M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[Nephthys]

Anyone think it possible that damo intentionally dropped off after so many people called him out?

Now this is interesting

Is it though?

Not in and of itself no

Perhaps later if he starts pulling up 50 excuses as to why he can't be on at EOD

[Vecna]

This reminds me, I wonder why Sumfev townreads Sarah. Don't believe he's given any reasons. @summit question for you.

Kgray, you like it in the sense that "Yes, I agree Sarah is town" or "Yes, she is a distraction"? Or is this more of, just an extension to your scumread of food?

I don't know how to read her. I did lean slightscum. I am aware she played this same style while townie in a previous game. Anybody think she would be capable of pulling out the same style in her first scum game?

Considering that her particular style consists mostly of evading questions and posting irrelevant commentary, yeah. I'd say it would be pretty easy to pull off that same style.

Interesting take though after scumreading Foodcoats for flipping his thoughts.

Just goes to show; town can change their minds. I can see it, being suspicious of people using the route of "we need to lynch this day1" and seeing it can come from scum, but then looking at the over-the-place play and thinking it could be flailing scum.

[Vecna]

Why way more powerful?

My guess is that one scum is a roleblocker (Vecna already said why) and one is a janitor (hides the role of the person they kill, because there is a specific proviso for that in the rules). There's probably one or two more Mafia besides those two. Maybe a strongman, maybe a godfather or ninja.

3p is harder to guess. I hope it's not a recruiting faction, I don't like those.

Because if every town has powers, scum needs to have stronger powers to balance

TheMarche is looking townie... what scum would think this way?

Yeah, think im still pretty happy with my foodcoats read

[Vecna]

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

Flavour, or mechs? I read it as latter and usual.

If it wasn't flavor it wouldn't be in a flavor post. If worcej is trying to convey game mechanics through flavor, that's bad GMing.

What nonsense is this?

Plenty of the greatest games allow certain deductions to be made to apply logic to flavour. Guess Chaqa aint used to playing closed setups a ton?

[Vecna]

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

Pffffff!!!!!

If xorxes isn't dead by around Day 3, I say we lynch him.

Xorxes play is reminiscent of his 3p play, or his VT play. I dont think ive ever seen him play as scum this way. We know VT aint really a thing, so im guessing lowly powered PR or 3p. Still think more than likely town, but the 3p option is something not to be ignored.

[Vecna]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

im calling donny as town

[Vecna]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

FWIW, usually when brain latches onto someone this early, he turns out to be right, but forgets about it later. So, if you're scum, you should be happy, and if you're town, you don't have to worry lol

Oof, in a vacuum this post reads so much as scum soothing another scum to calm the fuck down.

(no I dont think thats what is happening here, but wtf is the point of this post chaqa?)

[Nephthys]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

FWIW, usually when brain latches onto someone this early, he turns out to be right, but forgets about it later. So, if you're scum, you should be happy, and if you're town, you don't have to worry lol

Oof, in a vacuum this post reads so much as scum soothing another scum to calm the fuck down.

(no I dont think thats what is happening here, but wtf is the point of this post chaqa?)

I think if one of them turns out to be scum the other deserves a bit of a look.

[Nephthys]

Im going to bed but will attempt to re-read in the morning.

My scum reads have been shattered and so I clearly need to sit back and look again

[TheMarche]

Do you still think kgray is scummy?

I read kgray's posts and this confused me. I don't think he's scummy anymore, but i don't think he's town either. I just don't know how he acts, and i haven't much to base my opinions on. I don't have an opinion at the moment. I noticed however that most of his posts are focused on voting Sarah, but i liked his questions. I just need to wait a bit more.

[Vecna]

I dont have any reason to think all 4 of those are town. but If they are id say we probably lose this game

I agree
##Vote Donny

##VOTE Donny Dude

I am always willing to vote for someone who votes for themselves.

Voting for someone who is self-voting when theyre obviously angry at the situation is nearly always a mistake

[Vecna]

Yea Donny is scum.

"I am annoyed at my own play"

I agree that Donny could definitely be scum and succumbed to newb-scum nerves.

