M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[brainbomb]

I do not have any certainty other than my own gut feelings which I trust heavily wrt foxcastle

[brainbomb]

I dont understand why you think he is scum at all

[Donny Dude]

I dont have any reason to think all 4 of those are town. but If they are id say we probably lose this game

I agree
##Vote Donny

[Jamiet99uk]

So, entertaining Brainbomb's little thought experiment... it's Day 5, and Dargorygel, DonnyDude, SarahK and Flash have all been mislynched and Xorxes, Brainbomb, Vecna and Kgray have been NKed.

This leaves the following people alive:

BismarckAlive
bozotheclown
Chaqa
damo666
DemonRHK
e.m.c^42
foodcoats
Foxcastle
Jamiet99uk
Nephthys
rdrivera2005
summit_fever
TheMarche

I'd be looking at Foxcastle, Damo, and DemonRHK in particular, and possibly Chaqa.

What is the point of this flight of fancy?

[damo666]

Anyone think it possible that damo intentionally dropped off after so many people called him out?

Who called me out about what?

[Jamiet99uk]

I dont have any reason to think all 4 of those are town. but If they are id say we probably lose this game

I agree
##Vote Donny

You are voting for yourself because...… erm….?

[xorxes]

@Xorxes: 33.3333333% of your reason for voting Darg was that Chaqa was.

Are you confident about the other 66.66666666% of your reasoning?

I wasn't voting him because Chaqa was voting him, but because Chaqa said he was scum. That reason doesn't vanish just because Chaqa votes for someone else.

Did you vote him because you thought town Chaqa had worked out that Darg was scum, or because you thought that scum Chaqa was bussing his team-mate?

I just want to get this absolutely clear.

I thought that Chaqa, whatever his alignment, produced a correctish assessment of dargo's meta. I think bussing is least likely, and I think Chaqa is most likely town, but that's about it.

[brainbomb]

we entertain vague notions of fakeclaims

we entertain wild fantasies about scumslips and townslips

we entertain radical notions of entire scunteams being caught day 1 based on 1 post

why do we not entertain the possibility of ourselves being completely wrong

[Donny Dude]

I dont have any reason to think all 4 of those are town. but If they are id say we probably lose this game

I agree
##Vote Donny

You are voting for yourself because...… erm….?

Brainbomb , Do you have any scum reads other than me ?

[xorxes]

You're voting for Fox but I'm not persuaded he is scum. Can you remind me what your reasons were?

You agreed on Page 7 that I had caught him

But that was because I had missed his hidden vote.

[Jamiet99uk]

we entertain vague notions of fakeclaims

we entertain wild fantasies about scumslips and townslips

we entertain radical notions of entire scunteams being caught day 1 based on 1 post

why do we not entertain the possibility of ourselves being completely wrong

I don't know, you tell me, Brainbomb.

Because he simply isnt scum Jamie. reading his posts in comparison to any scum rand hes ever had would tell you that

You tell me...?

[Jamiet99uk]

You're voting for Fox but I'm not persuaded he is scum. Can you remind me what your reasons were?

You agreed on Page 7 that I had caught him

But that was because I had missed his hidden vote.

If he had just posted that wall of tripe without a hidden vote, why would that catch him as scum?

[xorxes]

I dont have any reason to think all 4 of those are town. but If they are id say we probably lose this game

I agree
##Vote Donny

WTF

Why do people do this shit?

[Donny Dude]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

[xorxes]

You agreed on Page 7 that I had caught him

But that was because I had missed his hidden vote.

If he had just posted that wall of tripe without a hidden vote, why would that catch him as scum?

Not that, but asking why his nonsense merited less respect than yours.

And I was slightly exaggerating when I said "caught", in case you missed that.

[Chaqa]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

FWIW, usually when brain latches onto someone this early, he turns out to be right, but forgets about it later. So, if you're scum, you should be happy, and if you're town, you don't have to worry lol

[xorxes]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

How does voting for yourself help with any of that?

[Donny Dude]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

He is also the only person to respond to my much and rightfully ridiculed
role survey.
I am also still waiting on why he voted for me.

[brainbomb]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

FWIW, usually when brain latches onto someone this early, he turns out to be right, but forgets about it later. So, if you're scum, you should be happy, and if you're town, you don't have to worry lol

pretty fair actually
accurate

[Donny Dude]

Because Brainbomb has been fixated on me being scum nearly the entire game and I want to know if he has any other scum reads because if I am so scummy,
Why is he voting for Flash?

How does voting for yourself help with any of that?

Two reasons
one I have outlined
two. I currently don't see any good lynches