MAFIA 52: You Can't Take The Sky From Me [HIDDEN]

[damo666]

OK. Happy with me reading Fox?

Obviously not if we are lynching Fox.

I was asking Xorxes assuming we are following Xorxes' plan in lynching Temasek today and Fox or Chaqa tomorrow depending on the result I get on today's read.

[dargorygel]

I watched Jamie... No one visited him

[damo666]

Why are you in such a hurry damo?

Following Xorxes' plan is fairly automatic, I don't see any advantage in waiting.

dargo could potentially clear Jamiet.

And now we know Bunny was a Reaver, we may be able to figure something out about the violations.

OK

[xorxes]

I watched Jamie... No one visited him

Too bad you didn't watch me.

They were not going to kill Jamiet when there's a backup Doctor.

[Jamiet99uk]

I watched Jamie... No one visited him

Too bad you didn't watch me.

They were not going to kill Jamiet when there's a backup Doctor.

Indeed.

[dargorygel]

I watched Jamie... No one visited him

Too bad you didn't watch me.

They were not going to kill Jamiet when there's a backup Doctor.

Good point... Bad choice. I considered bunny. Wish I'd gone there

[damo666]

Also if we lynch Tem there is a fair chance the Assassin and last remaining Reaver may target the same person tomorrow night and town only suffer one NK and we have room for 2 mislynches.

[xorxes]

Confirmed started as PR
xorxes (Captain)
peterlund (Hero of Mudtown)
teacon (Twin)
darg (Watcher)
damo (Reader)
Jamie (Doctor)

Claimed VT
emc (confirmed by damo)
Chaqa
Foxcastle

Scum
Temasek (Reaver Prime)

Dead
FlaviusAetius (VT)
rdrivera2005 (Twin)
ItsHosuke (Companion)
Kalel (MAFIA Customs)
bozo (VT)
worcej (MAFIA Agent)
Tom Bombadil (First Mate)
ND (Backup Companion)
Goldfinger (Bounty Hunter)
BunnyGo (Pilot) REAVERED

[damo666]

I watched Jamie... No one visited him

Too bad you didn't watch me.

They were not going to kill Jamiet when there's a backup Doctor.

Good point... Bad choice. I considered bunny. Wish I'd gone there

Shame you didn't.

[dargorygel]

Confirmed started as PR
xorxes (Captain)
peterlund (Hero of Mudtown)
teacon (Twin)
darg (Watcher)
damo (Reader)
Jamie (Doctor)

Claimed VT
emc (confirmed by damo)
Chaqa
Foxcastle

Scum
Temasek (Reaver Prime)

Dead
FlaviusAetius (VT)
rdrivera2005 (Twin)
ItsHosuke (Companion)
Kalel (MAFIA Customs)
bozo (VT)
worcej (MAFIA Agent)
Tom Bombadil (First Mate)
ND (Backup Companion)
Goldfinger (Bounty Hunter)
BunnyGo (Pilot) REAVERED

I'm sorry... I need to carefully catch up... But I thought we were not sure tem was prime?

[xorxes]

Confirmed started as PR
xorxes (Captain)
peterlund (Hero of Mudtown)
teacon (Twin)
darg (Watcher)
damo (Reader)
Jamie (Doctor)

Claimed VT
emc (confirmed by damo)
Chaqa
Foxcastle

Scum
Temasek (Reaver Prime)

Dead
FlaviusAetius (VT)
rdrivera2005 (Twin)
ItsHosuke (Companion)
Kalel (MAFIA Customs)
bozo (VT)
worcej (MAFIA Agent)
Tom Bombadil (First Mate)
ND (Backup Companion)
Goldfinger (Bounty Hunter)
BunnyGo (Pilot) REAVERED

I'm sorry... I need to carefully catch up... But I thought we were not sure tem was prime?

Now we're sure. He has to be. If damo was lying about him being Prime, then damo has to be a Reaver. But then the only Reaver left is Reaver Prime.

If damo is not a Reaver, then we can trust his read.

Either way, Temasek is Reaver Prime.

[xorxes]

@damo, I think scanning Chaqa might be better because Chaqa is one of the four people that posted between EON3 and the D4 violation announcement. If you clear him, we still get Fox as Assassin, but we have also cleared Chaqa from being a Reaver. Two birds with one stone.

