M53: Mafia 1 Redux

[Jamiet99uk]

random not choosing? well I chose an online dice roller with the list from the first page, subtracted the everytime the names from the list (so at first it were 17, then 16 etc. from there to roll), that's why I got 2 different names with rolling the same number once. Here the list:
brainbomb (rolled 3)
flash2015 (rolled 6)
rdrivera2005 (rolled 12)
BunnyGo (rolled 3)
bozotheclown (rolled 2)

If I had to choose, I probably would've chosen brain, emc, jamie, RD and Vecna, maybe food, but that wasn't the question there.

The second of the 7 objects is: "Investigate all aspects of the reality-hallucination"

I am investigating this post, by Kakarroto.

What is this gibberish? The highlighted phrase, in particular, makes no logical sense in the English language. "subtracted the everytime the names from the list"?

What?

Cone on, this isn't that hard to understand even badly phrased.

Well I do not understand what the fuck he was talking about. Could you interpret it for me, O wise being?

[xorxes]

What gave you the impression Xorxes was content to let Vecna drive?

I don't think she was paying much attention to anything I was doing until I mentioned her, which was in response to a comment Vecna made about her. That's why she would think I am letting Vecna lead the investigation. Also "scum accusations" just because I thought her opening posts were bad?

Yeah, I'll have to put Kit on the scum side I think.

As a side note, this is forced.

You were the second person Kit mentioned behind bozo, I hardly find that as though you *summoned* her or anything. Going back, I hardly find you mentioning her at all, more just commenting on her post.

I would like some elaboration please

I never said I summoned her. I was explaining to Squigs why I thought that Kit would think that I was letting Vecna drive.

As you point out, I had barely mentioned her. Vecna said her opening post was bad, and I said that her second post was even worse. That was it. From that, she concluded that I was letting Vecna lead the investigation, and that I was scumreading her.

[Jamiet99uk]

##VOTE EMC

Posting weird shit, avoiding questions, invoking the mods as cover, very sketchy.

[Vecna]

@Vecna, you and xorx both arrived at opposite reads of Kit about 5 mins apart. Why no attempt to discuss it further?

(Also @xorx)

I am catching up. Hard to argue with "yikes" though.

Haha touche. Theres a reason it was mainly aimed at Vecna

I dont like arguing out my reads early on and giving people an easy roadmap on where theyll look bad for not realizing who is obvtown.

Especially with tricksy players like xorxes, ill discuss with him when im satisfied with a townread on the slot. Untill that time, its much preferably to let people read their own conclusions

[Nephthys]

I am catching up. Hard to argue with "yikes" though.

Haha touche. Theres a reason it was mainly aimed at Vecna

I dont like arguing out my reads early on and giving people an easy roadmap on where theyll look bad for not realizing who is obvtown.

Especially with tricksy players like xorxes, ill discuss with him when im satisfied with a townread on the slot. Untill that time, its much preferably to let people read their own conclusions

So you're only going to interact with people you don't rate as a player or town read?

[Nephthys]

When can we expect to see you "arguing out" your reads

[Vecna]

if youre lucky ill leave you some cliffnotes N1 right before I die

[Vecna]

Also I looked at that M44 game. Reasoning accepted.

[Nephthys]

The more I think about this worse it seems.

As town you want other people to be generating town reads. Its easier to portray town as scum that scum as town. Also, if you can say X is clearly town for Y and Z and we all agree then its VERY likely that they are actually town. This lessens the pool of scum and allows more cohesion as a unit (although clears seem to love just going AWOL once theyre clear).

Can you justify why you don't want to be showing who's town? The only thing I can think of is the SK but we need to consider that a non-factor atm.

[xorxes]

Adding Jamie to my town reads as well

Probably correct.

[Vecna]

Look, I can clearly tell when Ive done enough towntelling that ill never be in danger of getting lynched. Ive already reached that. Im never getting lynched this game.

So, I want to use my time and get as clear a picture of the gamestate as I can. That means observing people their own reasoning and analysis. People dont generally like to argue with me if I provide a solid case. Or they just say "your reasons are shit, because its all based on your dumb gut". That just aint useful to me. Especially when it concerns Xorxes.

[xorxes]

I am catching up. Hard to argue with "yikes" though.

Haha touche. Theres a reason it was mainly aimed at Vecna

I dont like arguing out my reads early on and giving people an easy roadmap on where theyll look bad for not realizing who is obvtown.

Especially with tricksy players like xorxes, ill discuss with him when im satisfied with a townread on the slot. Untill that time, its much preferably to let people read their own conclusions

Sounds like a copout for not wanting to elaborate, either because of laziness or because you don't really have much to support your point with.

[Nephthys]

Look, I can clearly tell when Ive done enough towntelling that ill never be in danger of getting lynched. Ive already reached that. Im never getting lynched this game.

So, I want to use my time and get as clear a picture of the gamestate as I can. That means observing people their own reasoning and analysis. People dont generally like to argue with me if I provide a solid case. Or they just say "your reasons are shit, because its all based on your dumb gut". That just aint useful to me. Especially when it concerns Xorxes.

I'll give you have a point for this. You are probably right however we have a SK that we need to find (all going well) which means that we hopefully will end up selectively lynching non-mafia. While you may not be around by then, it's naive to say you wont be lynched at all

[Vecna]

huh, imagine my face realizing only now theres an sk in this game.

[Vecna]

not that it changes anything.

Also, xorxes, really?

Youre acting like any of that is like, shocking, and new or whatever.

[BunnyGo]

What part of my post confuses you?

Nvm, thought you had mixed up Kit and Bun, but it was just pronoun mistake on part of Bun

Is Bun male or female? It's difficult keeping track of everyone's pronouns nowadays

Irl I am a cis male. But feel free to use any pronouns including:

It
Them
Judy
Me
You
Jackass

[xorxes]

huh, imagine my face realizing only now theres an sk in this game.

If you just realized that, then you can't possibly be the sk. Excellent!

[Vecna]

Look, I can clearly tell when Ive done enough towntelling that ill never be in danger of getting lynched. Ive already reached that. Im never getting lynched this game.

So, I want to use my time and get as clear a picture of the gamestate as I can. That means observing people their own reasoning and analysis. People dont generally like to argue with me if I provide a solid case. Or they just say "your reasons are shit, because its all based on your dumb gut". That just aint useful to me. Especially when it concerns Xorxes.

I'll give you have a point for this. You are probably right however we have a SK that we need to find (all going well) which means that we hopefully will end up selectively lynching non-mafia. While you may not be around by then, it's naive to say you wont be lynched at all

in over 30 games as town (not just on this website) ive been mislynched a grand total of twice. Maybe thrice if im misremembering or whatever.

Its not naive, its just like my hidden superpower for being so shit at scum that my towngame is superobvious.

[Vecna]

huh, imagine my face realizing only now theres an sk in this game.

If you just realized that, then you can't possibly be the sk. Excellent!

Or MAAAAYBE I was just faking it!

I love it when a plan comes together

[xorxes]

not that it changes anything.

Also, xorxes, really?

Youre acting like any of that is like, shocking, and new or whatever.

Any of what? That you're lazy?