MAfIA 84 - A VERY TENDER THANKSGIVING GAME THREAD

[Bonatogether]

bongo did not make a towny post in that whole discussion

[damo666]

bongo did not make a towny post in that whole discussion

Yeah, I noticed that. All he's done all game is question other people. Has he stated an opinion?

[damo666]

Gaussian rdr

##unvote

In fact I doesn't really scumread you, just can't understand people's reasoning. I am probably getting too old for this.

@#vote Chaqa

typo in your vote rdr

[damo666]

##vote Bunny

[rdrivera2005]

Gaussian rdr

##unvote

In fact I doesn't really scumread you, just can't understand people's reasoning. I am probably getting too old for this.

@#vote Chaqa

typo in your vote rdr

Thanks.

##vote Chaqa

[Bonatogether]

##vote Bunny

##vote bunny

[Chaqa]

##Vote Hamilton

[Chaqa]

I have D&D today from 12 to 5 and then my mom's birthday dinner later. I should be able to check in around EOD between those though.

My thought is that Will was the preferred wagon by scum on D1 so probably he's town. I don't want to vote for any of the Sweet voters on principle at least today.

[Bonatogether]

I have D&D today from 12 to 5 and then my mom's birthday dinner later. I should be able to check in around EOD between those though.

My thought is that Will was the preferred wagon by scum on D1 so probably he's town. I don't want to vote for any of the Sweet voters on principle at least today.

quoth chaqa,

I feel like D1 was SvS with BoNDatogether and Sweet, personally.

[worcej]

This milkshake is awful.

Sickly vanilla.

Made in French Canada…

They are not made to be drank for enjoyment…

[worcej]

Well. They just called me. Thanks for keeping me company. Back in a while.

In the meantime ##vote damo. Bad math damo = NAI. But the repeated not caring about mismathing and general lack of interest seems bored. Bored damo is scum damo.

Only thing that gives me pause is I’d think scum!Damo would at least check the numbers of his frequencies before claiming the sum is 27. But maybe he’s at the pub? Maybe he’s just that bored?

I don’t know if damo using math is a scummy tactic by him…

Not vibing this read to say the least - though your back and forth dominated the thread for about 2 pages…

[worcej]

I'm liking Jamie and Ghug

Not liking Tem and Damo

Bona and Bozo hold special places in my heart and are unlikely to catch votes.

Some severe OMGUSing going on here

In retrospect, I guess it is.

Ghug is a usual townread from me. I like the way he thinks, plays and defends. Nothing about him seems off, and I'd like to keep him around.

Jamie is a bit of a shock. When I played back in the day, jamie and I did not get along, but he's been great this game. Attacking and defending ideas I also supported.

Bozo is a genius and a huge town asset, I support him long before I get a read on him.

I can't forsake Bob by voting bona with no good reason. Also, that guy is constantly D1'd and we all had a responsibility to stop that from happening again.


Tem. I know it looks OMGUS coming from me, but as many have said, the way you acted on D1 around voting me was suspicious. Others have explained it better than I could, and you all have zero reason to believe it coming from me.

Damo. For me, the read came from this post [editors note: 1am me is tired and cannot remember what post it was. Likely something where he hides behind math and poor assumptions]


Hope that helps you!

I find it conflicting to my own thoughts to see the town reads are more rooted in meta and the scum reads are rooted in this game. I can see this being done by both town and scum based off skill level, which I don’t have a good appreciation for Macca’s gameplay to assess…

[worcej]

bongo did not make a towny post in that whole discussion

I felt it was NAI by both damo and Bunny and just some guy trying to fact check another lol…

[worcej]

I have D&D today from 12 to 5 and then my mom's birthday dinner later. I should be able to check in around EOD between those though.

My thought is that Will was the preferred wagon by scum on D1 so probably he's town. I don't want to vote for any of the Sweet voters on principle at least today.

quoth chaqa,

I feel like D1 was SvS with BoNDatogether and Sweet, personally.

I almost just want to put Chaqa out of his misery of coming back to play this game, but odds are high it’s a waste of a day kill.

[worcej]

Another cluster-sex of wagons.

I don’t want to kill either damo or bunny this phase.

The standard lurker vibes has me focused in on Macca - not much substance but at least recently stated some opinions.

Tem has done more under pressure - I feel like the reasoning is more sound and people are more scumming him for D1 voting.

HB is under fire from an OMGUS-like Jamie, a non-present Chaqa, and an uber-defensive Will. Not vibing a flip of HB over my concern on Macca currently.

[Bonatogether]

bongo did not make a towny post in that whole discussion

I felt it was NAI by both damo and Bunny and just some guy trying to fact check another lol…

so if it's nai it's not towny

[Bonatogether]

I have D&D today from 12 to 5 and then my mom's birthday dinner later. I should be able to check in around EOD between those though.

My thought is that Will was the preferred wagon by scum on D1 so probably he's town. I don't want to vote for any of the Sweet voters on principle at least today.

quoth chaqa,

I feel like D1 was SvS with BoNDatogether and Sweet, personally.

I almost just want to put Chaqa out of his misery of coming back to play this game, but odds are high it’s a waste of a day kill.

why

[worcej]

quoth chaqa,

I almost just want to put Chaqa out of his misery of coming back to play this game, but odds are high it’s a waste of a day kill.

why

Why do I want to put him out of his misery? Because he doesn’t seem to enjoy Mafia from what I can tell from his prior few games.

Why do I think it’s a waste of a day kill? I feel like him not even bothering with the game is mostly town him. Scum him would be more engaged. I also don’t think he is capable (by choice, not skill) of faking lurking if he was scum.

[Bonatogether]

Another cluster-sex of wagons.

I don’t want to kill either damo or bunny this phase.

The standard lurker vibes has me focused in on Macca - not much substance but at least recently stated some opinions.

Tem has done more under pressure - I feel like the reasoning is more sound and people are more scumming him for D1 voting.

HB is under fire from an OMGUS-like Jamie, a non-present Chaqa, and an uber-defensive Will. Not vibing a flip of HB over my concern on Macca currently.

no reason stated here is a reason to scumread. every read here is disjoint from its reason, which is always a reason to townread

[Bonatogether]

I almost just want to put Chaqa out of his misery of coming back to play this game, but odds are high it’s a waste of a day kill.

why

Why do I want to put him out of his misery? Because he doesn’t seem to enjoy Mafia from what I can tell from his prior few games.

Why do I think it’s a waste of a day kill? I feel like him not even bothering with the game is mostly town him. Scum him would be more engaged. I also don’t think he is capable (by choice, not skill) of faking lurking if he was scum.

what's the in game argument for why he's town? i would doubt that he's incapable of just not hitting the submit post button