MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[BunnyGo]

anyone who honestly believes i'm scum should vote me

anyone who thinks i'm scum but advocates for me to survive wants to deny information to town that they need to operate. losing a doctor is not a big deal, but flipping someone you believe is scum is.

there will be no cc because scum will leave me alive and ignored to be eventually daykilled. they will not cc because i will be killed anyways.

I agree with Bona. We should kill Bona.

I'm honestly tempted...but still don't see the rush.

It's 9-2...we have 3 miskills in our pocket. We can get bona tomorrow or the next day when the doctor does claim or is killed at night.

[Bonatogether]

anyone who honestly believes i'm scum should vote me

anyone who thinks i'm scum but advocates for me to survive wants to deny information to town that they need to operate. losing a doctor is not a big deal, but flipping someone you believe is scum is.

there will be no cc because scum will leave me alive and ignored to be eventually daykilled. they will not cc because i will be killed anyways.

I agree with Bona. We should kill Bona.

I'm honestly tempted...but still don't see the rush.

It's 9-2...we have 3 miskills in our pocket. We can get bona tomorrow or the next day when the doctor does claim or is killed at night.

Having so many miskills means that town can afford to be wrong. stop kicking the fucking can

[BunnyGo]

I agree with Bona. We should kill Bona.

I'm honestly tempted...but still don't see the rush.

It's 9-2...we have 3 miskills in our pocket. We can get bona tomorrow or the next day when the doctor does claim or is killed at night.

Having so many miskills means that town can afford to be wrong. stop kicking the fucking can

No...?

[heartthrob24909]

##vote heart

Just to tie things up

"Just tying things up" when you are one of the people in that tie (at the time), and on people's shortlist for a good DK today, seems weird

[Bonatogether]

anyone who seriously thinks that not voting for your top scumread is optimal townplay is simply delusional. no rational person can possibly argue for voting anyone other than a top scumread

[BunnyGo]

I'm honestly tempted...but still don't see the rush.

It's 9-2...we have 3 miskills in our pocket. We can get bona tomorrow or the next day when the doctor does claim or is killed at night.

Having so many miskills means that town can afford to be wrong. stop kicking the fucking can

No...?

But if we get your partner today, you are allowed to resign...

[BunnyGo]

Ok...back to work!

[heartthrob24909]

Ok...back to work!

I hope you're not talking to me

[ghug]

well this was a surprise to come back to

Which part?

[Bonatogether]

##vote bona

[rdrivera2005]

anyone who seriously thinks that not voting for your top scumread is optimal townplay is simply delusional. no rational person can possibly argue for voting anyone other than a top scumread

The problem is that you weren't top scumread before this Jamiet thing and there is a chance he hadn't seen you (if you are town you know this). So why use a DK on you? Let scum kill you or if they let you alive and you are town it's even better as we got a clear on the last days. Can't you see this?

[heartthrob24909]

well this was a surprise to come back to

Which part?

Leading with 5 votes. Sorry, should've specified. I'll admit I don't think I've been doing a superb job this time around (not used to the sheer amount of stuff that happens on these webdip games so my prior strategy of taking some notes and looking back thru stuff as I go seem like cow tools compared to what's apparently needed) but even then wasn't expecting to see the level of momentum that my wagon got

[Bonatogether]

anyone who seriously thinks that not voting for your top scumread is optimal townplay is simply delusional. no rational person can possibly argue for voting anyone other than a top scumread

The problem is that you weren't top scumread before this Jamiet thing and there is a chance he hadn't seen you (if you are town you know this). So why use a DK on you? Let scum kill you or if they let you alive and you are town it's even better as we got a clear on the last days. Can't you see this?

why would scum kill me? town won't ever townread me if i stay alive.

[brainbomb]

GM NOTE
a deceased player may not use the +1 feature during the remainder of the game. Please do not use that feature once youve died

[damo666]

I think Bona is probably scum but in the absence of a cc (don't, I'm sure you won't) I don't think he's worth DKing until D5 jic.

If Bona is scum then unless all 4 were bussing at EOD1 there is a scum in {heart, Tem, Chaqa, Macca} but I have already indicated Macca is quasi-locktwon so I advocate

heart
Tem
Chaqa

as the next 3 DKs (unless Bona survives to D5).

If we do get a scum, the doctor should CC immediately.

As much as I agree that Bona is probably scum, a non-immediate CC when we're down to 1 scum probably clears him.

Also, if we get the RB, that messes with the mechanical possibility that Jamie saw Bona going anywhere.

Obviously

[damo666]

anyone who seriously thinks that not voting for your top scumread is optimal townplay is simply delusional. no rational person can possibly argue for voting anyone other than a top scumread

I don't think you are particularly anyone's top scumread other than Jamie. The problem is Jamie was Watcher so naturally we wonder did Jamie see you visit someone (particularly Spirit).

Because there is sufficient doubt people aren't going to vote for you today.

Just accept this and vote for your best scumguess.

Thanks.

[brainbomb]

Meanwhile somewhere near Sturgis SD.

Lacey: We made it. Isnt it beautiful.

Paschal: Yes. This reminds me of Little House on the Prairie but with motorcycles.

(holds her hand)

Lacey: And love. Lets find this Mount Rushmore everyone keeps talking about.

Paschal: My Biker values are telling me we should find a nice comfy biker bar near by and do something risky, like play darts… oooh! Or shuffleboard.



—-
heartthrob24909 (5) BunnyGo ghug Temasek22 damo666 Chaqa
Temasek22 (3) rdrivera2005 bozotheclown Macca573
Chaqa (1) worcej
damo666 (1) heartthrob24909
Bonatogether (1) Bonatogether

heart is scheduled to die
under 4 hours remain

[bozotheclown]

Oh! What if it's two of damo/heart/Tem?

That would make some sense for the EOD movement. Sweet and Just couldn't get on Macca, since they could see Macca would save by jumping on them, and they were worried it'd line up all the scum on one nearly 100% scum driven wagon.

@bozo thoughts?

I doubt when there was a 3 way tie at 4 votes at D1 EOD that 3 mafia were voting for Macca, but I think one of damo/heartthrob/Temasek is likely, unless Macca is mafia. Of the 3, I suspect Temasek the most.

Just may have voted for Macca over sweetandcool not because he did not want to bus, but because someone was already bussing sweetandcool (or because Just was bussing by voting for Macca, or both). That would fit with Bonatogether, but also worcej or ghug.

If Bonatogether is really the doctor, I would suspect ghug for trying to get Bonatogether DKed today and for his T vs. T conclusion about D2 EOD.

[bozotheclown]

I think Just being mafia increases the chances that BunnyGo is mafia despite the effort that BunnyGo has put in today, because it would explain why he kept his vote on Just all of D1.

[bozotheclown]

Those are literally NOT the same thing.

Forming an ALLIANCE where only one will end up winning (Catan) or where you will play kingmaker is a FUNDAMENTALLY different style of game.

I'm talking about a TEAM. Like fu**ing baseball, or bridge, or MAFIA where you win or lose with THE WHOLE TEAM regardless of your actual actions.

Your answer suggests you do not understand that fundamental thing.

So to answer your original question: I do think there's a chance you're mafia. But I don't actually care. Town's chances of winning will be increased if we eliminate you day 1 regardless. I care about that statement (usually that statement requires me to believe a player is mafia)

The point.

You seem to su** as a teammate. You seem to even be incapable of recognizing what a TEAM IS!! So I have 2 options:

1) you are mafia (so I should vote you)
2) you’re a shitty teammate and will harm my team (so I should vote you)

This would be funny if is turns out both were true (from BunnyGo's perspective).