M1024: Panhandlin' [GAME THREAD]

[brainbomb]

Night has begun
you may post

[Hamilton Brian]

Shit, sorry Bona.

Well as vanilla town I am going to catch a lot of shot for this.

[Hamilton Brian]

JFC HB…

What, I should have kept the vote on you and risked the tie?

[Jamiet99uk]

Remaining Players:

bozotheclown
damo666
Fluminator
Hamilton Brian
Jamiet99uk
KoalaAttack
rdrivera2005
worcej

Probably 6 town and 2 scum.
Assuming a NK tonight, 5 town and 2 scum alive in the morning.

[Jamiet99uk]

JFC HB…

What, I should have kept the vote on you and risked the tie?

You caused a tie.

[Hamilton Brian]

JFC HB…

What, I should have kept the vote on you and risked the tie?

You caused a tie.

Fuck, sorry! Doing this on phone is such shite

[damo666]

Shit, sorry Bona.

Well as vanilla town I am going to catch a lot of shot for this.

Don't help Mafia with the NK you banana.

[Hamilton Brian]

Still stand by my assertion that bozo isn’t scum.

<crumpled up notes and tosses them away>

Have to reevaluate everything.

[Hamilton Brian]

Shit, sorry Bona.

Well as vanilla town I am going to catch a lot of shot for this.

Don't help Mafia with the NK you banana.

They don’t need help. I’ve fucked up.

[Jamiet99uk]

Shit, sorry Bona.

Well as vanilla town I am going to catch a lot of shot for this.

Don't help Mafia with the NK you grapefruit.

Damo, I believe the Mafia can read the thread.

HB's involvement in the EoD, and the fact that he pretty much caused Bona's flip is evident to anyone at even a cursory glance, and the fact that HB would get heat for this and be a likely wagon tomorrow is also evident.

There's nothing to hide here.

[Jamiet99uk]

Re-reading Kakarroto, it stands out to me that on page 10, he strongly criticised KoalaAttack's vote for Bonatogether and said "Bona is a bit silent this game but I get good vibes from him", and he voted Koala (having earlier voted for Flum).

Now, at that moment in time, Bona had made 7 very short posts, as follows:

1. Saying he hadn't read the setup and asking if there's a third party
2. Saying he was in Virginia enroute to South Carolina.
3. Thanking Brainbomb for something (not sure what?)
4. Saying "I like Kak"
5. A vote for KoalaAttack
6. Saying his #1 post about the Third Party was a reaction test.
7. Calling my early exchange with HB "average Jamie vs HB posting".

That's it.

That doesn't seem a very strong basis for Kak saying he "likes" Bona, and taking that to the extent of voting for KoalaAttack in an apparent defence of Bona.

Thoughts? Could this be:

i) Kak protecting his scumbuddy Bona?
ii) Kak buddying Town Bona?
iii) Kak creating theatre with his scumbuddy Koala?

We now know that (i) was not the case, and (ii) was correct.

I would just like to point out that (iii) could also be a possiblity.

[Jamiet99uk]

It's a shame more people were not online at EoD.

[Hamilton Brian]

Maybe but there weren’t that many “missing” votes.

Anyway, I am goi g to go hide. See y’all for the start of D3.

[worcej]

JFC HB…

What, I should have kept the vote on you and risked the tie?

It wasn’t tied when bozo had the lead

[worcej]

What, I should have kept the vote on you and risked the tie?

You caused a tie.

Fuck, sorry! Doing this on phone is such shite

You didn’t realize you forced a tie between bozo and bona? Da fuq?

[KoalaAttack]

bonatogether has died he was Old Tom Bluderbuss a Vanilla Townie

Well, poop. RIP Bona and sorry I voted for you, if it makes you feel better it's because you were too good at pretending to Townie as a Mafia last game.

I am not caught up, just went straight for day result – will go read now.

[Hamilton Brian]

But I didn’t mafiaread Bozo.

I mafiaread Bona.

I mafiaread you.

And I’ve been here before where all of my conclusions are flipped upside down and wrong.

I’m leaving the pub soon and I’m going to hit my shroom stash.

[Hamilton Brian]

You caused a tie.

Fuck, sorry! Doing this on phone is such shite

You didn’t realize you forced a tie between bozo and bona? Da fuq?

Ducking mobile phones and flipping between browser windows. Don’t get all fucking sanctimonious on me about that!

[KoalaAttack]

i never fabricate shit

You do as mafia.

this just isn't true lol

I have to confess – if I were around and read this, I would have kept my vote on Bona regardless.

[KoalaAttack]

How would mafia play the game and never make anything up? <head scratching >.

I've played at least one game as Mafia where I didn't tell a single lie and I bussed multiple team-mates.

Is this like those Diplomacy players who stab you and the try to convince you real hard it was your fault and they didn't actually stab you and they had no choice – and in reality they are convincing themselves because they can't just own up to the stabbing?