M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[e.m.c^42]

To elaborate on bozo. He's made several rather astute observations that no-one else has bothered to do (such as calling out that Chaqa and I shared out-of-thread communication). Town points for him.

However, at the same time he has been more pedantic than usual and asking questions that seemingly are already answered?

He's also overly fond of dead Sarah at the expense of posting thoughts about other players.

Or, was. It's been mentioned by various people but it does feel at times that he is slightly lost without mechs.

[e.m.c^42]

Speaking of which that makes me recall something dargo(?) said about damo that I disagreed with. Let me find it.

[e.m.c^42]

Speaking of which that makes me recall something dargo(?) said about damo that I disagreed with. Let me find it.

Never mind, it was brain

[xorxes]

We have to deal with it case by case. Scum doesn´t have an easy task choosing a fake claim and I don´t want to give tips to scum on scum tactics.
But I am not saying to not lynch emc because he claimed Tracker, but because I think he is town (I believe in his story, can´t find a logic reason to fake all this as scum or 3p).

That's an acceptable position. You also must believe that Donny did some weird gymnastics to learn about the secretary role then, and was also just new town looking scummy. I don't say it's impossible. If you can argue that someone is more scummy than Donny then I can be persuaded to vote elsewhere. I don't want to move to a policy lynch just because emc claimed Tracker though.

xorxes if you do assume Donny was scum, what's your theory as to why emc said anything about Donny's role at all? Why would he bother going through all this just to try to convince town that Donny was town? Why not just claim coroner or a lie detector or something?

Chaqa said that emc said something inadvertently before making his full claim. Without access to that QT it is hard to say what transpired exactly. I should ponder more about that instead of keep wasting time with this silly discussion. Unfortunately it will have to wait until tomorrow.

[e.m.c^42]

damo is town
hes happier, his posts are kinda random, talks about 3p alot but it looks like its designed to garner reactions. Im alright with damo this round.

I disagree with this but mainly the underlined part. Damo is absolutely more laid back as scum. Jokes more as scum. Last game proved it pretty well lol.

[e.m.c^42]

That wasn't a slip lmao, but how about

Xorx, I'll copy paste select parts from our QT, and you can gauge whether you think I'm skilled enough to mimic Chaqa's styling of writing this quickly :D

[xorxes]

As scum, what is my motivation in claiming Donny is town? And in such a fashion as well.

I don't know. Maybe you thought it was a good way to convince Chaqa that you were town. You apparently did convince him, so it may have been a good way to do that.

[xorxes]

Why do I pull the whole 3P shenanigan? Why do I include Chaqa in it?

You're the one who told me some games ago to look at motivations and context lol

Did you choose to include Chaqa, or did Chaqa force you to include him?

[e.m.c^42]

So, full disclosure, I didn't actually mean to recruit you, EMC. I thought I could change my orders up to the end of phase, but apparently it's a one-and-done.

The entire +1 thing is a fabrication to keep people a bit confused as to what's going on.

What's your role?

If you happen to be mafia, can you at least let me live until late game lol

Ay! Yeah, I was a bit surprised when the message popped up out of nowhere.

I'm well aware that the +1 thing was shitposting lol

Wait, this is a town role?

Oops, I thought this was an item lmao

^
This was what Chaqa thought was a slip.

lol yeah. You haven't told me your role yet, which is making me nervous.

"Wait, this is a town role?" HMMM ARE YOU NOT TOWN? Don't tell me you've betrayed me.

Lol I was 3P when you recruited me

I'm going to wait another hour or so before revealing my current role. if that is ok with you?

I want to see certain things play out in the main thread first :v

[xorxes]

Sigh... I'm not basing it on your particular claim. If he was scum, and you claim that for whatever reason you know he is town, then you are lying. If you are lying, you are scum. I don't have to believe your claim in order to think that you're scum.

I had an instant scan and he was godfather, but it was too late to save him from the lynch. Do you do the same?

I don't understand what you're asking me here.

[bozotheclown]

I could get into why I think certain players are likely town, but I doubt anyone would care.

I would certainly be interested.

As would I.

Here is the further explanation of my town reads:

Foxcastle: His participation in tracking down information about Donny's secretary reference looked to me like he was town. I know Vecna started it, but that could have been a calculated move by Vecna, where Foxcastle jumped in and would have been less like to have planned to drive a Donny lynch.

kgray: For most of her questions, I whave been interested in hearing the answers, which leads me to believe she is looking at things from a town perspective.

