MAFIA 49 -Avengers "Re-release"- GAME THREAD [HIDDEN]

[Nephthys]

##vote espresso

[Vaporwave]

A few points

worcej, Tom Bombadil's excellence during M(insert correct number, probably 41) was something that only happens once every 500 mafia games, shooting scum one after another. It was my first game, of course he was memorable. As for that physical aspect compliment, it has been drilled into our skulls how GMs are handsome.

foodcoats, I'll explain why 4 scum seem 'few'. I'm mostly used to hearing about 5+ team, it was a new thing to hear about. I should have treated SK as a filthy enemy because that's what he is. Him not being explicitly part of mafia tricked my mind into considering him less dangerous. My fault

xorxes, can I suggest that you should not tinfoil on me based on dargo's opinion? He's a player that's not familiar with my style and he's not able to grasp any of my motives

[dargorygel]

A few points

worcej, Tom Bombadil's excellence during M(insert correct number, probably 41) was something that only happens once every 500 mafia games, shooting scum one after another. It was my first game, of course he was memorable. As for that physical aspect compliment, it has been drilled into our skulls how GMs are handsome.

foodcoats, I'll explain why 4 scum seem 'few'. I'm mostly used to hearing about 5+ team, it was a new thing to hear about. I should have treated SK as a filthy enemy because that's what he is. Him not being explicitly part of mafia tricked my mind into considering him less dangerous. My fault

xorxes, can I suggest that you should not tinfoil on me based on dargo's opinion? He's a player that's not familiar with my style and he's not able to grasp any of my motives

Much sorrow. Tom fakeclaimed doc... and that was the catalyst for someone ELSE to hip shoot three scum. Tom was great.... but so was 'someone else.'

[Nephthys]

Temasek22 (2) Vaporwave Kitsune
worcej (2) Maniac Jamiet99uk
BunnyGo (2) brainbomb KalelChase
KalelChase (2) damo666 rdrivera2005


these wagons are probably a better topic than topics 2 or 3. So perhaps we should discuss who is opportunistic scum on these wagons, and who is caught scum on these wagons.

scum usually arent all huddled on one player
and scum also arent likely to all be unvoted or on vanity. they do indeed want someone to die, someone not themselves nor each other

So I like when people organize and stay on topic like Brain is. The big risk is that he's scum and is able to steer the conversation. That said, it'll probably come out after a couple days if he is. I'm not a huge fan of his vote, but he's been trolling me, and isn't thinking hard about his vote for now.

I really don't understand the votes on worcej. But I'm chalking that up to previous metagaming.

That leaves me:

Kalel, Vapor, rdrivera, Maniac, Jamie

who are voting in ways I really don't get. But I'm willing to admit my ignorance. Especially in the signaling people are using here with voting and metagaming.

This post strikes me as odd.

TLDR: I'm confused

Why so lengthy and drawn out if you're generally trying to solve. There are no questions here and nothing comes from it, this seems like content for the sake of content 101

[Chaqa]

27 goddamn pages... alright I’m caught up but I definitely skimmed a bit. Some things that stick in my mind:

- Vapor claiming VT = bad
- xorxes and Jamiet seem very town
- I missed brain
- ND = bad because I hate when people play “roles” like Vecna does
- KalEl joking too much is scummy

##Vote ND for now

Yikes. Weren't you a fan of Vecna's shenanigans, or am I completely misremembering?

I can easily see ND as scum here, but he just hasn't done enough for me to tell one way or the other.

No, if you look at the Gladiator game, I was vehemently against ND and Jamiet's Roman shenanigans to the point of threatening to quit over them. Fuck that shit.

So far I am liking Kitsune as town as well.

@ND - meh, idc about anything you think ever.

[Chaqa]

@brain - I absolutely ADORE the idea of using D&D Alignment for reads.

IRL I'm very much Chaotic Good, FWIW.

[dargorygel]

@brain
Was your alignment chart based on in THIS game, or meta play?

[Nephthys]

@rdr, thoughts on the EP wagon?

[xorxes]

@rdr, thoughts on the EP wagon?

+1 want to know

[Nephthys]

Townlean

Worcej - Seems like he's moving forwards somewhat
Kitsune - Generally seems interested and throwing ideas out
Darg - Liking his post about the vapor wagon
Fox - Had a few decent posts, need more here
Damo
Kalel
Tem
Chaqa


Scumlean

Bunny - some odd posts, not really contributing too much
Maniac - Although some logical connections, seems caught up on a weird detail. Something I'd expect from Jamie
Vapor - Start of the game shenanigans, has improved somewhat though, not for lynch today
Rivera - Absolutely no content yet
ND

[Nephthys]

Fun thing for those wanting to do it, make a read list except you aren't allowed to have nulls. Makes it a lot harder but more fun to read back on

[dargorygel]

Fun thing for those wanting to do it, make a read list except you aren't allowed to have nulls. Makes it a lot harder but more fun to read back on

only 13? Are the ones you missed technically 'nulls?' Or still coming...

[xorxes]

Fun thing for those wanting to do it, make a read list except you aren't allowed to have nulls. Makes it a lot harder but more fun to read back on

only 13? Are the ones you missed technically 'nulls?' Or still coming...

That was the second part actually.

[dargorygel]

Fun thing for those wanting to do it, make a read list except you aren't allowed to have nulls. Makes it a lot harder but more fun to read back on

only 13? Are the ones you missed technically 'nulls?' Or still coming...

That was the second part actually.

AH... I see... thanks. nvm Nephthys

[Vaporwave]

would it be wrong to suddenly include Neph in towncore? I think there's bite to his posts, but not so hard that it would create a wound. He was over the top in Gladiators, but now there's equilibrium when he delivers opinions

or maybe I'm just too easy to please? thing is I only wanna chose 1 tinfoil between rdr/Neph and I would rather lean on Neph more confidently, feels less threatening than rivera

...what to do what to do? I'll say tentative town read

[Vaporwave]

newb trio party

let's see, Kitsune is the towniest, BG is in between and KalelC is the scummiest

[Vaporwave]

Fun thing for those wanting to do it, make a read list except you aren't allowed to have nulls. Makes it a lot harder but more fun to read back on

No, it triggers people and will upset many

[Chaqa]

Fun thing for those wanting to do it, make a read list except you aren't allowed to have nulls. Makes it a lot harder but more fun to read back on

No, it triggers people and will upset many

This is a scummy response.

[Kitsune]

newb trio party

let's see, Kitsune is the towniest, BG is in between and KalelC is the scummiest

What can I say, Ike brings all the newbies to the yard.

I was trying to persuade VI to join (he says he's wanted to for a while) but he's fully committed right now. Hopefully Mafia 50 though.

[Vaporwave]

Neph's proposal removes neutrals and forces us to include any slight scumlean, I'm not up for that, people are prone to OMGUS and I've already had too many votes

I'm only mentioning my strong scumbums.