M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[xorxes]

Not going to lie, I kind of want to see town lynch tracker twice in a row after both of them claimed lol

Claiming Tracker is not a particularly strong reason not to lynch someone in a role madness game where everyone will claim something. Tracker is not even a role that has to be necessarilty town. The reason to lynch Donny had to do with a very convincing (at least to me) scumslip. If you say you inherited his alignment, it's hard to see you as town. Maybe if we can find someone more scummy I'd be willing to give you a chance to track someone, but not just because you claim Tracker.

[brainbomb]

describe the exact message sent to you about trying to track foodcoats

[brainbomb]

was he unreachable, could you not find him, did it simply say action failed

[foodcoats]

was he unreachable, could you not find him, did it simply say action failed

Is this trying to break a rule without breaking a rule?

[foodcoats]

Not to be a shit-head, I just understand we're not supposed to copy GM comms, right?

[brainbomb]

it doesnt break a rule he can paraphrase what was said if he really got a msg

[Foxcastle]

was he unreachable, could you not find him, did it simply say action failed

Is this trying to break a rule without breaking a rule?

I don't think so. A lot of other people have already said their actions failed.

[xorxes]

Why do we think Chaqa is likely Town and not a Third Party?

I think if he was third party and recruited emc he would not have made that EON post. Then again It's Chaqa and emc, so who knows. But town seems more likely unless emc flips 3p.

[brainbomb]

keywords

now granted if hes in maf chat the maf killer knows also

[foodcoats]

Who are people's scumreads, mechanics aside?

[Jamiet99uk]

describe the exact message sent to you about trying to track foodcoats

I endorse this request.

EMC should tell us what the result of his Tracker action was.

[brainbomb]

Who are people's scumreads, mechanics aside?

the lurkers
mostly

[foodcoats]

Why do we think Chaqa is likely Town and not a Third Party?

I think if he was third party and recruited emc he would not have made that EON post. Then again It's Chaqa and emc, so who knows. But town seems more likely unless emc flips 3p.

Ah, you're right. Just went back and read that.

[bozotheclown]

Why do we think Chaqa is likely Town and not a Third Party?

His role would be insanely stupid as a third party alignment I feel, and even moreso as scum.

Were you told the name of his role?

[Chaqa]

ATTENTION:

I do not believe that Chaqa or EMC are continuing to +1 posts just "to make sure they remember to keep reading posts", which is what Chaqa has claimed.

I call bullshit on that claim.

I believe that either they are compelled to keep hitting +1, suffer some penalty if they do not, or gain some bonus if they do.

Chaqa is lying about this, I'm fairly sure.

If he is telling the truth it is very easy to prove.

CHAQA - I challenge you to STOP giving +1's to posts, from this page onwards. If you keep +1-ing it will be clear you lied about why, and at that point we should lynch you.

lol fine

[foodcoats]

Who are people's scumreads, mechanics aside?

the lurkers
mostly

Yeah... it sucks that I thought I had a great scum!Chaqa read but I believe he is true blue town now.

I need to look more closely at some other players I guess.

[xorxes]

Not from last night. I mean for next EON.

How would a mass claim today help with that?

I gave two options - mass claim OR claim of those that can potentially verify emc this EON. If we go down that more limited path, then I am not suggesting mass claim. I am thinking out loud. I don't know whether it makes sense. I am asking for advice and feedback.

He already has two choices, brain and Jamie, to Track. He can choose one (obviously without saying which until EON) and hope that scum doesn't interfere.

That's assuming we don't lynch him today.

[Chaqa]

Why do we think Chaqa is likely Town and not a Third Party?

His role would be insanely stupid as a third party alignment I feel, and even moreso as scum.

lol it would be a complete meme

[Chaqa]

I think at least one of emc or Chaqa is not-town.

Or at least, it is likely that.

I'm wondering why you think that?

[bozotheclown]

Not going to lie, I kind of want to see town lynch tracker twice in a row after both of them claimed lol

Claiming Tracker is not a particularly strong reason not to lynch someone in a role madness game where everyone will claim something. Tracker is not even a role that has to be necessarilty town. The reason to lynch Donny had to do with a very convincing (at least to me) scumslip. If you say you inherited his alignment, it's hard to see you as town. Maybe if we can find someone more scummy I'd be willing to give you a chance to track someone, but not just because you claim Tracker.

I do not think a scum tracker would be very useful, I doubt that is a scum role in this game.