M1010 Mini-Mafia

[xorxes]

For what it's worth, I think your error here is a huge towntell on you.

Which error?

His reads were actually kgray's reads.

[xorxes]

Shall we cut off his head?

If bo is JOAT it is better to lynch him first though.

why do you suppose he is joat? what evidence suggests he is lol

I'm not supposing anything, I'm just saying that's what Fox claimed.

[xorxes]

@Fox, can we have an update of your own reads now?

[Foxcastle]

Which error?

About my read on SarahK.

You claim I made an "error" yet you are refusing to explain.

How are you helping town by this behaviour?

Well, I'm not going to do your work for you, Jamiet. That wouldn't teach you anything. I have basically pointed out exactly where you need to look, and yet you have not even bothered! I really hope you a better work ethic than this to your PhD, otherwise I fear I will need to put in a word of warning to your advisor.

But, on the question of how it helps town, it did help me to establish a very strong townread on you. I hope others will see it too.

[worcej]

this is very eerily like last game in most respects

How so exactly? Eerily like 'a prominent town player is actually scum' or 'egos are clashing and not listening'?

[Jamiet99uk]

For what it's worth, I think your error here is a huge towntell on you.

Which error?

His reads were actually kgray's reads.

You mean the post on Page 85 was just meant to be a summary of what Kgray's reads had been?

Huh. I would suggest that Foxcastle erred by failing to communicate clearly. It looked to me as if he made a remark about the NK on Kgray, and then proceeded to give some reads.

Why couldn't he just clarify what he meant?

Why all the evasion and obfuscation?

[xorxes]

For what it's worth, I think your error here is a huge towntell on you.

How? Why couldn't scum have made the same mistake? It could be a towntell if you are scum, but I don't see how it's a towntell if you are town.

[worcej]

I’m just curious why you’re being shady rather than solvy, Bozo.

Because he is scum.

##vote bozo

[Jamiet99uk]

All poor or potentially misleading communication is a reaction test that is the responsibility of the reader.

Sure.

I'm going out for a walk.

[worcej]

##VOTE BOZO

Bozo, Brainbomb, and Damo.

Definitely, most likely not but hard to tell, leaning that direction at current read through.

[Jamiet99uk]

I’m just curious why you’re being shady rather than solvy, Bozo.

Because he is scum.

##vote bozo

I'm sure that's not the answer Bozo was about to give.

[xorxes]

Which error?

His reads were actually kgray's reads.

You mean the post on Page 85 was just meant to be a summary of what Kgray's reads had been?

Huh. I would suggest that Foxcastle erred by failing to communicate clearly. It looked to me as if he made a remark about the NK on Kgray, and then proceeded to give some reads.

Why couldn't he just clarify what he meant?

Why all the evasion and obfuscation?

First time I read it, it was clear to me he was reporting her reads. When you quoted it I did not remember that. So I don't think there was a problem with the initial post. Him basking in your mistake was a little silly but probably NAI.

[worcej]

OK... I won't be pushing for your lynch today, anyway. I think we have to lynch bo_sox first.

##VOTE bo_sox

I agree with you but I fear we just lose if Bo isn't scum. Are you so sure to take this risk?

Is there a less risky option? He is my strongest scumread.

Sarah, Fox, damo, brain and you are people I'm not too confident in (roughly in that order).

bozo, worcej, Jamie, emc I would say are town, but I could be wrong.

Why do you town bozo?

[Foxcastle]

@Fox, can we have an update of your own reads now?

I am less sure on Bo at the moment. I did think he was town, but I don't think he's gotten townier since yesterday, so that's a problem. Brain is also a weird question in the same vein, based on his antics, but I lean a little more townie on him.

Xorxes is town. Worcej and EMC seem townie to me. SarahK does not seem like noob scum, so she gets a townread. My gut read of Rdrivera is scum, but as I have learned, my gut read of him is reversed, so I'm tentatively marking him town.

Damo is the one that I think is scummiest in the range of "trying to look normal." I've gone sour on Bozo—I think he could be scum, because he's playing very poorly. I think he plays much better as town, and he played very well last game as scum when he didn't know his teammates.

Here's why I think Jamiet is town: scum would have been paying close attention to Kgray's reads, and paying close attention to people who were going back to try to dissect her reads. So I think in general that scum would have recognized that I was quoting Kgray's reads. Jamiet confused my summary of Kgray's reads for my own, ergo, Jamiet was not paying close attention to Kgray's reads, from which we conclude he is not scum.

[worcej]

Rdrivera is making no sense right now.

I am actually seeing a logical train of thought, but it is pretty ruthless (wanting to lynch Sarah for getting rid of a potential liability) and I am not used to seeing that side of rdr.

[Foxcastle]

All poor or potentially misleading communication is a reaction test that is the responsibility of the reader.

Sure.

I'm going out for a walk.

I quote Kgray's posts, I made comments about Kgray's posts, I made a closing summary of my views on what scum may have intended for Kgray's reads. I can't help it if you need more context clues than that.

[Foxcastle]

Which error?

His reads were actually kgray's reads.

You mean the post on Page 85 was just meant to be a summary of what Kgray's reads had been?

Huh. I would suggest that Foxcastle erred by failing to communicate clearly. It looked to me as if he made a remark about the NK on Kgray, and then proceeded to give some reads.

Why couldn't he just clarify what he meant?

Why all the evasion and obfuscation?

I'll let you answer for me:

That's easy. I'm an asshole.

[xorxes]

I agree with you but I fear we just lose if Bo isn't scum. Are you so sure to take this risk?

Is there a less risky option? He is my strongest scumread.

Sarah, Fox, damo, brain and you are people I'm not too confident in (roughly in that order).

bozo, worcej, Jamie, emc I would say are town, but I could be wrong.

Why do you town bozo?

Because his pushes have made sense to me. I will reread him to make sure I'm not being bamboozled. Without using the word "cautious", why do you scumread him?

[worcej]

yall just need to stop suckin ass at mafia, cryin out ya buttholes everytime a PR dies like its a greek tradgedy

Who was exactly crying because of the PR deaths?

[worcej]

I hope all the prs die today

You have done nothing but talk about PRs all game.

You are obsessed with PRs.

Shut up about them, then.

He may be now, but you started the PR comments on D1 before anyone else did.