M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

NON VOTERS

DemonRHK
e.m.c^42
flash2015
Foxcastle
kgray
rdrivera2005
SarahK24
summit_fever
Vecna


The majority of scum are hanging back right now. there is no way those people are all town.

id say the entire wolfteam is just chilling while we debate chaqas role

[brainbomb]

##Vote Vecna

[xorxes]

Oh, at this point I'm just +1'ing to keep track of where I'm at as far as reading the thread. I really think there's only two possibilities:

EMC is scum-aligned (Secretary? or w/e Donny was) after Donny's death
OR
EMC is town-aligned Tracker after Donny's death

I don't think he is a 3P variant of whatever Donny was, but I guess it's possible.

Does it make sense, given the info worcej gave us, that there was a third party that only lasted until the first death happened and then it was no longer a third party?

@emc, if that's what you're claiming, what is your role called exactly?

@Chaqa, what is your role called exactly?

@xorxes - I won't reveal that until just before the end of night 2. I have my reasons and they are in town's best interest.

OK. I think it's better to lynch emc first anyway.

[dargorygel]

NON VOTERS

DemonRHK
e.m.c^42
flash2015
Foxcastle
kgray
rdrivera2005
SarahK24
summit_fever
Vecna


The majority of scum are hanging back right now. there is no way those people are all town.

id say the entire wolfteam is just chilling while we debate chaqas role

How many of these have taken part in the debate?

[Chaqa]

NON VOTERS

DemonRHK
e.m.c^42
flash2015
Foxcastle
kgray
rdrivera2005
SarahK24
summit_fever
Vecna


The majority of scum are hanging back right now. there is no way those people are all town.

id say the entire wolfteam is just chilling while we debate chaqas role

This seems quite probable.

If Donny was town as EMC says, then Vecna is very likely scum, no?

[flash2015]

Voting e.m.c^42 for now since in the worst case it will give us some info on what actually happened D1:

##VOTE e.m.c^42

[xorxes]

That is explicitly NOT what I said. What gives you that impression?

Maybe I misread, I will check back. Was it in the middle of N1 then?

I didn't "pass" the QT to anyone, he can't add someone to it. Did I misunderstand you?

OK, I meant pass the address to it.

[Chaqa]

Maybe I misread, I will check back. Was it in the middle of N1 then?

I didn't "pass" the QT to anyone, he can't add someone to it. Did I misunderstand you?

OK, I meant pass the address to it.

Yes, he received it during Day 1, though we couldn't speak until night.

[xorxes]

##Vote Vecna

He said he would be busy today. It doesn't mean it was not an excuse, but I don't think this vote will do anything in terms of pressure at least until tomorrow.

[Jamiet99uk]

I didn't "pass" the QT to anyone, he can't add someone to it. Did I misunderstand you?

OK, I meant pass the address to it.

Yes, he received it during Day 1, though we couldn't speak until night.

Did the QT itself reveal your full role / role name to EMC from that moment?

What is your role called?

[xorxes]

NON VOTERS

DemonRHK
e.m.c^42
flash2015
Foxcastle
kgray
rdrivera2005
SarahK24
summit_fever
Vecna


The majority of scum are hanging back right now. there is no way those people are all town.

id say the entire wolfteam is just chilling while we debate chaqas role

This seems quite probable.

If Donny was town as EMC says, then Vecna is very likely scum, no?

I don't think so. I had the exact same thoughts he had about the secretary thing and I'm town.

[Chaqa]

OK, I meant pass the address to it.

Yes, he received it during Day 1, though we couldn't speak until night.

Did the QT itself reveal your full role / role name to EMC from that moment?

What is your role called?

Yes, and as I said to xorxes I would rather wait to reveal that until an EoN2 post.

[kgray]

There's a lot going on and I've only skimmed from EON to here. I'm going back to re-read closely now, but first impressions are:

• I'm willing to believe that foodcoats is lighting rod, and is semi-confirmed town.
• Neph jumped up significantly in my scumreads.
• I don't really see how emc and Chaqa could be scum together, and if one is scum I think emc is more likely, however:
• I don't see why emc would lie about Donny being the tracker. Town could have a coroner or something like that, which could make emc's claim really risky if emc is scum trying to spread misinformation. So I'm inclined to believe Chaqa's story about emc being 3p that takes on the first dead role.

