M50 Apocalypse Meme Redux

[FlaviusAetius]

^

(in reference to bunny's quote)

[Squigs44]

He literally didnt know there was a a role list, if he did he wouldnt have done it. I made the argument several times, which you just completely ignored that that's the exact reason why Ezio WOULDNT have done that, this isnt a mistake, we've talked about this too much for it to be a mistake

Game 1:
Vecna (not mafia) posted the phrase.
Then Vaporwave (rick roller) posted the phrase.
This action by Vecna helped town because it baited and caught Vaporwave

Game 2:
Ezio posted the phrase
Everyone cries out "how could someone who isn't mafia think that posting the phrase is helpful"

It's not that hard guys. I'm starting to think you guys are just acting stupid to get off an easy vote. Maybe I should vote for one of these people. Oh wait - I am.

Its different this time though because very publicly might I add, the Rick Roller role has completely changed, so that 'baiting' literally cant happen now

Shouldn't it be easier to bait people now? Like if someone else were to have posted the phrase they could have timed it so it triggers right at 12 hours after Ezio posted and now we have to figure out which of the two it is. Its safer for the rickroller, so they are more likely to take the bait.

[BunnyGo]

^

Are you missing an eyebrow? What's this?

[FlaviusAetius]

If someone else posts the phrase then we 100% know that its them, not Ezio, because we know exactly what they would be doing. Funny, no one is doing that, no?

[Squigs44]

Worcej's iso is full of attitude, but pretty sparse with actual content.

Lots of mechanics talk.
Said Bozo is obvtown.
Seconds a townread of Bo (after Bo was dead)
Says damo's reaction is not out of the ordinary.
Likes a comment of Ezio's.

Worcej I need more from you

Huh, I read his iso very differently. I liked the comments pointing out "good form" lessons from experienced players.

In general the statements you said had little content, I read as having the right amount for this early in the game: saying things that weren't totally obvious, but not loving the smell of his own fart so much that he thought he could solve the whole game because of a misplaced comma by some other player.

So agreeing with 4 people is the right amount of content?

[FlaviusAetius]

^

Are you missing an eyebrow? What's this?

I was trying to agree with what you said without quoting a massive quote :p

[BunnyGo]

Worcej's iso is full of attitude, but pretty sparse with actual content.

Lots of mechanics talk.
Said Bozo is obvtown.
Seconds a townread of Bo (after Bo was dead)
Says damo's reaction is not out of the ordinary.
Likes a comment of Ezio's.

Worcej I need more from you

Huh, I read his iso very differently. I liked the comments pointing out "good form" lessons from experienced players.

In general the statements you said had little content, I read as having the right amount for this early in the game: saying things that weren't totally obvious, but not loving the smell of his own fart so much that he thought he could solve the whole game because of a misplaced comma by some other player.

So agreeing with 4 people is the right amount of content?

This is my second forum game, but I have lots of experience playing f2f. I honestly have no idea how anybody can scum read in D1 when there's no body language? So yes...saying consistently clear statements is the right amount of content.

[BunnyGo]

^

Are you missing an eyebrow? What's this?

I was trying to agree with what you said without quoting a massive quote :p

WOOOO!

https://imgflip.com/i/20mr18

[BunnyGo]

Seriously, people: I'm old; I don't do memes; but this has been fun finding them. You should try it.

[FlaviusAetius]

Guys the Nationals have just come back and are now winning 4-2, I'm so happy :D

[Chaqa]

Guys the Nationals have just come back and are now winning 4-2, I'm so happy :D

##GM Note:

Goddamn...

[BunnyGo]

Guys the Nationals have just come back and are now winning 4-2, I'm so happy :D

Anyone here bet on them to win it all back in May?

[FlaviusAetius]

Guys the Nationals have just come back and are now winning 4-2, I'm so happy :D

Anyone here bet on them to win it all back in May?

Nope ;( I wanted the Yankees to win ripp

[Squigs44]

If someone else posts the phrase then we 100% know that its them, not Ezio, because we know exactly what they would be doing. Funny, no one is doing that, no?

Okay but the same held true for Vapor. I'm not saying Ezios play was a good one - frankly I'm pretty annoyed at how much of a distraction this has been - but when you say he's lock scum and there is no way town Ezio had a reason to do this, you are being short sighted. Maybe Ezio is town and had a completely different reason for doing this than what I can conceive. If you're going to vote Ezio, do it because his play has been anti-Town though, dont push the idea that he has to be lock scum because you dont think the same way others do.

[Squigs44]

Guys the Nationals have just come back and are now winning 4-2, I'm so happy :D

Wore my Nats hat today as a good luck charm. Looks like its paying off!

[BunnyGo]

If someone else posts the phrase then we 100% know that its them, not Ezio, because we know exactly what they would be doing. Funny, no one is doing that, no?

Okay but the same held true for Vapor. I'm not saying Ezios play was a good one - frankly I'm pretty annoyed at how much of a distraction this has been - but when you say he's lock scum and there is no way town Ezio had a reason to do this, you are being short sighted. Maybe Ezio is town and had a completely different reason for doing this than what I can conceive. If you're going to vote Ezio, do it because his play has been anti-Town though, dont push the idea that he has to be lock scum because you dont think the same way others do.

What's your opinion on my 6 options above? Did I miss anything? Do you agree with all my conclusions for each case?

[BunnyGo]

For the record: I've had that stupid Rick Astley song suck in my head for a whole day. The only cure was other Rick Astley songs...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yPYZpwSpKmA

[FlaviusAetius]

Actually this Vecna and Vapor thing fits perfectly, Vecna wasnt actually mafia, and so he said it, he actually didnt have good intentions since he was 3p, but regardless, Vapor actually was it, and thought he could get away with it, then said it, guess what no dice. But look everyone's been on, no one tried to get away with it by saying the forbidden words, all things point to Ezio

[BobMcBob]

I’m wondering if there is a compelling reason Jamie just used the G-word neatly and clearly spelled, after a post setting it up with similar spelling so it stood out less.

Possibly he was told that the scottishism earlier wouldn’t count?

So lets just make him say the word UP so that it resets wahahah btw he already said the N-WORD so, next would be the Y-word which he probably already so, oh my god jamie what did you do

Actually just read the role. Come on, it's not that hard. You have (or had) absolutely no clue what you were banging on about. Just because they say the phrase and nothing happens doesn't clear them. You have to say the words, seperately, without going afeneverffas (as far as I know) and PM the GM's saying you wnat to activate it. And it's so late into D1 already, even back when this was happening, that there would be next to no point in hammering.

[TrPrado]

Actually this Vecna and Vapor thing fits perfectly, Vecna wasnt actually mafia, and so he said it, he actually didnt have good intentions since he was 3p, but regardless, Vapor actually was it, and thought he could get away with it, then said it, guess what no dice. But look everyone's been on, no one tried to get away with it by saying the forbidden words, all things point to Ezio

Are you unfamiliar with SQUAWK-posting?

This sort of thing was my first impression of Vecna