Nephthys: Even though I have disagreed on a number of his reads, he has not been hesitant to give his opinions, and I believe he is actively trying to figure out what is going on.

rdrivera: I have agreed with most of his observations and suggestions.

TheMarche: It seems he was paying careful attention day 1, and I doubt he was faking his question that indicated he was not aware of how scum chat worked.

summit_fever: I thought his keeping track of the mass claim opinions seemed town motivated, and I think he has made good observations.

xorxes: He is putting in his usual town level of effort and questioning things I think are worth questioning.

[e.m.c^42]

Oh lord. Haha yeah, go for it.

Don't be too nervous lol

I’ve never done anything like this before, go easy on me

Was just double checking something with worce

But tl;dr Donny was indeed the tracker, and I'm the new one lol

If you're scum with an item, oh well lmao

I'm currently tracking rivera

Wait, hold up, I need some serious details like yesterday.

Were you the one who cleaned him up?

And lol no I'm not scum.

Let's come up with a signal for who you see rivera tracking

Yeah, the cleanup was automatic from me taking his role.

Open to suggestions for other people to track

[DemonRHK]

xorx, lemme try to state what I am seeing.

I completely understand your position that if B were to become A, and A is bad, then B is bad.

What I am saying, is we don't know IF A (Donny) was bad, and it's seeming like you are discarding any new developments to focus on everything that happened prior.

If Tom Brady played for the Pats and now plays for the Bucs, He's still Tom Brady, but that doesn't mean The Bucs are the Pats, and I damn sure wouldn't bet them the same.

[e.m.c^42]

Can you describe what your role was?

As far as tracking - I think most likely NK if Donny was town are probably xorxes, Vecna, and the like.

I think rivera is fine.

Mhh, I can't quote my PM at all (unfortunately)

but it was basically a third party that would gain the role of whatever role died first.

I had thought a bit about diverting the lynch but it seemed like it would put too much attention on me lol, and gaining either scum or tracker would've been great for me

Why can't you quote it?

Closed setup, can't quote GM communications :P

For telling you my results, I might just end up writing something lol, it's easiest to find and read.

Taunt me into something involving chipotle or whatever, and based on who it includes it'll be whoever rivera visited? And if he did not visit anyone, it'll be solo

[e.m.c^42]

Xorxes, you judge :D

[xorxes]

That wasn't a slip lmao, but how about

Xorx, I'll copy paste select parts from our QT, and you can gauge whether you think I'm skilled enough to mimic Chaqa's styling of writing this quickly :D

I don't doubt that you are/were in Chaqa's QT. I think Chaqa is likely town, so I tend to trust what he has reported.

[e.m.c^42]

That wasn't a slip lmao, but how about

Xorx, I'll copy paste select parts from our QT, and you can gauge whether you think I'm skilled enough to mimic Chaqa's styling of writing this quickly :D

I don't doubt that you are/were in Chaqa's QT. I think Chaqa is likely town, so I tend to trust what he has reported.

Oh, I'm talking about what Chaqa thought was a slip but was just my paranoia. I've posted the entire relevant section in-thread.

[e.m.c^42]

That joke did not work as intended lmao

[Chaqa]

FWIW, I can confirm these are all accurate posts from the QT.

[xorxes]

So, full disclosure, I didn't actually mean to recruit you, EMC. I thought I could change my orders up to the end of phase, but apparently it's a one-and-done.

The entire +1 thing is a fabrication to keep people a bit confused as to what's going on.

What's your role?

If you happen to be mafia, can you at least let me live until late game lol

Ay! Yeah, I was a bit surprised when the message popped up out of nowhere.

I'm well aware that the +1 thing was shitposting lol

Wait, this is a town role?

Oops, I thought this was an item lmao

^
This was what Chaqa thought was a slip.

lol yeah. You haven't told me your role yet, which is making me nervous.

"Wait, this is a town role?" HMMM ARE YOU NOT TOWN? Don't tell me you've betrayed me.

Lol I was 3P when you recruited me

I'm going to wait another hour or so before revealing my current role. if that is ok with you?

I want to see certain things play out in the main thread first :v

Interesting choice of word there "recruit".