[xorxes]

There's a lot going on and I've only skimmed from EON to here. I'm going back to re-read closely now, but first impressions are:

• I'm willing to believe that foodcoats is lighting rod, and is semi-confirmed town.
• Neph jumped up significantly in my scumreads.
• I don't really see how emc and Chaqa could be scum together, and if one is scum I think emc is more likely, however:
• I don't see why emc would lie about Donny being the tracker. Town could have a coroner or something like that, which could make emc's claim really risky if emc is scum trying to spread misinformation. So I'm inclined to believe Chaqa's story about emc being 3p that takes on the first dead role.

That's not a bad point.

[xorxes]

There's a lot going on and I've only skimmed from EON to here. I'm going back to re-read closely now, but first impressions are:

• I'm willing to believe that foodcoats is lighting rod, and is semi-confirmed town.
• Neph jumped up significantly in my scumreads.
• I don't really see how emc and Chaqa could be scum together, and if one is scum I think emc is more likely, however:
• I don't see why emc would lie about Donny being the tracker. Town could have a coroner or something like that, which could make emc's claim really risky if emc is scum trying to spread misinformation. So I'm inclined to believe Chaqa's story about emc being 3p that takes on the first dead role.

That's not a bad point.

Although if emc is a rolethief and he had inadvertently confessed that to Chaqa before realizing he had stolen a mafia role, claiming Tracker was his only option.

[Chaqa]

There's a lot going on and I've only skimmed from EON to here. I'm going back to re-read closely now, but first impressions are:

• I'm willing to believe that foodcoats is lighting rod, and is semi-confirmed town.
• Neph jumped up significantly in my scumreads.
• I don't really see how emc and Chaqa could be scum together, and if one is scum I think emc is more likely, however:
• I don't see why emc would lie about Donny being the tracker. Town could have a coroner or something like that, which could make emc's claim really risky if emc is scum trying to spread misinformation. So I'm inclined to believe Chaqa's story about emc being 3p that takes on the first dead role.

That's not a bad point.

Although if emc is a rolethief and he had inadvertently confessed that to Chaqa before realizing he had stolen a mafia role, claiming Tracker was his only option.

That was one thing I thought of. EMC even said he wanted to see how the first few hours of night 1 went before revealing his role, though he did admit to being 3P almost immediately. So, I think he didn't trust me, more than he was trying to mislead me.

I lean toward EMC being a Tracker, either town or 3P-aligned.

It's possible he is a member of a 3P faction that is now a Tracker for them, I suppose.

[kgray]

There's a lot going on and I've only skimmed from EON to here. I'm going back to re-read closely now, but first impressions are:

• I'm willing to believe that foodcoats is lighting rod, and is semi-confirmed town.
• Neph jumped up significantly in my scumreads.
• I don't really see how emc and Chaqa could be scum together, and if one is scum I think emc is more likely, however:
• I don't see why emc would lie about Donny being the tracker. Town could have a coroner or something like that, which could make emc's claim really risky if emc is scum trying to spread misinformation. So I'm inclined to believe Chaqa's story about emc being 3p that takes on the first dead role.

That's not a bad point.

Although if emc is a rolethief and he had inadvertently confessed that to Chaqa before realizing he had stolen a mafia role, claiming Tracker was his only option.

Is a rolethief always mafia? If emc is mafia and he'd stolen scum!Donny's role, then emc wouldn't have "realized" he'd stolen a mafia role. He'd have known from the beginning. If he's a 3p roletheif, isn't that what Chaqa is saying? If he's a town rolethief, why would he lie about Donny's role? Is it possible that stealing Donny's role would change emc's alignment?

[Jamiet99uk]

There's a lot going on and I've only skimmed from EON to here. I'm going back to re-read closely now, but first impressions are:

• I'm willing to believe that foodcoats is lighting rod, and is semi-confirmed town.
• Neph jumped up significantly in my scumreads.
• I don't really see how emc and Chaqa could be scum together, and if one is scum I think emc is more likely, however:
• I don't see why emc would lie about Donny being the tracker. Town could have a coroner or something like that, which could make emc's claim really risky if emc is scum trying to spread misinformation. So I'm inclined to believe Chaqa's story about emc being 3p that takes on the first dead role.

That's not a bad point.

Although if emc is a rolethief and he had inadvertently confessed that to Chaqa before realizing he had stolen a mafia role, claiming Tracker was his only option.

That's not a bad point.

[brainbomb]

as soon as I show a list of lurkers

kgray and flash snap into action

[kgray]

as soon as I show a list of lurkers

kgray and flash snap into action

Suspicious timing, maybe, but yeah I'll freely admitting to lurking since EON. There was a lot of mechanics stuff going on and I didn't have time to parse through it. I'm starting to do that now.