MAFIA 52: You Can't Take The Sky From Me [HIDDEN]

[BunnyGo]

Great outcome, no dead town.

It seems like there was an RB on Maf1 NK (=godfather "LAWRENCE DOBSON, the AGENT (Rank 1)").

Someone seems to know who the godfather is. It would certainly be interesting for town to know who the godfather is.

##CALL GM: If the Maf1 member performing the NK, is reavered the same night. Does the NK go through anyhow before he/she is converted to reaver?

Yes. Where Mafia 1 and Mafia 2 actions conflict, Mafia 1 is considered to be the tie breaker. In this instance the NK would go through.

##CALL GM: If the top ranked Maf1 player is reavered, will he/she continue to order the Maf1 NK?

Yes. The top ranking Maf1 player would retain control of the faction nk, while losing any individual powers they may have from their role.

Cool

[xorxes]

At a rest area. I visited xorxes again... I know some said to try a candidate for reaver, but I was unsure. I did expect someone to kill xorxes, so I watched him.
No one came.

There was an attempt iny life, but a doc saved me.

Sorry I chose poorly

It was a good choice, I was a strong NK candidate since Jamie could not have protected me last night. Guessing the Reaver's target is much harder, it could be almost anyone, and besides out best RP guess was supposedly roleblocked, so he could not visit anyone.

Having said that, don't be so quick to reveal who you watch next time. I wanted to hear from Tom first who he protected. Now he can say anyone else and we don't learn anything from that.

[xorxes]

At a rest area. I visited xorxes again... I know some said to try a candidate for reaver, but I was unsure. I did expect someone to kill xorxes, so I watched him.
No one came.

There was an attempt iny life, but a doc saved me.

Sorry I chose poorly

I have received confirmation that I saved you.

You're welcome.

Nice job!

[Foxcastle]

Rough weekend here, sorry for the lack of participation. I should be online more starting tomorrow.

[xorxes]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

[Chaqa]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

What makes you think there aren’t already three Reaver’d? Are you That sure Goldie is RP?

[xorxes]

@damo, you may want to consider a read of Tom tonight, although you may have been roleblocked.

[xorxes]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

What makes you think there aren’t already three Reaver’d? Are you That sure Goldie is RP?

Did you read what I wrote? "If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight."

In this case, killing goldfinger will not prevent anything.

[Chaqa]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

What makes you think there aren’t already three Reaver’d? Are you That sure Goldie is RP?

Did you read what I wrote? "If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight."

In this case, killing goldfinger will not prevent anything.

Oh, I missed that. Sorry, currently sulking in defeat to the Seahawks...

Goldie May have been roleblocked, though.

[xorxes]

What makes you think there aren’t already three Reaver’d? Are you That sure Goldie is RP?

Did you read what I wrote? "If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight."

In this case, killing goldfinger will not prevent anything.

Oh, I missed that. Sorry, currently sulking in defeat to the Seahawks...

Goldie May have been roleblocked, though.

I certainly hope so. And he should be roleblocked N3 again. If there's only one death N3, we can be pretty sure we were right about goldie.

[BunnyGo]

At a rest area. I visited xorxes again... I know some said to try a candidate for reaver, but I was unsure. I did expect someone to kill xorxes, so I watched him.
No one came.

There was an attempt iny life, but a doc saved me.

Sorry I chose poorly

It was a good choice, I was a strong NK candidate since Jamie could not have protected me last night. Guessing the Reaver's target is much harder, it could be almost anyone, and besides out best RP guess was supposedly roleblocked, so he could not visit anyone.

Having said that, don't be so quick to reveal who you watch next time. I wanted to hear from Tom first who he protected. Now he can say anyone else and we don't learn anything from that.

I think my sexy wife should stay silent on this fact for now.

[goldfinger0303]

@Kalel - who did you roleblock

[xorxes]

At a rest area. I visited xorxes again... I know some said to try a candidate for reaver, but I was unsure. I did expect someone to kill xorxes, so I watched him.
No one came.

There was an attempt iny life, but a doc saved me.

