M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Foxcastle]

Is this trying to break a rule without breaking a rule?

I don't think so. A lot of other people have already said their actions failed.

DID SOMEONE ACTUALLY SAY THAT THEIR ACTION FAILED? BEFORE THIS? I DONT REMEMBER THAT AT ALL

If scum dont have daychat this might be someone signalling the correct answer

My purpose with that particular phrasing was to try to draw a bad answer from EMC. Others had already discussed the jailer and that actions hadn't gone through since the target couldn't be found. When Brain asked, though, he basically led EMC to the right answer. Go back and read his question to EMC. I forget exactly what he said, but my recollection is that he asked EMC what happened with his action, and then basically gave him the answer by asking "did it fail or were you unable to find the target." My hope was that if EMC saw my clarification, he would mimic it in his response, and thereby out himself as having lied. Which is not what happened, obviously.

[Vecna]

keywords

now granted if hes in maf chat the maf killer knows also

Did brain just slip that he's mafia with a daychat?

There would be no way for the mafia killer to relay this information otherwise

Reads pretty desperate to read or look for scumslips in brainbombs statement here. Why would Chaqa also not be interested in this reply? Instead reads like he's trying to distract from it. Was quite a viable question from bb.

I couldn't find him obviously, so no.

how many elipses

Three. I attempted but failed as I cannot find him.

Guess this clears up the fox thing I stated as nonsense

claims

foodcoats: Lightning Rod
emc: Third Party Universal Backup, now Tracker
Chaqa: ?

THE FUCK is the point of this post

"oh hey guys, lets make an overview of all 2 claims so I can look like im TOTALLY CONTRIBUTING LOL"

damn bozo

##VOTE BOZOTHECLOWN

Didn't find out last night, maybe find out today.

please tell me you arent...

Alright, I aren't.

Jamiet is indeed sounding pretty towny. So Jovial. So merry-go-round this time around. Putting a smile on my face

[bozotheclown]

Since as a new player, I found it rather difficult to link actions/scumreads, and it was a lot easier to just look at other people's reads and play pattern recognition.

Granted it was a bit different in my case, but it feels similar enough.

Why was it different in your case?

But fair enough, I agree about pattern recognition being easy/natural to focus on. I certainly did that my first game, and probably still do too much. But, I think this is something that's pretty easy to notice as scum, just as much as town, so I think it's NAI from Bismarck.

You really have it in for me, kgray. I understand it if it's just because I am seen as "lurking". I certainly am not. And there's a lot of people here that simply make 1 liners in response to other nonsense and fill the pages of the thread. English is my second language, so reading the thread is slow, and this game has generated a whole lot of thread more than my other experience with the likes of Jamiet, Bomb, Fox, Flash, Damo, Vecna, and so on. I pick my targets carefully - I ask them questions after analysing their contributions. I try to work out scum. I don't assume that lurking is scummy - much the same as I don't assume that verbosity and page-filling with Walls means you are Town. And I can confirm that I have a Town role on this island. Sure, a minor role, but a Town role nonetheless.

When you say you can confirm you have a town role, does that mean your role can be proven?

[Jamiet99uk]

claims

foodcoats: Lightning Rod
emc: Third Party Universal Backup, now Tracker
Chaqa: ?

THE FUCK is the point of this post

"oh hey guys, lets make an overview of all 2 claims so I can look like im TOTALLY CONTRIBUTING LOL"

damn bozo

Yeah. Bozo is scum this time.

He's my other lynch option today if not EMC.

[Vecna]

I think worcej was a bit misleading in saying that there is a 3rd party faction but then having a 3rd party that is not a member of that faction if that is the case also. I don't know how much weight I can put on that, but that bothers me as well.

GM Note:
Everything stated in the known information (post #2) is factual. Due to the design as a closed setup, I would not intentionally mislead you with any of this information.

##Call GM

If a faction was eliminated, or stopped existing, would we be notified?

[bozotheclown]

keywords

now granted if hes in maf chat the maf killer knows also

Did brain just slip that he's mafia with a daychat?

There would be no way for the mafia killer to relay this information otherwise

Reads pretty desperate to read or look for scumslips in brainbombs statement here. Why would Chaqa also not be interested in this reply? Instead reads like he's trying to distract from it. Was quite a viable question from bb.

how many elipses

Three. I attempted but failed as I cannot find him.

Guess this clears up the fox thing I stated as nonsense

claims

foodcoats: Lightning Rod
emc: Third Party Universal Backup, now Tracker
Chaqa: ?

