M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

Oh and also... if Donny is scum... very likely one of Sarah, rdr, kgray, brain or this foodcoats guy is scum for sitting on a vanity.

so if I pile on as voter #15 I get cred instead? hows that logic work

[foodcoats]

Everyone please state their favourite cheese:

foodcoats - oka traditional

[kgray]

Oh and also... if Donny is scum... very likely one of Sarah, rdr, kgray, brain or this foodcoats guy is scum for sitting on a vanity.

Good point. Wanna vote for that foodcoats guy with me?

[foodcoats]

Oh and also... if Donny is scum... very likely one of Sarah, rdr, kgray, brain or this foodcoats guy is scum for sitting on a vanity.

so if I pile on as voter #15 I get cred instead? hows that logic work

Well if you move as a result then you are clearly scum.

[e.m.c^42]

In other words, Jamie has now surpassed jmo in terms of karma and is leading the forum

Have you +1ed all posts also?

;)

[foodcoats]

Oh and also... if Donny is scum... very likely one of Sarah, rdr, kgray, brain or this foodcoats guy is scum for sitting on a vanity.

Good point. Wanna vote for that foodcoats guy with me?

Actually I think he's obvtown.

[kgray]

It seems very unlikely Donny isn't getting lynched, but for the record I'm up for Sarah as a backup plan.

[brainbomb]

Oh and also... if Donny is scum... very likely one of Sarah, rdr, kgray, brain or this foodcoats guy is scum for sitting on a vanity.

so if I pile on as voter #15 I get cred instead? hows that logic work

Well if you move as a result then you are clearly scum.

so my alignment is entirely decided based on what you think it is

[brainbomb]

nobody wants a backup plan to murk me?

[Chaqa]

I can backup this idea. It could be Sarah too, just saying...

If we were going to divert the lynch, I'd be fine with either of them.

The Donny test needs some refinement though. It's extremely open to manipulation. If we had a Watcher, they could watch Donny to see if he's roleblocked, though.

If we spend time trying to verify he is the tracker, it just wastes his power if he really is the tracker, and if we prove he is the tracker, the scum will NK him. If we do not lynch him, which does not seem very likely, we should just see what tracker results he produces.

That's essentially the conclusion I came up with in my "no half-measures" post. Either we lynch him now, or we believe him.

[e.m.c^42]

In other words, Jamie has now surpassed jmo in terms of karma and is leading the forum

Am I?

Where is the Karma ranking?

Nowhere official but it's something like you (2,7k), jmo (2,5k), brain (1,9k), dargo (1,8k), bo (1,4k) and then like Octavious or something

[bozotheclown]

It seems very unlikely Donny isn't getting lynched, but for the record I'm up for Sarah as a backup plan.

Sarah did seem to post a lot more when she was a wagon.

[Chaqa]

Everyone please state their favourite cheese:

foodcoats - oka traditional

Chaqa - provolone (or maybe mozzarella... or romano... any Italian cheese)

[brainbomb]

It seems very unlikely Donny isn't getting lynched, but for the record I'm up for Sarah as a backup plan.

Sarah did seem to post a lot more when she was a wagon.

she does that

[brainbomb]

brie bomb

[Chaqa]

My main argument toward lynching Sarah wouldn't necessarily be that she is scummy, it would be that she's a liability to town and will never be night-killed, likely to enter into endgame and be not very useful much like last game.

[Foxcastle]

I can backup this idea. It could be Sarah too, just saying...

If we were going to divert the lynch, I'd be fine with either of them.

The Donny test needs some refinement though. It's extremely open to manipulation. If we had a Watcher, they could watch Donny to see if he's roleblocked, though.

If we spend time trying to verify he is the tracker, it just wastes his power if he really is the tracker, and if we prove he is the tracker, the scum will NK him. If we do not lynch him, which does not seem very likely, we should just see what tracker results he produces.

If Donny isn't lynched, he also won't be NK'd, because either he's scum or because he's a huge question mark for town that's going to just fester in uncertainty.

[kgray]

It seems very unlikely Donny isn't getting lynched, but for the record I'm up for Sarah as a backup plan.

Sarah did seem to post a lot more when she was a wagon.

Not sure if that's alignment-indicative for her, though. She mostly responds to comments directed at or about her (or whatever is on the current page when she checks in). I got the feeling from last game that she used the bot to search her name instead of reading through the whole thread.

[e.m.c^42]

My main argument toward lynching Sarah wouldn't necessarily be that she is scummy, it would be that she's a liability to town and will never be night-killed, likely to enter into endgame and be not very useful much like last game.

I would argue that is more of Bismarck this game lol, at least for Sarah we have a single reference.

[Jamiet99uk]

Everyone please state their favourite cheese:

foodcoats - oka traditional

Chaqa - provolone (or maybe mozzarella... or romano... any Italian cheese)

Stilton