MAFIA 51 - LONDON BY GASLIGHT [HIDDEN]

[purplecow]

Uggh fine but if your lying tom...
##vote rdr

[CmdrLikely]

Yes it's a good wagon, afaict
##VOTE rdrivera2005

[rdrivera2005]

I have a guilty on rivera. Watched xorxes night two.

Lynch rivera. First post of the game signaled who I was scanning. First post D2 was posting the guilty results

You are lying. Sherlock please don't Cc.

[Kitsune]

Right, I misread Tom's post as saying he saw Rdr watching Xorxes.

On re-read he's saying he watched Xorx, which makes SOME sense.

Except.

I still don't see any roles who could have done anything suspect to Xorxes N1.

He wasn't night killed.

He wasn't roleblocked, because that was on ND.

He couldn't have been grave robbed, he wasn't dead.

And we know Rdr isn't Moriarty, because he's dead.

I know we're short on time, but this doesn't quite gel for me.

[Kitsune]

No, I don't believe it.

##Vote Tom Bombadil

[e.m.c^42]

Worst case, Rivera flips VT or something, and we lynch Tom next day, or something like that yeah?

[Chaqa]

I have a guilty on rivera. Watched xorxes night two.

Lynch rivera. First post of the game signaled who I was scanning. First post D2 was posting the guilty results

You are lying. Sherlock please don't Cc.

If he's lying, we'll lynch him tomorrow. If you're town, give us your final thoughts and observations in the next five minutes.

[FlaviusAetius]

Okay, want to get a vote in just in case on a busy day, but has to be justified.
Did full game ISO on top 3...

##Vote CmdrLikely

And here's why (admittedly many of these only hold weight in context after knowing identities)....

D1
Pg7 - Shitty icebreaker (according to ND... more below)
Pg21 - Vote Computer_Genius due to low posting, but only posted 4 times themselves
Pg26 - Stayed on C.G. seemed to be protecting Bob, with efforts to align/pocket ND
D2
Pg44 Suspicious of Frostwind
Pg52 - Kill ND and Chaqa and town will be sitting pretty.
Pg64 - Argument with Flav and Xorx, very adamantly stating ND is town liability.
Pg82 - The infamous "I was trying my best to be town"
Pg99 - ND votes purple, response, "LOL, are you sure?" (He's clearly sparing with ND who is the closest thing to a town clear we have).
Page 102 - Voting Flav because he's voting Yav (well several others are voting Yav too). Then turns around and questions Yav?

Between these items and the fact that I town-lean Xorx and Bionic after ISOing them here's my vote.

Ugh..

He gave a reasonable explanation for the trying to be town confusion, wouldn't you agree?

And sparing with ND would be more town indicative, I think. Or bold scum.

Nothing in that case is very convincing.

I think I will bail out. ##VOTE Chaqa

I am convinced as well, Chaqa the act is up, I will be voting for Chaqa tomorrow too after we get Yavu

[ND]

Purplecow and Kit are scum

Chaqa is back to a scum lean

[Chaqa]

Right, I misread Tom's post as saying he saw Rdr watching Xorxes.

On re-read he's saying he watched Xorx, which makes SOME sense.

Except.

I still don't see any roles who could have done anything suspect to Xorxes N1.

He wasn't night killed.

He wasn't roleblocked, because that was on ND.

He couldn't have been grave robbed, he wasn't dead.

And we know Rdr isn't Moriarty, because he's dead.

I know we're short on time, but this doesn't quite gel for me.

KIt, you're still not getting it. Tom is saying:

On Night 1, he INVESTIGATED RIVERA and got a Guilty (Evil) scan.
On Night 2, he WATCHED XORXES and hasn't said if anyone visited xorx.

the cop in this game is like a JOAT Cop with 4 one-shot abilities.

[bozotheclown]

I have a guilty on rivera. Watched xorxes night two.

Lynch rivera. First post of the game signaled who I was scanning. First post D2 was posting the guilty results

You are lying. Sherlock please don't Cc.

If he is we will find out very soon.

[FlaviusAetius]

I have a guilty on rivera. Watched xorxes night two.

Lynch rivera. First post of the game signaled who I was scanning. First post D2 was posting the guilty results

##vote rdr

[Chaqa]

Purplecow and Kit are scum

Chaqa is back to a scum lean

Agreed on kIt, purplecow is possible too.

I wish we had a vig so they could just shoot me and solve this all.

[Vecna]

##vote rdrivera

[Kitsune]

Right, I misread Tom's post as saying he saw Rdr watching Xorxes.

On re-read he's saying he watched Xorx, which makes SOME sense.

Except.

I still don't see any roles who could have done anything suspect to Xorxes N1.

He wasn't night killed.

He wasn't roleblocked, because that was on ND.

He couldn't have been grave robbed, he wasn't dead.

And we know Rdr isn't Moriarty, because he's dead.

I know we're short on time, but this doesn't quite gel for me.

KIt, you're still not getting it. Tom is saying:

On Night 1, he INVESTIGATED RIVERA and got a Guilty (Evil) scan.
On Night 2, he WATCHED XORXES and hasn't said if anyone visited xorx.

the cop in this game is like a JOAT Cop with 4 one-shot abilities.

Oh.

Well then I don't feel comfortable voting for either of them so I'll go back to my original scumlean and you can use that information after I'm nk'd shortly.

You don't need my vote on Rdr anyway.

##vote bozo

[FlaviusAetius]

I still think Yavu is scum, but if tom is lying, this gurantees their both scum, if not then yavu's case is weaker, and I might go onto Chaqa instead...

[Vecna]

reasons for not outing it eon2 though? seems quite convenient to out this now

[Jamiet99uk]

===============
DAY HAS ENDED
PLEASE HOLD

[xorxes]

Right, I misread Tom's post as saying he saw Rdr watching Xorxes.

On re-read he's saying he watched Xorx, which makes SOME sense.

Except.

I still don't see any roles who could have done anything suspect to Xorxes N1.

He wasn't night killed.

He wasn't roleblocked, because that was on ND.

He couldn't have been grave robbed, he wasn't dead.

And we know Rdr isn't Moriarty, because he's dead.

I know we're short on time, but this doesn't quite gel for me.

He didn't say he saw anything. Just watched.

[e.m.c^42]

Eh, regardless of flip we'll have a scum lynch eventually, either Rivera or Tom