M54: Not a Carrot Conspiracy

[BunnyGo]

I have not seen anything more suspicious than BunnyGo calling out Balki for a town slip based on information that it seems only the mafia would be sure about, while later claiming to not have paid much attention to the post where the "slip" occurred.

##VOTE BunnyGo

I find this compelling. ##VOTE BUNNYGO

Have you gotten to read any of my responses? I think they were all quite lucid, as opposed to bozo zeroing in and not reading/thinking.

[BunnyGo]

OK...back later. More childcare...

[Jamiet99uk]

If it was Xorxes that first pointed out Balki's potential "townslip", I find it strange that experienced players like Foxcastle and Bozo are zeroing in on BunnyGo for talking about it, but not also giving Xorxes a hard time.

Hmm.

[Foxcastle]

I have not seen anything more suspicious than BunnyGo calling out Balki for a town slip based on information that it seems only the mafia would be sure about, while later claiming to not have paid much attention to the post where the "slip" occurred.

##VOTE BunnyGo

I find this compelling. ##VOTE BUNNYGO

Have you gotten to read any of my responses? I think they were all quite lucid, as opposed to bozo zeroing in and not reading/thinking.

I do not understand why you think responding is somehow exculpatory.

[xorxes]

If it was Xorxes that first pointed out Balki's potential "townslip", I find it strange that experienced players like Foxcastle and Bozo are zeroing in on BunnyGo for talking about it, but not also giving Xorxes a hard time.

Hmm.

The difference is I didn't call it a townslip. I was hoping it was a scumslip, though in all fairness my hopes were low.

[bozotheclown]

I have a new idea for a survey. In my opinion, it is significantly easier to correctly identify town early than scum. I would like to test this by having everyone identify 5 players they think are most likely to be town. Yes, it is only half way through D1, and some players will criticize the survey as pointless, but I think the results could be interesting. Here is my list:

Balki, kgray, Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera

Balki: I doubt he would "joke" claim patient zero just to make a fake town slip

kgray: I liked her early questioning of Balki and BunnyGo

Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera: I have played a lot of mafia games with these three, so far their questions and comments seem town motivated to me.

[Foxcastle]

If it was Xorxes that first pointed out Balki's potential "townslip", I find it strange that experienced players like Foxcastle and Bozo are zeroing in on BunnyGo for talking about it, but not also giving Xorxes a hard time.

Hmm.

I'm voting BunnyGo for a few things actually.

[bozotheclown]

I have not seen anything more suspicious than BunnyGo calling out Balki for a town slip based on information that it seems only the mafia would be sure about, while later claiming to not have paid much attention to the post where the "slip" occurred.

##VOTE BunnyGo

Feel free to vote for me, but I'd at least like you to acknowledge reading ANY of my responses to you. So here is the post that pointed it all out in the first place:

@mafia, I am patient zero. Please protect me, and generally follow my lead.

@town, nothing to see here folks. I'm vanilla town.

@mafia, *wink.

Are you implying that the rest of the scumteam don't know who patient zero is?

AS I'VE SAID BEFORE.

Now, if you refuse to read my thought process, that's cool. I'm not gonna OMGUS, but it's pretty shitty of you, and you're usually better than this.

I have read and carefully considered all of your responses, and they have not successfully alleviated my suspicions.

[Jamiet99uk]

If it was Xorxes that first pointed out Balki's potential "townslip", I find it strange that experienced players like Foxcastle and Bozo are zeroing in on BunnyGo for talking about it, but not also giving Xorxes a hard time.

Hmm.

I'm voting BunnyGo for a few things actually.

Please tell us about them - because when you voted you only made reference to this one thing.

[BunnyGo]

I find this compelling. ##VOTE BUNNYGO

Have you gotten to read any of my responses? I think they were all quite lucid, as opposed to bozo zeroing in and not reading/thinking.

I do not understand why you think responding is somehow exculpatory.

As I said, feel free to vote, I just found it strange that at no point were my responses even acknowledged. As if they were being completely ignored. It's one thing to say "this is scummy, and those responses to the accusation it is scummy are not exculpatory." And it's a different thing to say "this is scummy," and at no point even acknowledge that responses were offered.

[BunnyGo]

I have not seen anything more suspicious than BunnyGo calling out Balki for a town slip based on information that it seems only the mafia would be sure about, while later claiming to not have paid much attention to the post where the "slip" occurred.

##VOTE BunnyGo

Feel free to vote for me, but I'd at least like you to acknowledge reading ANY of my responses to you. So here is the post that pointed it all out in the first place:

Are you implying that the rest of the scumteam don't know who patient zero is?

AS I'VE SAID BEFORE.

Now, if you refuse to read my thought process, that's cool. I'm not gonna OMGUS, but it's pretty shitty of you, and you're usually better than this.

