Mafia 88: Murder at the Meadery - GAME THREAD

[kingofthepirates]

Use that AP studying to tell a story.

Convince your readers (not just me) of the premise. The plot. The characters. Sell it!

No I’m still salty todays ap psychology had basically nothing from Freud >:(((((((

[BunnyGo]

Reason #1 that Bunny and sweet are scumteammed together: Sweet defends Bunny without giving a reason.

In the space of half an hour you wanted to endhammer Balki, then you wanted to endhammer KingofPirates, and now you're advocating votes on Sparta despite not voting him yourself.

Have your forgotten to take your ADHD medication or are you just looking for spurious wagons to start and/or push?

Why the Brainbomb impression?

Excellent point. Bunny is being scummy.

The thing about ADHD is a little bit insensitive. I don't have ADHD or know anybody who does, but it's probably not a good topic for jokes of this kind.

He retracted his Cop claim like two days ago.

Why aren't you reading the thread?

Oh, look at this. Bonatogether can't even be bothered to track the thread. Idk if this is scum but it's definitely not good townplay.
Also, has everyone forgotten about bozo?

Strong town:
Ham
Jamiet

Weak town:
Balki
Sweet

Weak scum:
Bozo
Vecna
Bonatogether
BunnyGo

Null:
Everyone else

This post is a lot, but the important part is that I voice my suspicion of Bunny. Sweet's response on the next page...

Is nobody reading what Dip is writing? I don't think it could look much worse.

##VOTE Dip

I am genuinely impressed with how good this post is at defending scumteammate bunny. It discredits what I've been saying, sets Bunny up for voting me, changes the subject away from the suspicion of Bunny, and does this all without any evidence. If sweet actually thought I was scum because of what I was saying, he would've done the following:

• Taken the time to write a decent post

• Quoted evidence of this stuff I'm writing that supposedly couldn't look much worse

• Explained exactly what was wrong with my post

THATS A GOOD STORY

[BunnyGo]

Use that AP studying to tell a story.

Convince your readers (not just me) of the premise. The plot. The characters. Sell it!

No I’m still salty todays ap psychology had basically nothing from Freud >:(((((((

Adler? Much better….

[kingofthepirates]

That’s a terrible story. At no point did you ever tell me why you think either of us is scum.

As I said, I don’t think you are scum. I said I’d be surprised, and if you were scum the story is how id imagine the interaction. Perhaps I’m misunderstanding; is paired specifically only for paired scum??? As I said, you are paired, but in my eyes you are paired town.

Ah…I’d missed that part of your story!

Why are you seeing us as town?

The sheer amount of yap (GOOD YAP MIND YOU, but still pure yap) you two are pumping out. Additionally, your interactions feel far more organic than something cooked up in mafia night chat.

[sweetandcool]

I've gotten to the point where my mind has turned to mush. I don't have the energy to make cases like I normally would (the bot not working doesn't help).

I do, however, feel good about my reads.

I think I will ponder the damo NK and the claimed Sparta RB and see how that meshes.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Reason #1 that Bunny and sweet are scumteammed together: Sweet defends Bunny without giving a reason.

Excellent point. Bunny is being scummy.

The thing about ADHD is a little bit insensitive. I don't have ADHD or know anybody who does, but it's probably not a good topic for jokes of this kind.




Oh, look at this. Bonatogether can't even be bothered to track the thread. Idk if this is scum but it's definitely not good townplay.
Also, has everyone forgotten about bozo?

Strong town:
Ham
Jamiet

Weak town:
Balki
Sweet

Weak scum:
Bozo
Vecna
Bonatogether
BunnyGo

Null:
Everyone else

This post is a lot, but the important part is that I voice my suspicion of Bunny. Sweet's response on the next page...

Is nobody reading what Dip is writing? I don't think it could look much worse.

