MAFIA 49 -Avengers "Re-release"- GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[Nephthys]

@Kalel, I notice you there but you haven't shared any thoughts, come join and discuss.

[KalelChase]

- It is still very possible that both Temasek and Bunny are Scum (including SK in this, which I think is more likely for BG).

Bunny's defense of Maniac is quite aggressive for someone just afraid of mislynch (since there was no way to be sure).

This was all part of the thoughts on my earlier vote for BG.

I don't agree that if Scum has time stone then they would have ended this if Temasek was town as that would confirm they have it (i.e. they'll probably only get to use that trick once). It's more likely if they have the stone they'll keep the EoP timezone in a spot that's way early morning for the townies that are making the most sense (or better at coordinating a coalition).

With that said as the odds get worse for us it's a bit more important to keep the gap wide so SK can't choose. I'm sticking with Temasek, but am wide open for the Bunny/Maniac S/S theory next day (if I'm using those terms correctly).

[KalelChase]

@Kalel, I notice you there but you haven't shared any thoughts, come join and discuss.

Partially due the results of my D1 behavior I'm saving drafts and re-reading before submit. So I'm going more slowly. Also, I just noticed the blue bar saying that a player is online... and I do tend to leave windows open on my computer (for hours sometime). Might be a bad habit for this game.

[Nephthys]

- It is still very possible that both Temasek and Bunny are Scum (including SK in this, which I think is more likely for BG).

Bunny's defense of Maniac is quite aggressive for someone just afraid of mislynch (since there was no way to be sure).

This was all part of the thoughts on my earlier vote for BG.

I don't agree that if Scum has time stone then they would have ended this if Temasek was town as that would confirm they have it (i.e. they'll probably only get to use that trick once). It's more likely if they have the stone they'll keep the EoP timezone in a spot that's way early morning for the townies that are making the most sense (or better at coordinating a coalition).

With that said as the odds get worse for us it's a bit more important to keep the gap wide so SK can't choose. I'm sticking with Temasek, but am wide open for the Bunny/Maniac S/S theory next day (if I'm using those terms correctly).

This is inherently back to front. You are opting to go for one person rather than possibly unravel 2, let alone the seriousness of our situation.

That would also buy us more time to look for SK. None of this thought process adds up

[KalelChase]

- It is still very possible that both Temasek and Bunny are Scum (including SK in this, which I think is more likely for BG).

Bunny's defense of Maniac is quite aggressive for someone just afraid of mislynch (since there was no way to be sure).

This was all part of the thoughts on my earlier vote for BG.

I don't agree that if Scum has time stone then they would have ended this if Temasek was town as that would confirm they have it (i.e. they'll probably only get to use that trick once). It's more likely if they have the stone they'll keep the EoP timezone in a spot that's way early morning for the townies that are making the most sense (or better at coordinating a coalition).

With that said as the odds get worse for us it's a bit more important to keep the gap wide so SK can't choose. I'm sticking with Temasek, but am wide open for the Bunny/Maniac S/S theory next day (if I'm using those terms correctly).

This is inherently back to front. You are opting to go for one person rather than possibly unravel 2, let alone the seriousness of our situation.

That would also buy us more time to look for SK. None of this thought process adds up

Can you clarify? How would voting bunny unravel two?

[Nephthys]

- It is still very possible that both Temasek and Bunny are Scum (including SK in this, which I think is more likely for BG).

Bunny's defense of Maniac is quite aggressive for someone just afraid of mislynch (since there was no way to be sure).

This was all part of the thoughts on my earlier vote for BG.

I don't agree that if Scum has time stone then they would have ended this if Temasek was town as that would confirm they have it (i.e. they'll probably only get to use that trick once). It's more likely if they have the stone they'll keep the EoP timezone in a spot that's way early morning for the townies that are making the most sense (or better at coordinating a coalition).

With that said as the odds get worse for us it's a bit more important to keep the gap wide so SK can't choose. I'm sticking with Temasek, but am wide open for the Bunny/Maniac S/S theory next day (if I'm using those terms correctly).

This is inherently back to front. You are opting to go for one person rather than possibly unravel 2, let alone the seriousness of our situation.

That would also buy us more time to look for SK. None of this thought process adds up

Can you clarify? How would voting bunny unravel two?

The very Maniac/Bunny S/S theory you stated in your initial post

[KalelChase]

Tell you what: somebody else on my wagon do a read: since Neph wasn’t able to. Anyone? Someone make a case.

Ha... my biggest red-flag on you is the sheer volume of posts you make (word count). Possibly a fmaf newbie thing, but it seems the more 'extra' words/posts the more noise there is to sort through. But that's my bias because it's been such a pain to sort through so much stuff.

I really thought this would be one or two posts a day and a vote. Oy.

