M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[foodcoats]

I guess I should read while I eat this sphaget but there's so much alas

[e.m.c^42]

Isn't that true pretty often anyway? Not to be fatalistic about it, and not that town never catches scum on D1, but it's usually a mislynch. The idea that "Sarah is a good distraction" is just a specific case of "town is distracted" which is normal for Day 1.

This reminds me, I wonder why Sumfev townreads Sarah. Don't believe he's given any reasons. @summit question for you.

Kgray, you like it in the sense that "Yes, I agree Sarah is town" or "Yes, she is a distraction"? Or is this more of, just an extension to your scumread of food?

I don't know how to read her. I did lean slightscum. I am aware she played this same style while townie in a previous game. Anybody think she would be capable of pulling out the same style in her first scum game?

Yes, considering it doesn't look so intentional (or meant to be perceived as).

You won't know who I'm referring to, but I'm terribly reminded of Flavius, except much, much less verbose.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Chaqa: Why did you ignore my question to you?

What is your current view on the Dargorygel wagon which you started?

[foodcoats]

What if an inventor gives you a gun?

This is an odd line to take

I was just being contrarian, but what is odd about it?

That's an odd xorxes answer.

[e.m.c^42]

I guess I should read while I eat this sphaget but there's so much alas

I believe in the capacity of your stomach to accept all this sphaget. it neds to be et.

[Donny Dude]

This reminds me, I wonder why Sumfev townreads Sarah. Don't believe he's given any reasons. @summit question for you.

Kgray, you like it in the sense that "Yes, I agree Sarah is town" or "Yes, she is a distraction"? Or is this more of, just an extension to your scumread of food?

I don't know how to read her. I did lean slightscum. I am aware she played this same style while townie in a previous game. Anybody think she would be capable of pulling out the same style in her first scum game?

Yes, considering it doesn't look so intentional (or meant to be perceived as).

You won't know who I'm referring to, but I'm terribly reminded of Flavius, except much, much less verbose.

What happened to Flavius, I was in a game with and then he dissapeared.

[foodcoats]

We are also forgetting this. Which roles might be in game? If everyone has a power this means that scum powers are way more powerful than ours. We might have to deal with the possibility that some events may trigger two kills from scum, or other (and stronger) abilities. Any idea on what scum roles may be able to do?

Why way more powerful?

My guess is that one scum is a roleblocker (Vecna already said why) and one is a janitor (hides the role of the person they kill, because there is a specific proviso for that in the rules). There's probably one or two more Mafia besides those two. Maybe a strongman, maybe a godfather or ninja.

3p is harder to guess. I hope it's not a recruiting faction, I don't like those.

Because if every town has powers, scum needs to have stronger powers to balance

TheMarche is looking townie... what scum would think this way?

[worcej]

Vote Count 1.1
dargorygel (4) Chaqa, xorxes, damo666, SarahK24
flash2015 (4) dargorygel, Foxcastle, brainbomb*, summit_fever
Foxcastle (3) Jamiet99uk, TheMarche, foodcoats
SarahK24 (2) bozotheclown, rdrivera2005
brainbomb (1) flash2015
BismarckAlive (1) Vecna
Donny Dude (1) Nephthys
No‑Lynch (1) Donny Dude
foodcoats (1) kgray

End Votes: brainbomb (1/21) - another 10 end votes are needed to hammer the day.

Currently no one is set to by lynched. Three people are still stuck out on the beach and need to enter the forest before nightfall...

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa:
@Xorxes:

Is Dargorygel your current top scumread?

If so, please could you explain why?

lol no I forgot I was voting for him

[xorxes]

This is an odd line to take

I was just being contrarian, but what is odd about it?

That's an odd xorxes answer.

In what way? You don't think I was being honest?

[damo666]

Darg is an anagram of drag which is what D1s do, hence we should get rid of darg.

Oh no, please don't tell me you're scum again damo?

God no. Couldn't cope twice in a row!

Just having day 1 dargo fun!

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa:
@Xorxes:

Is Dargorygel your current top scumread?

If so, please could you explain why?

1) Because Chaqa said he is scum.
2) Because he has talked about very little other than the massclaim.
3) Because nobody else has beaconed me more strongly yet.

You think Dargo is scum because I said he is scum?

I was mostly joking.

[Chaqa]

Highly unlikely, given this:

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

Flavour, or mechs? I read it as latter and usual.

If it wasn't flavor it wouldn't be in a flavor post. If worcej is trying to convey game mechanics through flavor, that's bad GMing.

[damo666]

I agree with Brainbomb.

[Chaqa]

Highly unlikely, given this:

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

Pffffff!!!!!

If xorxes isn't dead by around Day 3, I say we lynch him.

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa: Why did you ignore my question to you?

What is your current view on the Dargorygel wagon which you started?

I wasn't caught up to that point yet. I catch up the Flavius way.

[Chaqa]

For now I will join ##Vote SarahK24

I think she's either scum or oblivious town like last game, and we're probably better off getting rid of her now.

[xorxes]

@Chaqa:
@Xorxes:

Is Dargorygel your current top scumread?

If so, please could you explain why?

1) Because Chaqa said he is scum.
2) Because he has talked about very little other than the massclaim.
3) Because nobody else has beaconed me more strongly yet.

You think Dargo is scum because I said he is scum?

I was mostly joking.

You said half, now it's mostly...

[xorxes]

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

Flavour, or mechs? I read it as latter and usual.

If it wasn't flavor it wouldn't be in a flavor post. If worcej is trying to convey game mechanics through flavor, that's bad GMing.

I don't think he was trying to.

[xorxes]

This post really rubs me the wrong way. town!xorxes wouldn't use flavor in his analysis.

Pffffff!!!!!

If xorxes isn't dead by around Day 3, I say we lynch him.

Deal.