##VOTE Dip

I am genuinely impressed with how good this post is at defending scumteammate bunny. It discredits what I've been saying, sets Bunny up for voting me, changes the subject away from the suspicion of Bunny, and does this all without any evidence. If sweet actually thought I was scum because of what I was saying, he would've done the following:

• Taken the time to write a decent post

• Quoted evidence of this stuff I'm writing that supposedly couldn't look much worse

• Explained exactly what was wrong with my post

THATS A GOOD STORY

Please stop being passive aggressive.

[sweetandcool]

Reason #1 that Bunny and sweet are scumteammed together: Sweet defends Bunny without giving a reason.


This post is a lot, but the important part is that I voice my suspicion of Bunny. Sweet's response on the next page...



I am genuinely impressed with how good this post is at defending scumteammate bunny. It discredits what I've been saying, sets Bunny up for voting me, changes the subject away from the suspicion of Bunny, and does this all without any evidence. If sweet actually thought I was scum because of what I was saying, he would've done the following:

• Taken the time to write a decent post

• Quoted evidence of this stuff I'm writing that supposedly couldn't look much worse

• Explained exactly what was wrong with my post

THATS A GOOD STORY

Please stop being passive aggressive.

I thought he was being sincere....

[Jamiet99uk]

Town:

Jamiet: The RB and swearing at Pirate (though maybe that's actually NAI)
Bona: I don't think he bussed, felt Town vs Will.
Pirate: I don't think he would bus unprovoked like that.
Ham?????????????

Null:
Worcej
Balki

Scum lean:
Bozo: Still feel like D2 voting behavior was scum motivated.
Bunny: basically a WIFOM
Sparta: Mainly PoE and his main contribution is meta analysis. I kind of want him to be Town, but I kind of think he could be scum.

Scum:

Vecna
Dip
Ham??????
----------------------------------------
I've already commented extensively on the scumteam. I might be wrong about Ham which means I'm wrong about someone, probably null or below.

I feel okay about my reasons for Towning players, but honestly I am not completely sure about any of them.

Have you ruminated on rdrivera's Day 1 vote? Can you explain (or repeat) your thoughts on that?

The entire scum team was spread between Bona, damo. So rdr busses by voting Just, tying the three wagons at three.

He probably figured his teammates could easily consolidate on either Bona or damo. If he was online, he might have made an effort to save Will, but alas he was gone after his vote.

This makes Kingofetc.. the top target because WHY?

Why did you avoid giving a reason when repeatedly challenged?

##Vote Sweetandcool for ignoring multiple questions on this topic.

[kingofthepirates]

I think I will ponder the damo NK and the claimed Sparta RB and see how that meshes.

What are you pondering? As I see it, and applying occam’s razor, this is simply mafia trying to keep the cop at bay. They suspected damo as the cop, and rb’d sparta too as a further measure to cut the potential cop’s power. They’re just hunting for the final pr to kill both town momentum/morale and eliminate the surefire way to determine scum.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Reason #2 sweet and bunny are likely scum-partners: Sweet scumreads Bunny but still trusts him.

Town:

Jamiet: The RB and swearing at Pirate (though maybe that's actually NAI)
Bona: I don't think he bussed, felt Town vs Will.
Pirate: I don't think he would bus unprovoked like that.
Ham?????????????

Null:
Worcej
Balki

Scum lean:
Bozo: Still feel like D2 voting behavior was scum motivated.
Bunny: basically a WIFOM
Sparta: Mainly PoE and his main contribution is meta analysis. I kind of want him to be Town, but I kind of think he could be scum.

Scum:

Vecna
Dip
Ham??????
----------------------------------------
I've already commented extensively on the scumteam. I might be wrong about Ham which means I'm wrong about someone, probably null or below.

I feel okay about my reasons for Towning players, but honestly I am not completely sure about any of them.

So sweet has been reading Bunny's posts as WIFOM. This contradicts numerous situations where sweet has been agreeing with Bunny, such as my evidence #1 where sweet rejects (I would say 'criticizes' but that implies he gave evidence and reasoning, and he gave neither) my post where I say Bunny is being unhelpful and add him to my scumreadlist. If Sweet thinks bunny is doing a lot of WIFOM, why doesn't he like my post saying that Bunny is being unhelpful? This looks a lot like sweet trying to disassociate himself with Bunny, perhaps for a stab or perhaps to prevent anyone from catching on.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

##VOTE SWEET

[sweetandcool]

Have you ruminated on rdrivera's Day 1 vote? Can you explain (or repeat) your thoughts on that?