Sorry I chose poorly

It was a good choice, I was a strong NK candidate since Jamie could not have protected me last night. Guessing the Reaver's target is much harder, it could be almost anyone, and besides out best RP guess was supposedly roleblocked, so he could not visit anyone.

Having said that, don't be so quick to reveal who you watch next time. I wanted to hear from Tom first who he protected. Now he can say anyone else and we don't learn anything from that.

I think my sexy wife should stay silent on this fact for now.

Why? It doesn't say it can't be used consecutively on the same person. I'm not sure why he should stay silent, but maybe I'm missing something.

You, on the other hand, should talk way less about what you may or may not have done with your power in previous nights.

[BunnyGo]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

If we're really wanting to go all in on goldfinger being RP (and not successfully spreading night 1), he can be commuted to prevent the spread more...

[BunnyGo]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

What makes you think there aren’t already three Reaver’d? Are you That sure Goldie is RP?

No...but I think it's worth pretending it is AND that he missed night 1. If we're wrong, oh well, if we're right it's good for us to protect that scenario.

[BunnyGo]

It was a good choice, I was a strong NK candidate since Jamie could not have protected me last night. Guessing the Reaver's target is much harder, it could be almost anyone, and besides out best RP guess was supposedly roleblocked, so he could not visit anyone.

Having said that, don't be so quick to reveal who you watch next time. I wanted to hear from Tom first who he protected. Now he can say anyone else and we don't learn anything from that.

I think my sexy wife should stay silent on this fact for now.

Why? It doesn't say it can't be used consecutively on the same person. I'm not sure why he should stay silent, but maybe I'm missing something.

You, on the other hand, should talk way less about what you may or may not have done with your power in previous nights.

Sorry, I thought you'd want to confirm I still had my powers to the group anyways. Wasn't that the plan?

[BunnyGo]

It was a good choice, I was a strong NK candidate since Jamie could not have protected me last night. Guessing the Reaver's target is much harder, it could be almost anyone, and besides out best RP guess was supposedly roleblocked, so he could not visit anyone.

Having said that, don't be so quick to reveal who you watch next time. I wanted to hear from Tom first who he protected. Now he can say anyone else and we don't learn anything from that.

I think my sexy wife should stay silent on this fact for now.

Why? It doesn't say it can't be used consecutively on the same person. I'm not sure why he should stay silent, but maybe I'm missing something.

You, on the other hand, should talk way less about what you may or may not have done with your power in previous nights.

I think Tom gives away guesses of what will be bodyguarded tomorrow. I think we preserve a very powerful combo of doctor protects Tom and Tom protects other person...This way the doctor protects 2 people at once.

[KalelChase]

@Kalel - who did you roleblock

As if you didn't know.

[KalelChase]

Let's think about it some more people. I think ##VOTE Kalel is the way to go today.

Here's my reasoning:

If we lynch goldfinger, then we need to be sure who to roleblock N3 so that Reaver2 doesn't recruit. I think it's likely to be Tom, but do we want to gamble on that?

If we kill the roleblocker, and keep roleblocking goldfinger, the Reavers don't grow. Also we get rid of the most annoying Mafia member, who can roleblock any one of our useful PRs.

If we're wrong about goldfinger being the RP (which I don't think we are) then killing him doesn't get us much: the Reavers are already three. And we will find out the truth tonight.

So I think Kalel is the best way to go today.

Thoughts?

I win most annoying? Not the trophy I was going for.

The only way to have a chance of not having 3 reavers out there is to kill Goldie today.

[Tom Bombadil]

I think my sexy wife should stay silent on this fact for now.

Why? It doesn't say it can't be used consecutively on the same person. I'm not sure why he should stay silent, but maybe I'm missing something.

You, on the other hand, should talk way less about what you may or may not have done with your power in previous nights.

I think Tom gives away guesses of what will be bodyguarded tomorrow. I think we preserve a very powerful combo of doctor protects Tom and Tom protects other person...This way the doctor protects 2 people at once.

I can guard the same person consecutively so it doesn’t really matter