Re: M76 - Dungeons and Dragons - Game Thread [HIDDEN]
Posted: Tue Sep 27, 2022 6:04 pm
i may have gotten lost in the weeds here
https://www.webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/
https://www.webdiplomacy.net/contrib/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=4308
Okay here during lunch.damo666 wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 8:07 amI believe this to be unanswerable and the nail in your coffin dear pyxxy.
I appreciate Wolfu taking his time and wanting to be sure and I admire the amount of effort pyxxy is putting in in the circumstances. Wel done!
However the game is up. We just wait on Wolfu to pull the trigger.
Celaph was open to voting bo on D5 and was going to re-read bo:rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Fri Sep 23, 2022 8:11 pmFirst of all, I don't think you should be misskilled, I think you are scum.bo_sox48 wrote: ↑Fri Sep 23, 2022 6:31 pm[edited for length]
I don't really care if you think I should be miskilled. Very few other people seem to have any issue townreading me based on several factors that they have laid out clearly, and you laid out some of those reasons yourself yesterday but forgot about them the moment that I recirculated by scum-has-a-lurker theory and voted for you. Stop playing that way.
Second, I don't think my play is unefecttive. Last game I identified both Snowy and you because the way you both tried to set me up. I also identified Bona as scum based on simple vote analysis logic, which you seem unable to understand and just kept saying "why Bona voted for a PR claimant" which is not a towny tell in any way. So, maybe you should reflect about your play if you are town.
Third, who said you are obviously town? Your only towny moment was that emotional outburst, but it can be easily done as annoyed scum too. And the fact you seem to be getting a pass worries me, because I think I might be NKed or shot tonight.
celaph wrote: ↑Sat Sep 24, 2022 1:05 amSounds like Bo is worth a read too!rdrivera2005 wrote: ↑Fri Sep 23, 2022 1:57 pmI still need to re-read Sabi, but right now I still stick with the obvious. Bo give the chance for Demon to hammer and was tryng to avoid a Bona kill yesterday. He also avoided voting Bona D1 tryng to jump on my wagon. Please don't give him a pass to him if I am not around tomorrow.wolfu wrote: ↑Fri Sep 23, 2022 1:53 pmi think sabi asking to vote first on demon was performative, neon was clearly being stubborn by refusing to unvote and sabi only posted once or twice, it wasn't like they were fightig likehell with neon to do it - and then they voted demon anyway to enable the hammer. so i don't think that is clearing
celaph wrote: ↑Sun Sep 25, 2022 9:19 amI feel like my read on Sabi is hurting from a lack of obvious explanations for their takes. There is certainly things to raise an eyebrow at here, but I want to hear more from them.
In the mean time, ##vote bo because he's next on my to read list and I like mixing it up. Would love to hear people's takes on Bo.
Celaph did vote for sabi after bo but it wasn't out of strong convictions:
Celaph didn't post at all during N5, which is pretty normal for celaph.
- Celaph posts, it's short with no solving, but he promises to be on _later_
I'm not going to tell you not to review damo but consider that D1 damo sat on bona all day. Also I'm pretty sure damo is town re: my VCA last night.wolfu wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:00 pmrumi naming bona/damo/demon as scumleans is pretty cracked if that's the team, lmfao
i could see it coming from a new/inexperienced scum who doesn't realize you're not supposed to just bus your entire team
her pivot to defending damo from Riot is weird
later hedge on damo at the start of day 3 can easily be partnered though
but then there's the suggestion to hammer damo outright which seems out of left field if mafia and the later interactions with him about his read of demon...don't feel scum/scum to me
This is again how I thought about the setup. Like I said, I really like the mech part of mafia. When I read the setup and was introduced to a lot of new roles (h/t mafiascum wiki), I spent some time thinking about the game theory around when the commuter should be using their uses, since this setup they only get 2.
