MAFIA 51 - LONDON BY GASLIGHT [HIDDEN]

[Chaqa]

I think this is as good point, why you now say you find Chaqa's female VT claim believable? I do not see how that has anything to do with this apparent contradiction.

I just think scum would not claim female because of Jack.

OK, but I am finding it hard to believe any Chaqa claim at this point.

Sigh.

I rolled female VT, knew that female roles were dangerous to Jack, and came up with what I thought would be a very interesting and effective strategy for me to leverage an early death into information.

I had now way of knowing ND would be strong-crumbing Sherlock and then get targeted by everyone and their mother, turning the entire thing into a clusterfuck. Then on Day 2, I wanted to see if any mafia members showed their hand, but I TBH haven't examined it too closely yet and it probably caused more confusion than insight...

[purplecow]

##Vote Tom

I don't like some of the votes on the top wagons (Tom, bozo, Bionic) and I think Tom's posts have been hollow.

In addition, I think flipping this slot answers some D1 questions regarding Scum vs. unknown.

Bozo and Bionic??? Literally no one has voted for one of them today except for me.

[Chaqa]

I am leaving now to get my daughter to a dance presentation, will try to be around at EOD, but if I can't and you decide to lynch me, please lynch Tom tomorrow.

This is not the post of a scum.

LOL I don't know what the case on him is, but yeah scum retreat from the thread all the time haha. wtf?

Specifically, scum will very rarely leave instructions on what to do in the event of their death. Townies often will, and these are often ignored (and often right).

[e.m.c^42]

so tl;dr with exaggerations for easier interpretation

Ok with Yavuz lynch due to inability to read slot, but if better one comes up will probably go there.

Against Rivera lynch for today

Tom lynch is...somewhat acceptable, hafta read him more.

Somewhat interested in starting Kit wagon, but don't have scumread reasons typed out yet

[Tom Bombadil]

I love the meta argument in a game I subbed in (and didn’t sign up for because I have little time and playing only on mobile).

[ND]

K, I'll probably stay on Purplecow if no one summarizes anything.

[Chaqa]

##Vote Tom

I don't like some of the votes on the top wagons (Tom, bozo, Bionic) and I think Tom's posts have been hollow.

In addition, I think flipping this slot answers some D1 questions regarding Scum vs. unknown.

Bozo and Bionic??? Literally no one has voted for one of them today except for me.

He's saying he deosn't like the three of them and they are voting for yavu.

[ND]

This is not the post of a scum.

LOL I don't know what the case on him is, but yeah scum retreat from the thread all the time haha. wtf?

Specifically, scum will very rarely leave instructions on what to do in the event of their death. Townies often will, and these are often ignored (and often right).

that is so weak

[Chaqa]

K, I'll probably stay on Purplecow if no one summarizes anything.

Can't speak to Yavu or Rivera as I feel those wagons are quite forced.

There's a medium/long length case against Tom a page or two back I posted.

Be a better town leader, ND.

[purplecow]

K, I'll probably stay on Purplecow if no one summarizes anything.

If you keep voting for me a tie could happen. Do you really want that?

[Tom Bombadil]

When I vote Tem and say things like yavu is obvscum it’s to see how people react to it.

I never had a scum read on Tem. In fact I said that I now townread him based on his reaction, and yavu is similar - misty because I believe his story about the Pm

[Chaqa]

LOL I don't know what the case on him is, but yeah scum retreat from the thread all the time haha. wtf?

Specifically, scum will very rarely leave instructions on what to do in the event of their death. Townies often will, and these are often ignored (and often right).

that is so weak

I didn't say it was super strong, and it's not the primary reason I think rivera is town or Tom is scum. Go back and read the damn thread.

[xorxes]

@Chaqa:

Part 1 of your case (words per post) is silly in my opinion.

Part 2 is a repeat of everything I have said. Why do you present it as original research? You could have just said Vapor/knife.

Part 3 is poorly researched. He explained why he changed his mind on Temasek.

So your long post is really... not much

[e.m.c^42]

Einstein feels rather not limpid and vaguely dead

catching up, catching up, what happened to the resolution of lynching the Jekyll/Hyde slot?

Nobody really made any effort to push for that.

Don't recall much of argument for, but anyone think it is worth it? I mean, the more the game goes on the more we will lose interest in ever lynching him, most likely.

[ND]

This is what I gather:

Yav: The slot. That's the best real evidence out there really. I might vote Yav actually.

Tom: ?

Rd: ? and no he isn't disqualified because he posted a message an hour ago saying he he had to go. I do that crap all the time when I'm scum. Retreating from the thread when under fire is a valid strategy. Anyone who has played or been around for 50 games knows that Chaqa. Come on now.

Purplecow, still suspicious imo.

[ND]

K, I'll probably stay on Purplecow if no one summarizes anything.

If you keep voting for me a tie could happen. Do you really want that?

No. Tie is bad. If a Tie occurs I'll break it.

[Chaqa]

@Chaqa:

Part 1 of your case (words per post) is silly in my opinion.

Part 2 is a repeat of everything I have said. Why do you present it as original research? You could have just said Vapor/knife.

Part 3 is poorly researched. He explained why he changed his mind on Temasek.

So your long post is really... not much

I didn't claim it was all original. I was just reformatting it into one post with everything I had so far.

It's hard for me to build these sorta of cases as it isn't something I really do often.

[FlaviusAetius]

Can someone explain the case on yavu?

I really think voting for Vecna or Tom is better.

Ok so
basically yavu has been being a little evasive the entire time he's been in the role thus far
bo_sox said some stuff I forget what it was, but there's that
computer_genius was top lynch the entire day then all of a sudden the votes fall like water, Im glad they did, but Im not THAT convincing, nor is chaqa
bo_sox also when asked about his impressions talked about vapor...when he in fact replaced computer, not vapor, tom replaced vapor
tom had zero emotions

[Chaqa]

This is what I gather:

Yav: The slot. That's the best real evidence out there really. I might vote Yav actually.

Tom: ?

Rd: ? and no he isn't disqualified because he posted a message an hour ago saying he he had to go. I do that crap all the time when I'm scum. Retreating from the thread when under fire is a valid strategy. Anyone who has played or been around for 50 games knows that Chaqa. Come on now.

Purplecow, still suspicious imo.

OK, sure, you still somehow miss the Tom case we've all been talking about since Vapor's knife comment on Day 1. Cool.

So glad you're our conf Town.

[ND]

I don't really have time to read 10 pages or w/e. Been busy with family. Doing what I can here people. Busy times.