M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[xorxes]

lets do a hypothetical


lets say darg, donny, sarah, and flash are all town.

How is brain fixated on Donny being scum?

[brainbomb]

donnys reaction appears to be one of nervous behavior. there doesnt seem to he much reason to be nervous unless he is aware that sarah, fox, darg and flash are all town as I just posited

[Donny Dude]

donnys reaction appears to be one of nervous behavior. there doesnt seem to he much reason to be nervous unless he is aware that sarah, fox, darg and flash are all town as I just posited

I seriously do not know
But read through my posts brain

[xorxes]

donnys reaction appears to be one of nervous behavior. there doesnt seem to he much reason to be nervous unless he is aware that sarah, fox, darg and flash are all town as I just posited

You posited Donny, not Fox.

[brainbomb]

donnys reaction appears to be one of nervous behavior. there doesnt seem to he much reason to be nervous unless he is aware that sarah, fox, darg and flash are all town as I just posited

You posited Donny, not Fox.

I also think fox is town. and ive been adamant about that

[Foxcastle]

I spent a lot of time last game trying to set people straight on my meta. I would prefer not to have to do that this game.

If your meta is that you "look bad" as town, does that mean you look good as scum?

Probably not. I've been lynched as scum for "looking bad", and it's not like town-metas and scum-metas are simply inverses of each other.

[Foxcastle]

risk to town:
1. the third party could be like the assassin in a previous game where they win by killing certain roles

Highly unlikely, given this:

“The goal is simple: be the last group alive. My team is equipped with the means to end you quickly, however will you be able to outwit them and overcome them yourselves? Time will tell. Just remember, there is no such thing as honor in a deathmatch…”

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

I generally agree with this, but in a closed setup, I don't blame him for looking for whatever hints to the GM's mind that he can find.

[brainbomb]

donny is sponging alot.
like with numerous posts, shooting rhk, my reads, ect
there are other examples
someone wanted massclaim
then he wanted ppl to rate their roles on a 1-10
then he wanted clarity on chaqas role

im.not seeing much solving by donny

[brainbomb]

donny doesnt display independent thinking.
his most independent manuevers involved role hunting

[brainbomb]

flash has tried to engage a lot of ppl

##Vote donny

[Donny Dude]

donny doesnt display independent thinking.
his most independent manuevers involved role hunting

I will admit to that being true.

[Foxcastle]

I spent a lot of time last game trying to set people straight on my meta. I would prefer not to have to do that this game.

You and worcej were presenting your respective metas in very similar manner: "I always look scummy", "I'm always scumread when I'm town", "that's my towntell", "woe me". I would appreciate it very much if you don't start with that again.

I find this to be a mischaracterization. I don't assert that I always look scummy, I assert that people think I do; and it's not a towntell, it's a baseline. But it's really up to town, isn't it.

[Nephthys]

@Donny why are you so fixated on brain scumreading you and yet ignoring the person who is actually voting for you?

[xorxes]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

How does voting for yourself help with any of that?

Two reasons
one I have outlined
two. I currently don't see any good lynches

The only way someone prefers to be lynched over someone else is if they are scum trying to save a more valuable teammate. Otherwise, as town, you would always prefer to lynch someone who has a chance of being scum than you who you would know for sure is town.

I suppose in this game you could know another townie's alignment as well if there's one of those couples that can talk to each other or something like that, but even so it doesn't make a lot of sense to vote for yourself.

[Donny Dude]

How does voting for yourself help with any of that?

Two reasons
one I have outlined
two. I currently don't see any good lynches

The only way someone prefers to be lynched over someone else is if they are scum trying to save a more valuable teammate. Otherwise, as town, you would always prefer to lynch someone who has a chance of being scum than you who you would know for sure is town.

I suppose in this game you could know another townie's alignment as well if there's one of those couples that can talk to each other or something like that, but even so it doesn't make a lot of sense to vote for yourself.

Alright.

[Foxcastle]

That was poorly worded @Foxcastle... I got overexcited. Sorry for the unnecessary cussing.

I'll take the cussing if you'll include a reason with it

[brainbomb]

donny the key to being good at mafia is knowing when to follow others and when to take initiative and think for yourself.

its gotta be both. even I cant just go solo. it doesnt work.

[Donny Dude]

donny the key to being good at mafia is knowing when to follow others and when to take initiative and think for yourself.

its gotta be both. even I cant just go solo. it doesnt work.

I will try some independent thinking

[brainbomb]

##Unvote

this guy is so... idk

[brainbomb]

im genuinely confused