I have read and carefully considered all of your responses, and they have not successfully alleviated my suspicions.

Fair enough.

[Jamiet99uk]

I have a new idea for a survey. In my opinion, it is significantly easier to correctly identify town early than scum. I would like to test this by having everyone identify 5 players they think are most likely to be town. Yes, it is only half way through D1, and some players will criticize the survey as pointless, but I think the results could be interesting. Here is my list:

Balki, kgray, Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera

<snip>

Here is my list:

Xorxes, BunnyGo, kgray, sulit.

Yeah, only four, I know. I can't give you five because there are so many people who have hardly participated. This game is very poor so far in terms of participation. More than halfway into D1 and 7 players are on 9 or fewer posts, including one newbie who hasn't posted at all.

[bozotheclown]

If it was Xorxes that first pointed out Balki's potential "townslip", I find it strange that experienced players like Foxcastle and Bozo are zeroing in on BunnyGo for talking about it, but not also giving Xorxes a hard time.

Hmm.

xorxes questioned Balki for implying that the remaining scum team does not know the identity of patient zero, which was the same question that I had when I read Balki's post. BunnyGo called out Balki for a "town slip", apparently with the knowledge that the remaining scum team does know the identity of patient zero. Maybe he was just correctly assuming this information, but I find it suspicious he was so sure. His later implying that he was not aware that Balki also claimed VT in the same post also seemed questionable.

[xorxes]

I have a new idea for a survey. In my opinion, it is significantly easier to correctly identify town early than scum. I would like to test this by having everyone identify 5 players they think are most likely to be town. Yes, it is only half way through D1, and some players will criticize the survey as pointless, but I think the results could be interesting. Here is my list:

Balki, kgray, Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera

Balki: I doubt he would "joke" claim patient zero just to make a fake town slip

kgray: I liked her early questioning of Balki and BunnyGo

Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera: I have played a lot of mafia games with these three, so far their questions and comments seem town motivated to me.

OK, I'll play, but they are still low confidence first impression reads. I reserve my right to change my mind: Jamie, brain, bozo, damo, Fox.

[rdrivera2005]

I have a new idea for a survey. In my opinion, it is significantly easier to correctly identify town early than scum. I would like to test this by having everyone identify 5 players they think are most likely to be town. Yes, it is only half way through D1, and some players will criticize the survey as pointless, but I think the results could be interesting. Here is my list:

Balki, kgray, Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera

Balki: I doubt he would "joke" claim patient zero just to make a fake town slip

kgray: I liked her early questioning of Balki and BunnyGo

Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera: I have played a lot of mafia games with these three, so far their questions and comments seem town motivated to me.

Bozo being Bozo, but I will play along

Balki, Xorxes, Kgray, Flum and Brain.

##vote Fox - I want to see his few things to vote Bunny.

[bozotheclown]

I have a new idea for a survey. In my opinion, it is significantly easier to correctly identify town early than scum. I would like to test this by having everyone identify 5 players they think are most likely to be town. Yes, it is only half way through D1, and some players will criticize the survey as pointless, but I think the results could be interesting. Here is my list:

Balki, kgray, Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera

<snip>

Here is my list:

Xorxes, BunnyGo, kgray, sulit.

Yeah, only four, I know. I can't give you five because there are so many people who have hardly participated. This game is very poor so far in terms of participation. More than halfway into D1 and 7 players are on 9 or fewer posts, including one newbie who hasn't posted at all.

thanks for participating

[BunnyGo]

I have a new idea for a survey. In my opinion, it is significantly easier to correctly identify town early than scum. I would like to test this by having everyone identify 5 players they think are most likely to be town. Yes, it is only half way through D1, and some players will criticize the survey as pointless, but I think the results could be interesting. Here is my list:

Balki, kgray, Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera

Balki: I doubt he would "joke" claim patient zero just to make a fake town slip

kgray: I liked her early questioning of Balki and BunnyGo

Jamie, xorxes, rdrivera: I have played a lot of mafia games with these three, so far their questions and comments seem town motivated to me.

It's better than what you did last game:

kgray, Balki, jamie, Damo, xorxes

[Jamiet99uk]

@Bozo:

Updated list:

Xorxes, BunnyGo, kgray, sulit, Rdrivera2020.

[damo666]

@bozo

Balki Xorxes rdr kgray bozo

[worcej]

I am hearing alot of talk about this patient 0 traitor thing. and I havent seen anything conclusive about it. What I have seen is 3 players lurking who Id like to lynch.

That and the obvious focus of some people trying to find the one isolated scum is interesting. I am more inclined to think one of those people are scum and attempting to communicate.

Why scum will try to communicate with the traitor? What's the point?

Why not? You want them to figure it out at some point so they don't push their own team, right?