Mafia 86: Accidents Happen... - Game Thread

[ghug]

I have explained this. Catch up.

I find it suspicious despite your explanation.

Okay. I don't think I can add any more information for you at this point.

Although talking about this again is making me realize again how awful brain and ghug's play is if they are actually town.

Man, you're literally the only person who believed me.

Brain, I can see your point, but we tend to underutilize PR chaos here, and it tends to go pretty well for town when we do do it.

[bozotheclown]

Saying I "jumped to a conclusion" is disingenuous. I'm not going to quote everything for you because you should read the whole interaction, but:

1. ghug said he was the cop, that he had a guilty scan, that he had crumbed the scan, brain had figured it out, and brain would reveal it
2. brain voted for me, then ghug voted for me

To think this is not sending a message that they mechanically knew I was mafia is absurd. And since I knew it was impossible, I challenged them.

I did read the whole interaction, and you pointed out that ghug had only made one previous post, implying that ghug could not have indicated a scan result. So, why did you press ghug to make a hard claim?

My post was about eating and then brain fingered food, obviously.

Do you think foodcoats could have thought you were seriously claiming cop after this:

guilty
guilty
guilty
guilty
guilty

Ah man you should have held it a day.

sorry ghug. got too happy.

Ah well, good scan.

We're about to get Chaqa'd by the last one though.

There have been multiple people that have crumbed PR. What the fuck is going on?

I'm the cop. I crumbed my scan result and soon brainbomb will announce it.

[bozotheclown]

I find it suspicious despite your explanation.

Okay. I don't think I can add any more information for you at this point.

Although talking about this again is making me realize again how awful brain and ghug's play is if they are actually town.

Man, you're literally the only person who believed me.

Brain, I can see your point, but we tend to underutilize PR chaos here, and it tends to go pretty well for town when we do do it.

Why do you accept that he actually believed you?

[Hamilton Brian]

which he didn't

What do you think this was, then:

This is Dr. Foosier Croats… I’m listening.

A frustrated spoonerism/pun referencing an old US comedy series

Okay...but aren't we...well, most of you that are better players, intentional with what we write? Are you so willing to chalk that phrase up to "frustration?"

[BunnyGo]

I can't help but imagine heartthrob as a tub of vanilla ice cream in front of his computer.

This is not an insult, just a reflection on the fact that I've yet to glean anything from him and it has been like three games now.

Heart, maybe you should emulate Bunny here?

This is a safe thing for scum sweet to say to town heart. it is the perfect player to do this toward because it is unlikely to accidentally cause heart to transform into an elite tier town voice, and its also someone unlikely to feel like this is scum talking to them.

the advice also makes me think that scum sweet would not tell scum heart to play more like scum bunny. The mere suggestion would create too many people looking too alike, and this sort of team dynamic would make little sense. It seems more likely that mafia sweet would suggest to Heart, that he should behave like bunny, because at the time bunnys gimmick was drawing negative reactions and attention.

So this would appear to be bunny and heart are probably not sweets teammates. Given how darg has played since arrival I find it even less likely that heart was ever mafia.

If heart was town, and bunny was mafia I cant see why sweet would encourage this as it draws more attention to bunny who is already getting more than enough attention.

How does your analysis change if bunny is town?

[Hamilton Brian]

Saying I "jumped to a conclusion" is disingenuous. I'm not going to quote everything for you because you should read the whole interaction, but:

1. ghug said he was the cop, that he had a guilty scan, that he had crumbed the scan, brain had figured it out, and brain would reveal it
2. brain voted for me, then ghug voted for me

To think this is not sending a message that they mechanically knew I was mafia is absurd. And since I knew it was impossible, I challenged them.

So do you see them as more likely town or more likely mafia?

[Hamilton Brian]

If Bunny was scum, sweet would likely have made a case on me instead.

That is an interesting point. However, why would sweet NOT make a case on you and instead focused on Bunny if they were teammates?

[bozotheclown]

I have explained this. Catch up.

I find it suspicious despite your explanation.

Okay. I don't think I can add any more information for you at this point.

Although talking about this again is making me realize again how awful brain and ghug's play is if they are actually town.

If you are town, I would like to understand what happened, so please let me know how you interpreted this sequence:

guilty
guilty
guilty
guilty
guilty

Ah man you should have held it a day.

sorry ghug. got too happy.

Ah well, good scan.

We're about to get Chaqa'd by the last one though.

There have been multiple people that have crumbed PR. What the fuck is going on?

I'm the cop. I crumbed my scan result and soon brainbomb will announce it.

[Hamilton Brian]

And bozo is interrogating me the way town!bozo would, despite my rage at reliving these moments of rage.

I will agree with you there; I think bozo is pretty town here.

[Hamilton Brian]

My post was about eating and then brain fingered food, obviously.

To each their own, obviously, but TMI. Some of us are eating here.

[Hamilton Brian]

So food...if you're thinking bozo is pretty town, I am assuming you remove your vote off of them. Where do you go with your vote? Of your bozo voters who's your least likely town?

[ghug]

I did read the whole interaction, and you pointed out that ghug had only made one previous post, implying that ghug could not have indicated a scan result. So, why did you press ghug to make a hard claim?

My post was about eating and then brain fingered food, obviously.

Do you think foodcoats could have thought you were seriously claiming cop after this:

guilty
guilty
guilty
guilty
guilty

Ah man you should have held it a day.

sorry ghug. got too happy.

Ah well, good scan.

We're about to get Chaqa'd by the last one though.

There have been multiple people that have crumbed PR. What the fuck is going on?

I'm the cop. I crumbed my scan result and soon brainbomb will announce it.

I was pretty surprised I was being taken seriously, but I believe his reaction was legitimate. It didn't feel fake.

[Frogsterking]

Hey HamiltonBrian did you follow up yet?

[ghug]

Hey HamiltonBrian did you follow up yet?

Hey Frogsterking did you follow up yet?

[Hamilton Brian]

Hey HamiltonBrian did you follow up yet?

Yep; check your inbox.

[Hamilton Brian]

So food...if you're thinking bozo is pretty town, I am assuming you remove your vote off of them. Where do you go with your vote? Of your bozo voters who's your least likely town?

And then if we look at the roster of sweet voters, would the busser/s (if there were any) drive the bozo wagon (if bozo is indeed town)?

[Frogsterking]

Frogster, what do you think about brainbomb? What does that guy of yours say?

My "guy" ?

I've been assuming that brainbomb is town for most of this game, if they are scum then they are pretty good at appearing town.

[Frogsterking]

Hey HamiltonBrian did you follow up yet?

Hey Frogsterking did you follow up yet?

Nope

[Frogsterking]

Hey HamiltonBrian did you follow up yet?

Yep; check your inbox.

I can't find your post

[Frogsterking]

Or, he could claim he was the doctor, forcing the doctor to CC.

which he didn't

What do you think this was, then:

This is Dr. Foosier Croats… I’m listening.

Uh oh