M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[bozotheclown]

You're missing out on important info then.

Potentially. But it's bad play and bad practice to use flavor to relay information. If I had known this was the case, I may not have signed up.

Could you stop whining about the way the GM has chosen to present the game? Anyway, even a blind rodent can see that people are making reference to wording from the flavour, and if you just stubbornly choose not to read it, you're literally depriving yourself of information. Don't spite yourself like that just because you'd do it differently as GM. You're not the GM today. Apparently people are calling your the chairman of the Neighbourhood Watch but since we're on a desert island that doesn't carry much weight.

Instead, how about you ##VOTE BOZO with me, Chaqa, eh, chum?

Chaqa is already voting for me. I am assuming you and Chaqa are town, but you are setting me up for scum to join my wagon (like Sarah and dargorygel).

[Jamiet99uk]

Potentially. But it's bad play and bad practice to use flavor to relay information. If I had known this was the case, I may not have signed up.

Could you stop whining about the way the GM has chosen to present the game? Anyway, even a blind rodent can see that people are making reference to wording from the flavour, and if you just stubbornly choose not to read it, you're literally depriving yourself of information. Don't spite yourself like that just because you'd do it differently as GM. You're not the GM today. Apparently people are calling your the chairman of the Neighbourhood Watch but since we're on a desert island that doesn't carry much weight.

Instead, how about you ##VOTE BOZO with me, Chaqa, eh, chum?

Chaqa is already voting for me. I am assuming you and Chaqa are town, but you are setting me up for scum to join my wagon (like Sarah and dargorygel).

Oh, so he is.

What a clever chap he is.

[Chaqa]

You're missing out on important info then.

Potentially. But it's bad play and bad practice to use flavor to relay information. If I had known this was the case, I may not have signed up.

It's bad practice to be an arse to the GM bud.

Where did I do that?

[xorxes]

If there is a mafia tracker, it is possible emc would try to clear himself by claiming it as scum, but I doubt there is a mafia tracker, because that would not be very useful to scum.

So the main reason you don't think emc is scum is that you don't think there's a Mafia Tracker, would that be correct?

You think it is more likely that Donny was town than that there is a Mafia Tracker. So your scumread of Donny was relatively weak, then?

You are misrepresenting what I said. If I said I was sure emc would claim tracker if it is a scum role and he is scum, then "the main reason you don't think emc is scum is that you don't think there's a Mafia Tracker" would be true. However, that is not what I said, I said it was possible he would.

Can you explain then what is the main reason you think he is town? It is pretty clear now that he is indeed Watcher, which means that his 3P conversion story is likely true. So he has not been lying about anything mechanical except perhaps his alignment, which I think makes perfect sense as either alignment.

Do you think Donny was more likely town or scum watcher?

I don't think we can use people's roles as the main basis for reading their alignment, because pretty much any role could be any alignment as far as we know. It seems very unlikely now that Mafia won't claim their true role.

[e.m.c^42]

Food, now that you bring up FoxC I remembered - he said something about disliking mechs, didn't he? For some reason I remember a very different meta for him in regards to that, does anyone else recall?

To elaborate. Fox said he dislikes/find tedious mechs of roles and such. I kind of remember that being the opposite based on his past play. However I do believe it's possible that I'm still misreading what mechs in his case means.

Could someone else weigh in?

[e.m.c^42]

Xorxes, what?

I am tracker not watcher. Are you sure you are reading

[Chaqa]

You're missing out on important info then.

Potentially. But it's bad play and bad practice to use flavor to relay information. If I had known this was the case, I may not have signed up.

Could you stop whining about the way the GM has chosen to present the game? Anyway, even a blind rodent can see that people are making reference to wording from the flavour, and if you just stubbornly choose not to read it, you're literally depriving yourself of information. Don't spite yourself like that just because you'd do it differently as GM. You're not the GM today. Apparently people are calling your the chairman of the Neighbourhood Watch but since we're on a desert island that doesn't carry much weight.