[xorxes]

emc is now Reaver clear as well, btw, even if damo isn't.

damo not Reaver -> emc not Reaver, nor Assassin.
damo Reaver -> emc not Reaver, possibly Assassin.

[damo666]

@damo, I think scanning Chaqa might be better because Chaqa is one of the four people that posted between EON3 and the D4 violation announcement. If you clear him, we still get Fox as Assassin, but we have also cleared Chaqa from being a Reaver. Two birds with one stone.

OK. Hoping GMs will allow me to change.

[xorxes]

Actions update:

D1:
xorxes revealed as Captain
damo reads Flav as town
Town lynches Flav (VT)

N1:
peter shoots Tom's bulletproof
dargo watches xorxes, sees Jamiet visit
Jamiet protects xorxes
Tom protects bozo
Superstition doesn't roleblock anyone
teacon redirects to rivera
rivera doesn't redirect
worcej kills rivera (directly or indirectly)
Kalel roleblocks ??????
Investigator investigates ?????
Reaver Prime (Temasek) visits ??????

D2:
Town lynches Hosuke (Companion)
damo reads ND (VT)

N2:
ND didn't roleblock anyone
dargo watches xorxes, noone visits
Jamiet protects and saves dargo
worcej fails to kill dargo
Tom protects damo
Kalel roleblocks damo
Investigator investigates ??????
Reaver Prime (Temasek) visits ??????

D3:
Town lynches Kalel (Mafia Roleblocker)
damo roleblocked

N3:
ND roleblocks goldie
dargo watches himself, Tom protects him
Tom protects dargo
Jamiet protects someone who is not attacked
worcej kills bozo
Investigator investigates ??????
Reaver Prime (Temasek) visits ??????

D4:
Town lynches worcej (Mafia Agent)
damo reads Temasek (Reaver Prime)
Temasek revealed by GM as part of Reavers

N4:
ND roleblocks Temasek but is assassinated
Jamiet tries to save ND
dargo watches damo and sees noone visit him
Temasek kills Tom
Assassin kills ND

D5:
Town lynches goldfinger (BH)
damo reads emc (VT)

N6:
Jamiet protects xorxes
dargo watches Jamiet and sees noone visit him
Assassin kills Bunny (Pilot - REAVERED)
Temasek holds his kill

[xorxes]

@damo, I think scanning Chaqa might be better because Chaqa is one of the four people that posted between EON3 and the D4 violation announcement. If you clear him, we still get Fox as Assassin, but we have also cleared Chaqa from being a Reaver. Two birds with one stone.

OK. Hoping GMs will allow me to change.

I suppose it could go the other way as well. Fox's interrogation of Chaqa about the Reavers was kind of weird. I need to reread it.

[xorxes]

@damo, I think scanning Chaqa might be better because Chaqa is one of the four people that posted between EON3 and the D4 violation announcement. If you clear him, we still get Fox as Assassin, but we have also cleared Chaqa from being a Reaver. Two birds with one stone.

OK. Hoping GMs will allow me to change.

I suppose it could go the other way as well. Fox's interrogation of Chaqa about the Reavers was kind of weird. I need to reread it.

Ideal scenario is that you hit the jackpot and read one of them as Reaver. Then it's autowin.

[Chaqa]

Well, from my perspective, this game is (mostly) solved if damo is still town. That means Fox is Assassin, Tem is RP, xorx is town, etc.

If damo isn’t town, it’s a little more dicey.

I’ll try to dig into Bunny’s posts about Reavers a bit more, but I have a hunch that he was converted Night 2 after a failed attempt night 1

[Chaqa]

Temasek probably wouldn’t withhold his kill if he thought his second and third Reavers were likely to be lynched. Makes me think Reaver 2 is damo or Jamie after all.

Why didn’t Jamie and Dargo coordinate to prove themselves? :/

[xorxes]

Well, from my perspective, this game is (mostly) solved if damo is still town. That means Fox is Assassin, Tem is RP, xorx is town, etc.

If damo isn’t town, it’s a little more dicey.

I’ll try to dig into Bunny’s posts about Reavers a bit more, but I have a hunch that he was converted Night 2 after a failed attempt night 1

Or converted Night 3 after a failed attempt night 2. But yes, conversion after a failed attempt makes sense.