/shrug i've seen scum do that idle bus routine before and it's not like he was agitating for it, so it doesn't strike me as outright impossible, but i might be overly paranoidpyxxy wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 7:47 pmI'm not going to tell you not to review damo but consider that D1 damo sat on bona all day. Also I'm pretty sure damo is town re: my VCA last night.wolfu wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 5:00 pmrumi naming bona/damo/demon as scumleans is pretty cracked if that's the team, lmfao
i could see it coming from a new/inexperienced scum who doesn't realize you're not supposed to just bus your entire team
her pivot to defending damo from Riot is weird
later hedge on damo at the start of day 3 can easily be partnered though
but then there's the suggestion to hammer damo outright which seems out of left field if mafia and the later interactions with him about his read of demon...don't feel scum/scum to me
I was traveling
I think I was checking the game during boarding? Stayed online through EON, saw that I wasn't NK'd, then saw darg get shoot (re: so I was misremembering in my post just about about bo NKs, btw) and was like wtf. I do think I at least remembered to check my webdip PMs since I knew now that chaqa would give me the result through them. Idr if posting PMs is against the rules but it looks like "you scan demon and he is GUILTY"
can't do mobile so I just logged off until the plane was in the air and I could pay $5 for the wifi to satisfy my sick need for an internet forum gamepyxxy wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 7:28 pmIf I do serious typing on my phone I get elbow pain. Someone diagnose me please. I think it's ulnar stuff but idk.RagingIke297 wrote: ↑Sat Sep 17, 2022 6:13 pmWe've been on mobile this whole time baby, just gotta use the preview to make sure it looks good
maybe I'm misremembering or maybe I went to the wrong spot in the bot but I think, yes? you are correct?
In what world was a town read and in what world was I playing well in your eyes?bo_sox48 wrote: ↑Wed Sep 14, 2022 8:26 pmSorry for missing these.pyxxy wrote: ↑Wed Sep 14, 2022 8:02 pmAlso I'm in a bit of a "let the lurkers live a little" phase because it's been wrong in M75 and M1021, which sure is maybe a little more of the gambler's fallacy (trying to nail 1 scum lurking in 3 people is going to miss 2 out of 3 times).
But like I agreed with worcej earlier, I agree with the idea that scum are more likely to be more active because of the N0.
I disagree with pretty much everything you’ve said here but most of it is philosophical so I’ll just say you’re wrong and let it be.
As for not pressuring rdrivera and explicitly noting that you won’t pressure rdrivera because he couldn’t handle pressure in a prior game, that is some bullshit. If he’s too busy to play he just won’t reply - who cares?
##VOTE pyxxy
oh I think I get you nowwolfu wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 8:54 pmnot sure i'm getting through here
what i'm saying is i realize you had limited time and couldn't type much but i'm not sure how HEY EVERYONE I HAVE A GUILTY was not the first thing on your mind when you opened the thread? did you think it could wait several hours until you landed?
on another subject i guess - when you were accusing me of my argument with bona looking like scum theater - have you seen scum arguing like that in your previous games?
and my immediate takeaway is: i'm not sure why you were concerned outing it was a mistake? and further, if you were actually concerned about possibly getting shot, that makes it stranger to me that you waited. wouldn't that have heightened the urgency when you saw rumi outing?pyxxy wrote: ↑Mon Sep 19, 2022 9:59 amI'm caught up from where I got pissed off and went and watch youtube for the rest of the flight.
It's past 2:00am for me (later addition: when I started writing this) and I've been awake for almost 20 hours. So I'm not confident. But this game is already such a shit show that if this is a mistake then so be it. Also I half expected to be shot by now. But I think scum is still holding out hope that the real commuter cc's Demon.
Brain gave me the scan (scrying stone) N1 and I scanned Demon N2 and he's guilty as fuck.
(later addition: actually I had to double check my pm, and it doesn't say who I got it from, just describes the item. more on this near the bottom of this post)
Work wrapping up.wolfu wrote: ↑Tue Sep 27, 2022 11:01 pmokay. i askin because this is the post you made when outing the check:
and my immediate takeaway is: i'm not sure why you were concerned outing it was a mistake? and further, if you were actually concerned about possibly getting shot, that makes it stranger to me that you waited. wouldn't that have heightened the urgency when you saw rumi outing?pyxxy wrote: ↑Mon Sep 19, 2022 9:59 amI'm caught up from where I got pissed off and went and watch youtube for the rest of the flight.
It's past 2:00am for me (later addition: when I started writing this) and I've been awake for almost 20 hours. So I'm not confident. But this game is already such a shit show that if this is a mistake then so be it. Also I half expected to be shot by now. But I think scum is still holding out hope that the real commuter cc's Demon.
Brain gave me the scan (scrying stone) N1 and I scanned Demon N2 and he's guilty as fuck.
(later addition: actually I had to double check my pm, and it doesn't say who I got it from, just describes the item. more on this near the bottom of this post)