[Nephthys]

In fun news, this is now my most active mafia game ever

@Worcej, hope this is the interaction you wanted

[foodcoats]

Actually, I've had another thought

- If I'm right then scum know who vision is, is there any harm in outing her?
- If I'm wrong then I'm also probably wrong about who vision is, should I out him?

All in all, there could be a case for me to share my entire case including outing our lovely vision.

Discuss

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

[KalelChase]

This is inherently back to front. You are opting to go for one person rather than possibly unravel 2, let alone the seriousness of our situation.

That would also buy us more time to look for SK. None of this thought process adds up

Can you clarify? How would voting bunny unravel two?

The very Maniac/Bunny S/S theory you stated in your initial post

Ah, well even if Bunny flipped Scum I'm not sure I'd be 100% on the other. What do you think about my Tem post? If you think Tem is scum then we'll get get Bunny next... if you think Tem is a mislynch I'd want to see your points (if you've already posted it simply tell me the post # and I'll look it up myself).

[Nephthys]

Can you clarify? How would voting bunny unravel two?

The very Maniac/Bunny S/S theory you stated in your initial post

Ah, well even if Bunny flipped Scum I'm not sure I'd be 100% on the other. What do you think about my Tem post? If you think Tem is scum then we'll get get Bunny next... if you think Tem is a mislynch I'd want to see your points (if you've already posted it simply tell me the post # and I'll look it up myself).

I haven't looked into Tem because he isn't relevant at this stage.

Do you realise the seriousness of my claim if I'm right?

[damo666]

Actually, I've had another thought

- If I'm right then scum know who vision is, is there any harm in outing her?
- If I'm wrong then I'm also probably wrong about who vision is, should I out him?

All in all, there could be a case for me to share my entire case including outing our lovely vision.

Discuss

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

[KalelChase]

@Kalel, I notice you there but you haven't shared any thoughts, come join and discuss.

Partially due the results of my D1 behavior I'm saving drafts and re-reading before submit. So I'm going more slowly. Also, I just noticed the blue bar saying that a player is online... and I do tend to leave windows open on my computer (for hours sometime). Might be a bad habit for this game.

Okay, Meta-noise here
I also see the line at the bottom that says who is browsing this forum.
Is it cheating to browse the forum as a guest even if you're a player?
I guess I'm not sure how you'd get caught, but I notice many guests browsing now.
No rush on this one Ike, now that I'm aware of this extra surveillance I'm curious if this is a tactic some use while playing.

##Call GM

[KalelChase]

Actually, I've had another thought

- If I'm right then scum know who vision is, is there any harm in outing her?
- If I'm wrong then I'm also probably wrong about who vision is, should I out him?

All in all, there could be a case for me to share my entire case including outing our lovely vision.

Discuss

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

Honestly, Vision didn't use the stone before potential EoD I think it's likely town doesn't control it anymore. With that said only post your theory if you think it's so rock-solid tight that we'll bag a scum off of it. If it is and the theory holds up under peer-review I'd change my vote before bed.

[damo666]

@Kalel being incognito is allowed.

I hide my onlineness (onlineitude?)

[Nephthys]

Actually, I've had another thought

- If I'm right then scum know who vision is, is there any harm in outing her?
- If I'm wrong then I'm also probably wrong about who vision is, should I out him?

All in all, there could be a case for me to share my entire case including outing our lovely vision.

Discuss

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

We are 1/1

Can everyone please weigh in on this

[Nephthys]

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

Honestly, Vision didn't use the stone before potential EoD I think it's likely town doesn't control it anymore. With that said only post your theory if you think it's so rock-solid tight that we'll bag a scum off of it. If it is and the theory holds up under peer-review I'd change my vote before bed.

The stone is on CD. It comes off tonight

[damo666]

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

Honestly, Vision didn't use the stone before potential EoD I think it's likely town doesn't control it anymore. With that said only post your theory if you think it's so rock-solid tight that we'll bag a scum off of it. If it is and the theory holds up under peer-review I'd change my vote before bed.

I think Mind stone on cooldown until N3 Kalel.

[KalelChase]

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

Honestly, Vision didn't use the stone before potential EoD I think it's likely town doesn't control it anymore. With that said only post your theory if you think it's so rock-solid tight that we'll bag a scum off of it. If it is and the theory holds up under peer-review I'd change my vote before bed.

The stone is on CD. It comes off tonight

Ah, right. I knew that. @Nephy, can't wait to hear your theory TOMORROW.

[BunnyGo]

I feel like no. Maybe you picked it up and they didn't.

I say give us your complete theory. If it's right we bag a scum and they have Vison sussed anyway. If you're wrong probably doesn't matter.

Honestly, Vision didn't use the stone before potential EoD I think it's likely town doesn't control it anymore. With that said only post your theory if you think it's so rock-solid tight that we'll bag a scum off of it. If it is and the theory holds up under peer-review I'd change my vote before bed.

Stone still on Cooldown