The entire scum team was spread between Bona, damo. So rdr busses by voting Just, tying the three wagons at three.

He probably figured his teammates could easily consolidate on either Bona or damo. If he was online, he might have made an effort to save Will, but alas he was gone after his vote.

This makes Kingofetc.. the top target because WHY?

Why did you avoid giving a reason when repeatedly challenged?

##Vote Sweetandcool for ignoring multiple questions on this topic.

What are you going on about?

King is not a top target by any stretch of the imagination.

[BunnyGo]

As I said, I don’t think you are scum. I said I’d be surprised, and if you were scum the story is how id imagine the interaction. Perhaps I’m misunderstanding; is paired specifically only for paired scum??? As I said, you are paired, but in my eyes you are paired town.

Ah…I’d missed that part of your story!

Why are you seeing us as town?

The sheer amount of yap (GOOD YAP MIND YOU, but still pure yap) you two are pumping out. Additionally, your interactions feel far more organic than something cooked up in mafia night chat.

I can yap as scum. Ask anyone.

[sweetandcool]

I think I will ponder the damo NK and the claimed Sparta RB and see how that meshes.

What are you pondering? As I see it, and applying occam’s razor, this is simply mafia trying to keep the cop at bay. They suspected damo as the cop, and rb’d sparta too as a further measure to cut the potential cop’s power. They’re just hunting for the final pr to kill both town momentum/morale and eliminate the surefire way to determine scum.

Mainly the implications of those events. Yes, the "why" is obvious, but the implications are what I shall ponder.

[BunnyGo]

Reason #1 that Bunny and sweet are scumteammed together: Sweet defends Bunny without giving a reason.


This post is a lot, but the important part is that I voice my suspicion of Bunny. Sweet's response on the next page...



I am genuinely impressed with how good this post is at defending scumteammate bunny. It discredits what I've been saying, sets Bunny up for voting me, changes the subject away from the suspicion of Bunny, and does this all without any evidence. If sweet actually thought I was scum because of what I was saying, he would've done the following:

• Taken the time to write a decent post

• Quoted evidence of this stuff I'm writing that supposedly couldn't look much worse

• Explained exactly what was wrong with my post

THATS A GOOD STORY

Please stop being passive aggressive.

Nothing passive about this. I’m looking for reads and action.

[BunnyGo]

THATS A GOOD STORY

Please stop being passive aggressive.

I thought he was being sincere....

Oh. I misunderstood his comment. I was being sincere.

[sweetandcool]

Excellent, Dip has revealed his true colours. I do appreciate the scumteam making this game easy.

##VOTE Dip

Okay, so the real mystery is who is the third Mafia? I still think it could be Ham.

Mafia could think damo is cop without believing him to have scanned Ham.

[BunnyGo]

Have you ruminated on rdrivera's Day 1 vote? Can you explain (or repeat) your thoughts on that?

The entire scum team was spread between Bona, damo. So rdr busses by voting Just, tying the three wagons at three.

He probably figured his teammates could easily consolidate on either Bona or damo. If he was online, he might have made an effort to save Will, but alas he was gone after his vote.

This makes Kingofetc.. the top target because WHY?

Why did you avoid giving a reason when repeatedly challenged?

##Vote Sweetandcool for ignoring multiple questions on this topic.

Stop being a lazy liar. You read better than this.

[sweetandcool]

In fact, ##END

I couldn't be more confident.

[BunnyGo]

Excellent, Dip has revealed his true colours. I do appreciate the scumteam making this game easy.

##VOTE Dip

Okay, so the real mystery is who is the third Mafia? I still think it could be Ham.

Mafia could think damo is cop without believing him to have scanned Ham.

Really?! I was thinking he showed his true colors by telling a good story.

I was starting to think king was showing us true colors too by refusing to. ##vote Balki.