He could also be a townie that was growing increasingly concerned he was at risk of being lynched. If Donny is scum he's done a fairly good job today getting some of the heat off his back. I'm currently more neutral on him, and feeling more confused.

Also calling this as town

[Vecna]

As with all things, im towny until I mislynch anyone or try to save a scum by accident. thus the sport of mafia is to not do those things.

I just cant resist the joy that comes from living an edgy lifestyle

talking about connecting A to B....

These are the type of posts you dont normally make as town but ive seen you make as scum a few times to withhold us from lynching you after you realized you made a boo-boo

[Vecna]

Lets dissect this shit: comments in the post

Alright the reread has cleared my head. I shall postulate some thoughts and ideas that have come up in my brain now.
It is no coincidence that emc and chaqa are karming everyone's posts.
I am unsure of the endgoal of it though or how it relates .
I am also not sure if Emc hand can take clicking his mouse so much so I conclude it must be very important to who he is.

Actually showing critical thought about EMC's painful hands. Noone thought of this yet. EMC must be obliged to do the +1's since his hands are hurting

Looking at Sarah's case to be lynched
She is being very evasive and I think the intense questioning of her may
be a split of scum/town
I personally think she might be 3p which would make sense as it is an undefined role for her. Plus the red text post

Not sure why he took the red text for truth, but its a thought that others have shown

I however would encourage others to take a look back at her posts and in particular Chaqa and Bozo reactions

I think Nephtys may also be scum

I wouldve actually expected town-neph to also have doubts about your allignment here. He seems pretty black/white that youre scum for your play here

I have a slight scumread on Chaqa due to evasiveness but it is not a strong one yet

Nuanced. Towny way to formulate his read

This is more related to sarah than their votes for me.
I also don't buy that he 'forgot' his vote
Brain xorxes vecna are town
also emc
Bismarck I saw was reading the thread earlier so am unsure of lurking

Paying attention to who is reading but not posting. NAI, but good to note that the newbies are noticing these things.

Demon is mia so null read but slight towards scum due to manner or tone


Brainbomb, one q
What promise would you be breaking
"but then id have to kill someone and break a promise.
just dont gun me"
If you don't wish to answer that is fine.

Guess he missed something obvious here. This is proof his post is not taillored by daychat or whatever id say but comes from him personally. Townpoints for genuine missing/mitake?

Damo i think is 3p or scum until additional info comes up.

classic calling it as he sees it as anyone would observing damo for the first time

My self-anger is not really reflected in my writings
I know I don't sound mad, but it really comes out by me looking frustrated.

If people cannot see the frustration, I really dont know what game they are reading

##Vote Nephthys
Also summit I think is town
Food coats I need to reread.

Seem like good thoughts to me

Lets see how people respond to this thing

[Vecna]

I also believe Mafia could have a secretary, this is because votes have fluctuated a bit
I could totally be wrong though and have no basis for this claim.

How do you know what a secretary is? What makes you think this?

[Vecna]

Also Bismarck you've been online so often yet aren't posting, whats up?

Interesting that he only calls this out after the wall just did

[rdrivera2005]

Because if every town has powers, scum needs to have stronger powers to balance

TheMarche is looking townie... what scum would think this way?

Yeah, think im still pretty happy with my foodcoats read

Because he stated the obvious that The Marche is town? I don't think it's a great reason.

[rdrivera2005]

I agree
##Vote Donny

##VOTE Donny Dude

I am always willing to vote for someone who votes for themselves.

Voting for someone who is self-voting when theyre obviously angry at the situation is nearly always a mistake

You can properly speak about it...

[Vecna]

im willing to vote bismark
I had him prematurely as town and thats evaporated

neph, im watching and reading. and ill judge you by who you lynch more than if I cant understand how you operate

youd be my last choice today

I still want to know how that one post made you townread him.

And him just not posting for 12 hours after that suddenly changed that? Just because two people pointed out he's showing but not posting? There was a lot to read most likely, and his first post clearly

[Vecna]

https://youtu.be/bsRNCvHXHHU

I listen to this when I scumhunt at these hours. helps me as I begin my rereads

You need something more upbeat for the quest that is scumhunting

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=reOLeLX ... 9kk-jvKoav

Wait, youre not dutch