M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Vecna]

We don't even know if it was some sort of janitor, do we? For all we know it could've been an item

For all we know it could be a passive ability that will persist untill we lynch the person causing it

Welcome to closed setups!

[xorxes]

On the contrary, the only way yours makes sense is if you know he was scum. Considering that you townread him up until the slip it just seems off that you so readily are willing to accept him as scum.

A blatant scumslip can do that, yes.

But yet there was a plausible, albiet unlikely, explanation.

Does it change your thoughts that I genuinely thought secretary was the official role as well??

Had you been considering the secretary role before he brought it up?

[Vecna]

My first conclusion is that Vecna and kgray are probably not scum with Donny. Both of them noticed and focused on the slip. Could be double bluff bussing especially from Vecna, but I won't really go there.

I noticed the mention of secretary as I was reading and I thought it was a scumslip even before reading anything else, so I have no problem regarding it as such. In fact what I noticed as I was reading is how long it took some people to notice the slip.

Xorxes noticing a scumslip and not mentioning it? really?

[Nephthys]

A blatant scumslip can do that, yes.

But yet there was a plausible, albiet unlikely, explanation.

Does it change your thoughts that I genuinely thought secretary was the official role as well??

Had you been considering the secretary role before he brought it up?

Not at all, I don't see any point in hypothesising what roles there are at this stage.

The main reason we would be considering what roles are in play are to get some conf town and personally I don't want those on D1/2 when they can be used later.

As for mafia roles, I don't see any benefit to this

[xorxes]

My first conclusion is that Vecna and kgray are probably not scum with Donny. Both of them noticed and focused on the slip. Could be double bluff bussing especially from Vecna, but I won't really go there.

I noticed the mention of secretary as I was reading and I thought it was a scumslip even before reading anything else, so I have no problem regarding it as such. In fact what I noticed as I was reading is how long it took some people to notice the slip.

Xorxes noticing a scumslip and not mentioning it? really?

Yes, because I was several pages behind, and by the time I was caught up you had already mentioned it. It was also interesting to see how others were reacting (or not reacting) to it.

[kgray]

My first conclusion is that Vecna and kgray are probably not scum with Donny. Both of them noticed and focused on the slip. Could be double bluff bussing especially from Vecna, but I won't really go there.

I noticed the mention of secretary as I was reading and I thought it was a scumslip even before reading anything else, so I have no problem regarding it as such. In fact what I noticed as I was reading is how long it took some people to notice the slip.

I didn't notice it was a slip when I first read it. I am assuming there are a lot of roles that I'm not familiar with, and I would never have guessed that he was referring to something that is apparently so specific to webDip mafia and worcej's setups. I only realized it was a slip when Vecna and others explained that. What made you think I was focused on that?

[Vecna]

Also, did I already tell you guys that Chaqa is quite possibly the scum dark horse here? He's always this eloquent and charming when he is scum, because thats when he cares more about appearances than just having a good time trolling the shit out of people.

[SarahK24]

Also, did I already tell you guys that Chaqa is quite possibly the scum dark horse here? He's always this eloquent and charming when he is scum, because thats when he cares more about appearances than just having a good time trolling the shit out of people.

Ooh

[xorxes]

But yet there was a plausible, albiet unlikely, explanation.

Does it change your thoughts that I genuinely thought secretary was the official role as well??

Had you been considering the secretary role before he brought it up?

Not at all, I don't see any point in hypothesising what roles there are at this stage.

The main reason we would be considering what roles are in play are to get some conf town and personally I don't want those on D1/2 when they can be used later.

As for mafia roles, I don't see any benefit to this

Your not wincing at Donny's hypothesis is a bit weird then. I think encryptor had been mentioned before, but not secretary, which is a less common role. And considering he is new, his bringing that specific role up was pretty strange.

[kgray]

You don't think it's a good idea?

I think its dangerous and I would generally consider you more thought out.

