webdiplomacy.net

Isn't it four Mafia? Is that a townslip?

Tunneling is when you devote all your attention to a single target and lose sight of anything else and nothing can get you to change your mind.

4 Mafia
1 Godfather
1 Hooker
1 Illusionist
1 Kidnapper

Xorxes, I noted how you came in as me in that game I subbed out of. You literally took over my role that was locked to get lynched. Not only did you salvage a lost position, you led lynch on eden and got fearkilled. That was amazing.

I just read your ISO and you talked a ton about mechanics. I didnt see alot of solving.

Then there was a post about how you scumread reedeer, and you then state you find durga, and some others scummy. I didnt see any townreads but I will reread. Why the playstyle change tho?

brainbomb wrote: ↑

Sun Mar 18, 2018 1:24 am

Xorxes, I noted how you came in as me in that game I subbed out of. You literally took over my role that was locked to get lynched. Not only did you salvage a lost position, you led lynch on eden and got fearkilled. That was amazing.

I just read your ISO and you talked a ton about mechanics. I didnt see alot of solving.

Then there was a post about how you scumread reedeer, and you then state you find durga, and some others scummy. I didnt see any townreads but I will reread. Why the playstyle change tho?

When I took over your position that game was already in day 3 or 4, of course there's a lot you can figure out by then. Do you really expect anyone to have a valid scumread on day 1?

The reason I said one of Durga, Jamiet or Vecna was scum was because both Jamiet and Durga were adamantly claiming that Vecna was not the Deputy, so I thought one of them was the real Deputy but didn't want to claim yet. Durga was completely certain that Vecna was GUAK, even though all the evidence pointed to Deputy, and the only way that could be I thought was if she *knew* he couldn't be the Deputy.

No I just didn't think that he could be so ridiculous.

Finished reading the pages that I missed.

Jamiet lynch was really poor play, we got almost no info from EOD, as there were just few votes close the deadline.
And Jamiet reaction was really disgusting, you should play by the rules or don´t play, there is no excuse for this behaviour.
From the people on Jamiet´s wagon, I think Bozo and Xorxed were the scumiest. Bozo placed a classic anchor vote on Jamiet and just vanished and I expect Xorxes to be a lot better then lynching Jamiet because of his emotional reactions, it looks like scum finding a juice town target to hang. Durga seems the most legit Jamiet pusher and Ezio and Yav should be looked as both votes lack a more substantial reasoning. Anyway, I don´t believe more then two scum would be on the Jamiet wagon considering it was the leading wagon most of the day.
I still have a soft scumread on Bo and Fox and townreads on Snowy, Nesdunk and Tham in this order. The others are null to me.
I know I should probably wait for EON to write reads, but tomorrow will be another busy day and I want to share my thoughts now that I just read the EOD.

BB, Tham, just wondering what the justification is for scumread on me? That one seemed to come out of nowhere.

nesdunk14 wrote: ↑

Sun Mar 18, 2018 2:12 am

BB, Tham, just wondering what the justification is for scumread on me? That one seemed to come out of nowhere.

https://media.giphy.com/media/ESF9cwhWJeMN2/giphy.gif

Who are you in this picture?
The answer is important af.

Two feet in the top left corner, no question.

nesdunk14 wrote: ↑

Sun Mar 18, 2018 2:41 am

Two feet in the top left corner, no question.

Welcome to webdip mafia. My scumread on you was the whole odd thing where you tried to fit in asking durga about being drunk. I thought it was you trying to appear relateable. Are you desperate for approval?

Definitely desperate for approval, but that's just my real life meta.

nesdunk14 wrote: ↑

Sun Mar 18, 2018 2:49 am

Definitely desperate for approval, but that's just my real life meta.

Same. Good answer. Who you got in your scum circle?

Ghug and durga are interesting this game. They really havent had much to say to me I feel lile ghug would. He read me wrong last game and invented some crazy town paranoia theory on me knowing that if he knows a setup its because hes a PR . Mostly looking at that Ghug appeared to like both wagons. I dont understand how ghug and durga are spread out, and cooperating. Interesting.

Last time these two cooperated both were wolves.

Ghug, which do you love more, chaqa's mullet, vash's spikey hair, or Jamiet99uk's hairy, poorly groomed sweaty undercarriage?

Welcome BB, your arrival is bittersweet for me because I enjoy games that you are in much more, but I’m in PR all this week so it will be even more of a struggle to keep up and stay active.
Jamit is known for his temper, I hope he is able to return next game a little cooler.
Xorsex does seem somewhat scummy now that the light is on him, but we’ll see Tomorow.

@nesdunk - most of your interactions read as awkward, and it just feels like you know too much. You also haven't answered direct questions to you on a couple occasions (from Durga, from me, yavuz).

There's some weird interactions between you and Foxcastle that I definitely think could be m/m (mafia/mafia)

I thought Jamie refusing to acknowledge that Vecna could not have shot Vashta the way he did as GUAK was suspicious, it seemed to me his reaction could have been fake because I did not think he would ignore the facts as town. I do not think it was a bad lynch because I did not see any better options develop.

[/quote]

Same. Good answer. Who you got in your scum circle?
[/quote]

Anyone who voted Jamiet is suspect for me.

thamrick wrote: ↑

Sun Mar 18, 2018 3:36 am

@nesdunk - most of your interactions read as awkward, and it just feels like you know too much. You also haven't answered direct questions to you on a couple occasions (from Durga, from me, yavuz).

Fair enough, especially on the second point. On the former, I'd chalk it up to never having played with y'all before. Latter, honestly there's so much coming so quick sometimes that I can barely keep up, and less important questions or points are pushed to the wayside for me. That's not really any different than what I've seen from many other players, and I'm sure I could find some examples.

rdrivera usually finds a better reason to scum read me, and I find his analysis questionable in general, I could see him as scum this game. I think he is wrong to say the lynch was not informative because there were few votes close to the deadline. With the double and zero vote powers and Jamie and Ezio within one vote, I think the lack of EOD vote changes does provide information.

##CALL GM

I deleted both of Jamie's deadposts. I can bring them back if you two prefer it. Just let me know.