everyone believe this?

No reason whatsoever for him to lie about this.

summit_fever, Nephthys, and Vecna: You are voting for brainbomb. If you think brainbomb is scum, do you think DemonRHK is scum as well, trying to cover for brainbomb?

It would be so nonsensical for scum to claim Doctor when they don't even know if there could be a town Doctor and having two Doctors would be so awkward (I know worcej said this could happen). Only way scum claim Doctor is if for some reason the Doctor ended up as a scum role.

So do you think brainbomb and DemonRHK are relatively clear?

No, I think brainbomb is town and Demon is scum.

[xorxes]

Xorxes is 3p

No, I'm not.

Well you've convinced me

Which one of us?

[Nephthys]

No, I'm not.

Well you've convinced me

Which one of us?

You ofc

[Nephthys]

Well you've convinced me

Which one of us?

You ofc

Why? Am I wrong?

[xorxes]

The rules suggest that there could not be two roleblockers in the same faction, as it would not be clear who roleblocks who if they target each other.

##VOTE DamonRHK

[xorxes]

##VOTE Demon (correcting typo)

[xorxes]

Which one of us?

You ofc

Why? Am I wrong?

Nope. It's just that we were both so convincing it was hard to tell which one you found more compelling.

[bozotheclown]

No reason whatsoever for him to lie about this.



It would be so nonsensical for scum to claim Doctor when they don't even know if there could be a town Doctor and having two Doctors would be so awkward (I know worcej said this could happen). Only way scum claim Doctor is if for some reason the Doctor ended up as a scum role.

So do you think brainbomb and DemonRHK are relatively clear?

No, I think brainbomb is town and Demon is scum.

Do you think DemonRHK is scum with a protective role?

[bozotheclown]

It's pretty clear alraedy who it is, and they were probably trying to roleblock me, but I won't out them if they don't want to claim.

Why would a town jailer want to roleblock you?

They wouldn't obviously (unless they thought I was scum). But I think we have a Mafia Jailor.

Then why would you not want to out a mafia jailer?

[xorxes]

Why would a town jailer want to roleblock you?

They wouldn't obviously (unless they thought I was scum). But I think we have a Mafia Jailor.

Then why would you not want to out a mafia jailer?

I would if I knew he was Mafia, of course.

[xorxes]

The rules suggest that there could not be two roleblockers in the same faction, as it would not be clear who roleblocks who if they target each other.

##VOTE DamonRHK

Actually, that doesn't make sense. Scratch that as the reason.

I will leave my vote there and get back to it tomorrow.

[bozotheclown]

They wouldn't obviously (unless they thought I was scum). But I think we have a Mafia Jailor.

Then why would you not want to out a mafia jailer?

I would if I knew he was Mafia, of course.

So it is clear to you who the jailer is, but you are not sure if he is scum?

[Nephthys]

You ofc

Why? Am I wrong?

Nope. It's just that we were both so convincing it was hard to tell which one you found more compelling.

True....

Damo does have a good point