THE FUCK is the point of this post

"oh hey guys, lets make an overview of all 2 claims so I can look like im TOTALLY CONTRIBUTING LOL"

damn bozo

please tell me you arent...

Alright, I aren't.

Jamiet is indeed sounding pretty towny. So Jovial. So merry-go-round this time around. Putting a smile on my face

I was starting a list for later use.

[bozotheclown]

claims

foodcoats: Lightning Rod
emc: Third Party Universal Backup, now Tracker
Chaqa: ?

THE FUCK is the point of this post

"oh hey guys, lets make an overview of all 2 claims so I can look like im TOTALLY CONTRIBUTING LOL"

damn bozo

Yeah. Bozo is scum this time.

He's my other lynch option today if not EMC.

Do you think I would never make a list of 2 items as town? This looks like confirmation bias, assuming you are town.

[Vecna]

Oh, this has been discussed already. Never mind.

Just to point out that was my thought. (I believe I was the first to point it out)

You were, I think. I meant that I didn't need to call attention to it, because others already had. I still think it was a good catch, and I'd like to know why Vecna did it.

Im not going to respond to this, so please just stop wasting your time and focus on other stuff.

[Jamiet99uk]

THE FUCK is the point of this post

"oh hey guys, lets make an overview of all 2 claims so I can look like im TOTALLY CONTRIBUTING LOL"

damn bozo

Yeah. Bozo is scum this time.

He's my other lynch option today if not EMC.

Do you think I would never make a list of 2 items as town? This looks like confirmation bias, assuming you are town.

That's not the main reason I think that you are scum.

[e.m.c^42]

Well I was already voting for you.

You have spent a lot of time answering questions which I quite understand. Could you remind us who your own top three scumreads are. Who are you likely to vote for?

tl;dr

Don't necessarily think Neph is scum, but I do think he's pulling his lhf tactic again for some reason, and I'd probably vote for him to trigger it and see if he wakes up in time to respond.

[e.m.c^42]

It's kind of the same for bozo. I think I called him having lost shepherd boy vibes and that hasn't changed.

On one hand: He's definitely been paying close attention as he was the first one to notice and call out that Chaqa and I had out-of-thread communication. He's made another astute observation about something similar earlier but I can't recall off top of head.

[e.m.c^42]

On the other hand, lost shepherd boy vibes.

[Vecna]

There is one mafia faction, one town faction, and a 3P faction
There is at least one 3p (obviously)
Role and alignment of the player will be revealed on flips, unless an ability prevents it

This makes me think there is an additional 3P faction outside of EMC.

He isn't a 3P faction, he's just a 3P.

So you're saying that in addition to the 3P faction, there may be another 3p that is not part of the faction? I guess it can be interpreted that way,,,

Yeah, I suspect there is like a Cult or some other non-mafia 3P out there

Didnt EMC imply he was undecisive on whether he was town or scum? (his role flavour)

[Jamiet99uk]

I don't actually have any scumreads.

Noted.

[e.m.c^42]

He's stayed consistently on Sarah and not bothered as much with other players.

[e.m.c^42]

Which really does come off as an excuse to not like, scumhunt? He's usually pretty good about finding a person, finding a flaw, questioning intensively until his query is answered, then rinse and repeat. That hasn't really happened though.

[bozotheclown]

Yeah. Bozo is scum this time.

He's my other lynch option today if not EMC.

Do you think I would never make a list of 2 items as town? This looks like confirmation bias, assuming you are town.

That's not the main reason I think that you are scum.

Yes, but you seemed to agree that it was supporting evidence, which I think is an example of confirmation bias, since I believe it is completely NAI.

[bozotheclown]

Yeah. Bozo is scum this time.

He's my other lynch option today if not EMC.

Do you think I would never make a list of 2 items as town? This looks like confirmation bias, assuming you are town.

That's not the main reason I think that you are scum.

What is the main reason you think I am scum?

[e.m.c^42]

Which really does come off as an excuse to not like, scumhunt? He's usually pretty good about finding a person, finding a flaw, questioning intensively until his query is answered, then rinse and repeat. That hasn't really happened though.

Granted Donny's thing completely overshadowed D1 and Chaqa's premature leak overtook D2 today, but still. He's very much his own agenda type of guy.

[bozotheclown]

On the other hand, lost shepherd boy vibes.

That is vague enough that I have no way to respond to it.