Instead, how about you ##VOTE BOZO with me, Chaqa, eh, chum?

I thought I was voting Bozo?

And it's not that I'm whining, it's that there was no indication that flavor was/would be relevant, as it never has been in 50+ games here. It would have been nice to at least have notice of such a thing.

I'm still not liking factoring it into our analysis, as what if it's all a misdirection?

[e.m.c^42]

If it was once I could understand as typo but you repeatedly used watcher instead.

[e.m.c^42]

Lmao I am confused again

[xorxes]

Xorxes, what?

I am tracker not watcher. Are you sure you are reading

What do you think?

[damo666]

So the main reason you don't think emc is scum is that you don't think there's a Mafia Tracker, would that be correct?

You think it is more likely that Donny was town than that there is a Mafia Tracker. So your scumread of Donny was relatively weak, then?

You are misrepresenting what I said. If I said I was sure emc would claim tracker if it is a scum role and he is scum, then "the main reason you don't think emc is scum is that you don't think there's a Mafia Tracker" would be true. However, that is not what I said, I said it was possible he would.

Can you explain then what is the main reason you think he is town? It is pretty clear now that he is indeed Watcher, which means that his 3P conversion story is likely true. So he has not been lying about anything mechanical except perhaps his alignment, which I think makes perfect sense as either alignment.

Do you think Donny was more likely town or scum watcher?

I don't think we can use people's roles as the main basis for reading their alignment, because pretty much any role could be any alignment as far as we know. It seems very unlikely now that Mafia won't claim their true role.

Why tracker=> watcher? Most unlike a meticulous Xorxes. What gives?

[xorxes]

If it was once I could understand as typo but you repeatedly used watcher instead.

Do you think I believe you are the watcher that tracked flash who could not find me, or do you think I made a silly mistake? What's your best guess?

[xorxes]

Do you think Donny was more likely town or scum watcher?

I don't think we can use people's roles as the main basis for reading their alignment, because pretty much any role could be any alignment as far as we know. It seems very unlikely now that Mafia won't claim their true role.

Why tracker=> watcher? Most unlike a meticulous Xorxes. What gives?

What's your theory?

[e.m.c^42]

Xorxes, what?

I am tracker not watcher. Are you sure you are reading

What do you think?

I don't know what to think. You don't make mistakes like this in general. Maybe you are tired? :D

Or it's a plot but I can't tell

[Jamiet99uk]

Xorxes, what?

I am tracker not watcher. Are you sure you are reading

What do you think?

Xorxes you are being odd. Whether you believe his Tracker claim or not, he has used the word "Tracker" consistently. I never saw him claim Watcher.

Do you have some new information? Was there something written on the wall of your cell?

[damo666]

Lmao I am confused again

Your confused? I really haven't the foggiest notion of what's going on. Half the roles I've never heard of.

##vote Xorxes

His crusade against EMC is too much.

[e.m.c^42]

If it was once I could understand as typo but you repeatedly used watcher instead.

Do you think I believe you are the watcher that tracked flash who could not find me, or do you think I made a silly mistake? What's your best guess?

I don't think it's either of those, but maybe you are doing a reading test on us? Lmao

[damo666]

Do you think Donny was more likely town or scum watcher?

I don't think we can use people's roles as the main basis for reading their alignment, because pretty much any role could be any alignment as far as we know. It seems very unlikely now that Mafia won't claim their true role.

Why tracker=> watcher? Most unlike a meticulous Xorxes. What gives?

What's your theory?

Don't have one .

[Chaqa]

Can someone give me a number between 1 and 10? I need it for something.

[damo666]

Do you think Donny was more likely town or scum watcher?

I don't think we can use people's roles as the main basis for reading their alignment, because pretty much any role could be any alignment as far as we know. It seems very unlikely now that Mafia won't claim their true role.

Why tracker=> watcher? Most unlike a meticulous Xorxes. What gives?

What's your theory?

You're sending a message to Chaqa?