MAFIA 52: You Can't Take The Sky From Me [HIDDEN]

[xorxes]

So it seems highly unlikely that goldfinger is in a team with two VT claimants.

Absolutely agreed. Because I am not on a scum team

I think your main problem is explaining the two Companion claims.

If Jamiet is the Roleblocker, why did two people claim Companion, who is lying, and how did they decide to claim that role specifically?

[BunnyGo]

So it seems highly unlikely that goldfinger is in a team with two VT claimants.

Absolutely agreed. Because I am not on a scum team

I think your main problem is explaining the two Companion claims.

If Jamiet is the Roleblocker, why did two people claim Companion, who is lying, and how did they decide to claim that role specifically?

Agreed. And I think Jamie’s outburst is his hardest part.

[goldfinger0303]

So it seems highly unlikely that goldfinger is in a team with two VT claimants.

Absolutely agreed. Because I am not on a scum team

I think your main problem is explaining the two Companion claims.

If Jamiet is the Roleblocker, why did two people claim Companion, who is lying, and how did they decide to claim that role specifically?

Honestly, I think that the reaper prime is between worcej and the companion claims (assuming that you have not been reaper'd, which I think unlikely). The other is the investigator. Remember Bunny's analysis that showed worcej and Kalel as the two most likely to have violated the press restrictions?

[Chaqa]

Still say Jamie is Doc, Hosuke is RB.

Goldie is probably RP. Doctor is a good one to claim as it can explain visits without risking too many counter-verifiable claims.

This leaves Agent and Investigator in the VT claims, or worcej.

[Chaqa]

Still say Jamie is Doc, Hosuke is RB.

Goldie is probably RP. Doctor is a good one to claim as it can explain visits without risking too many counter-verifiable claims.

This leaves Agent and Investigator in the VT claims, or worcej.

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

[xorxes]

Still say Jamie is Doc, Hosuke is RB.

Goldie is probably RP. Doctor is a good one to claim as it can explain visits without risking too many counter-verifiable claims.

This leaves Agent and Investigator in the VT claims, or worcej.

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

You have not been reading the thread in full, have you?

[goldfinger0303]

I swear, Chaqa's analyses are all half-baked today. Is he always like this, or was my last game where he was spot-on just an anomaly?

[BunnyGo]

Still say Jamie is Doc, Hosuke is RB.

Goldie is probably RP. Doctor is a good one to claim as it can explain visits without risking too many counter-verifiable claims.

This leaves Agent and Investigator in the VT claims, or worcej.

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

You have not been reading the thread in full, have you?

I mean...it’s nice he repeats things for us.

[BunnyGo]

I swear, Chaqa's analyses are all half-baked today. Is he always like this, or was my last game where he was spot-on just an anomaly?

Last game wasn’t great either. But he’s enthusiastic.

[Chaqa]

Still say Jamie is Doc, Hosuke is RB.

Goldie is probably RP. Doctor is a good one to claim as it can explain visits without risking too many counter-verifiable claims.

This leaves Agent and Investigator in the VT claims, or worcej.

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

You have not been reading the thread in full, have you?

Did I miss something big?

I’ve been a bit preoccupied the last day or so

[BunnyGo]

@Kalel, did you find my crumb? I figured of all the players you’d be the most likely to.

[BunnyGo]

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

You have not been reading the thread in full, have you?

Did I miss something big?

I’ve been a bit preoccupied the last day or so

No. Just all this has been said at least twice. Like I said, repeating it is nice.

[Chaqa]

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

You have not been reading the thread in full, have you?

I mean...it’s nice he repeats things for us.

I’ve been saying all of this for the whole day. I get no credit :p

[Jamiet99uk]

Could it be that Goldfinger was bussing his team-mate EMC a little too hard, and his other team-mate Bozo warned him off?

I am not asking Goldfinger to answer this, because I know he is a liar, therefore his answer will probably be a lie. However, I would like everyone else to consider this.

Unlikely.

If goldfinger is Mafia1, then given that you would not be the roleblocker, then Hosuke/Kalel is likely the roleblocker. That means only one Mafia1 claimed VT (presumably the Agent) and so goldfinger would be the Investigator.

That would mean the other scum VT would be the Reaver (or worcej is the Reaver and the other VT the Bounty Hunter).

So it seems highly unlikely that goldfinger is in a team with two VT claimants.

Not to mention that one Mafia member warning another that they're bussing a third member a little too hard just never happens.

Then what is your own interpretation, Xorxes, of the events I described, in which Goldfinger went from strongly pushing an EMC lynch, to criticising people for voting EMC, in very short space of time? Tell me what you think about it.

[xorxes]

And if I’m right. Goldie converted Tom, I think,

You have not been reading the thread in full, have you?

Did I miss something big?

I’ve been a bit preoccupied the last day or so

I said a couple pages back more or less the same you just did.

[xorxes]

Unlikely.

If goldfinger is Mafia1, then given that you would not be the roleblocker, then Hosuke/Kalel is likely the roleblocker. That means only one Mafia1 claimed VT (presumably the Agent) and so goldfinger would be the Investigator.

That would mean the other scum VT would be the Reaver (or worcej is the Reaver and the other VT the Bounty Hunter).

So it seems highly unlikely that goldfinger is in a team with two VT claimants.

Not to mention that one Mafia member warning another that they're bussing a third member a little too hard just never happens.

Then what is your own interpretation, Xorxes, of the events I described, in which Goldfinger went from strongly pushing an EMC lynch, to criticising people for voting EMC, in very short space of time? Tell me what you think about it.

If he is the Reaver, he may not care that his views are not too consistent.

If he is teammates with emc (which would mean emc is the Agent), bozo was just an innocent bystander.

[Jamiet99uk]

So it seems highly unlikely that goldfinger is in a team with two VT claimants.

Absolutely agreed.

Town ought to have at least two genuine VT claimants left alive.

You agree you are not on a team with two VT claimants.

This is interesting.

[BunnyGo]

FYI I’ll likely miss EOD. This shouldn’t matter as I’m not allowed to move my vote.

[Jamiet99uk]

Absolutely agreed. Because I am not on a scum team

I think your main problem is explaining the two Companion claims.

If Jamiet is the Roleblocker, why did two people claim Companion, who is lying, and how did they decide to claim that role specifically?

Agreed. And I think Jamie’s outburst is his hardest part.

I am a hot-headed borderline alcoholic. I average 1.2 emotional outbursts per game.

[goldfinger0303]

Then what is your own interpretation, Xorxes, of the events I described, in which Goldfinger went from strongly pushing an EMC lynch, to criticising people for voting EMC, in very short space of time? Tell me what you think about it.

If you go back, when I voted for emc, peterlund and Kalel pretty much immediately joined the wagon without being too convincing. bozo pointed this out, and I was wary of the sheeping.