So you think it's completely open whether he was town or scum? You don't have an opinion one way or the other? It is something we should just ignore and move on?

Sure one might be more likely, but there's no way you're town advocating that we assume one thing and never challenge that assumption. That's silly even when it seems so likely that an assumption is true, like that two tied wagons in mylo can't both be town....

[kgray]

Alright, I think there's a very good chance that Donny is scum and it would be nice to finally vote to lynch a scumbag... so ##vote Donny.

But if emc/chaqa/anyone else think the Sarah wagon should be bigger, I'd move there. I hadn't considered vote manipulation being a possibility.

This post makes me uncomfortable.

It seems last minute attempt to save

Who do you think I could have been trying to save...?

[e.m.c^42]

We don't even know if it was some sort of janitor, do we? For all we know it could've been an item

For all we know it could be a passive ability that will persist untill we lynch the person causing it

Welcome to closed setups!

Worcej is not that cruel to unbalance that way lol

[xorxes]

My first conclusion is that Vecna and kgray are probably not scum with Donny. Both of them noticed and focused on the slip. Could be double bluff bussing especially from Vecna, but I won't really go there.

I noticed the mention of secretary as I was reading and I thought it was a scumslip even before reading anything else, so I have no problem regarding it as such. In fact what I noticed as I was reading is how long it took some people to notice the slip.

I didn't notice it was a slip when I first read it. I am assuming there are a lot of roles that I'm not familiar with, and I would never have guessed that he was referring to something that is apparently so specific to webDip mafia and worcej's setups. I only realized it was a slip when Vecna and others explained that. What made you think I was focused on that?

I mistook Sarah for you. It makes sense you would not notice. Now I have to figure out why Sarah did notice it...

[kgray]

I also believe Mafia could have a secretary, this is because votes have fluctuated a bit
I could totally be wrong though and have no basis for this claim.

What do you mean by secratary?
Like a role or something

Correction, it was Sarah, not kgray, that did this. I have to read that again, for some reason I thought it had been kgray who brought attention to this first.

Oh, I see. An easy mistake to make. We're so similar, after all

[xorxes]

I think its dangerous and I would generally consider you more thought out.

So you think it's completely open whether he was town or scum? You don't have an opinion one way or the other? It is something we should just ignore and move on?

Sure one might be more likely, but there's no way you're town advocating that we assume one thing and never challenge that assumption. That's silly even when it seems so likely that an assumption is true, like that two tied wagons in mylo can't both be town....

I'm not advocating that "we" do that, I'm stating that I'm going to be doing that (at least for the time being).

[xorxes]

What do you mean by secratary?
Like a role or something

Correction, it was Sarah, not kgray, that did this. I have to read that again, for some reason I thought it had been kgray who brought attention to this first.

Oh, I see. An easy mistake to make. We're so similar, after all

Hey, you both have a k in your name. (Was that Fox? Can't remember.)

[kgray]

Correction, it was Sarah, not kgray, that did this. I have to read that again, for some reason I thought it had been kgray who brought attention to this first.

Oh, I see. An easy mistake to make. We're so similar, after all

Hey, you both have a k in your name. (Was that Fox? Can't remember.)

Yeah, it was Fox. Thought you'd be paying closer attention though, rivera.

[xorxes]

Oh, I see. An easy mistake to make. We're so similar, after all

Hey, you both have a k in your name. (Was that Fox? Can't remember.)

Yeah, it was Fox. Thought you'd be paying closer attention though, rivera.

Wish I could say I was drinking caipirinhas at the beach...

[xorxes]

Worcej did post this later on
Another good catch. I apologize for my ineptitude - They have a faction kill, but not a faction RB.

I don't know what Donny was apologizing for here. Does anyone know?

[dargorygel]

Worcej did post this later on
Another good catch. I apologize for my ineptitude - They have a faction kill, but not a faction RB.

I don't know what Donny was apologizing for here. Does anyone know?

If he was scum, his slip.
If he was not scum... i dunno.