M62: PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF REVOLUTIONARY MAFIA GAME THREAD!

[Balki Bartokomous]

I both (a) love this moment of anticipation and (b) want it to end now.

[Hellenic Riot]

If you weren't going to out the report immediately, you shouldn't have claimed at all...


I'll be back in 46.5 hours

[Durga]

If you weren't going to out the report immediately, you shouldn't have claimed at all...


I'll be back in 46.5 hours

HR scum

[VashtaNeurotic]

Hiya yall! I'm back from my walk.

Vig you screwed up :/

In my defense. It's hard to have accurate kills when you are barely reading the game, so killing the second wagon if the first was village to accelerate the game was the best I could do. Was contemplating just going after Vecna anyway but uh, yeah forgot to change stuff. Anyway, 50% hit rate is pretty alright and HB was probably going to get DK'd at some point.

[ghug]

The only way I can see for a tracker to catch multiple scum members is if she tracked the Smuggler & knows they're scum because they performed the kill as well. But unless she was sitting on a guilty for the entirety of D2, I don't see how she can have caught three...

Player A visits player B N1
Player A visits player C and Nephthys (or HB, I suppose) N2

A is smuggler, B and C both scum. Or A is rb, B and C both town.

Though that would make me pretty certain it's three. The way she suggests that Neph's role matters makes me think she saw someone she thinks is the investigator visit Neph N1, and then saw someone else visit Neph and a third player N2.

[aarodactyl]

Hammering is not an option in this setup, Eden removed the option to hammer. All phases have a set length.

This is a good reason for her not to tell us, or at least not tell us everything for about half of the day.

Yeah, I think it'll be interesting to see how scum play this phase. I'll probably reveal an hour before EoD

This is essentially going to pause the game for the next two days, right? And then the thread is going a huge mess for the last hour.

[Fluminator]

The problem is Durga none of our votes will mean anything right now since they won't be in danger this round unless they happen to be your scan in which case they were dead anyway.

I'd rather know who at least one scum is now so we can use that info asap.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Hammering is not an option in this setup, Eden removed the option to hammer. All phases have a set length.

This is a good reason for her not to tell us, or at least not tell us everything for about half of the day.

Yeah, I think it'll be interesting to see how scum play this phase. I'll probably reveal an hour before EoD

Don’t do that. I don’t want to waste my time reading the game if we already have some answers.

[worcej]

The only way I can see for a tracker to catch multiple scum members is if she tracked the Smuggler & knows they're scum because they performed the kill as well. But unless she was sitting on a guilty for the entirety of D2, I don't see how she can have caught three...

I also cannot understand how she caught 3 based on the setup information.

If she saw 3 people move onto her target, one has to be a town PR of some sort.

[Hellenic Riot]

If you weren't going to out the report immediately, you shouldn't have claimed at all...


I'll be back in 46.5 hours

HR scum

Nobody is going to give a fuck about the entire day when we're all sitting waiting for a reveal.

[Durga]

Naw but it'll help me. Plus it's not like I know them all? No reason not to continue scum hunting

[kgray]

HR not even going to pretend he looked at EoD2 votes like he said he would. Was fully expecting him to claim his damo stuff was a reaction test after he the way he was talking to Flum about it. And he’s scumreading worcej because of the TvT thing and not damo?

I don’t like half of his reads/reasons and I didn’t feel that way at all when we were town together in M60.

Also why does balki have no read of me? Seriously dude?

Didn't I? You'll notice that I've now got scumreads on 2 of the 3 people who jumped between the main wagons (Flum & Maniac) and a distinct lack of a townread on the third (Vecna). Of the people who stayed on HB and were present, celaph was the only one of note and I actually really liked his explanation at the time of why he'd consider jumping but was staying on HB.

And worcej was much more vocal on the TvT thing, so it looks much worse from him. Indeed damo made only one post during the EoD, which was to quote & agree with worcej... And I see zero reason whatsoever for a scum member who is happy with both wagons being on town to announce their presence and draw attention like that.

Anything else?

So how does this not apply to worcej then??

[ghug]

Hammering is not an option in this setup, Eden removed the option to hammer. All phases have a set length.

This is a good reason for her not to tell us, or at least not tell us everything for about half of the day.

Yeah, I think it'll be interesting to see how scum play this phase. I'll probably reveal an hour before EoD

I think there's a real possibility that the game starts to lag if you don't tell us. I'd consider giving us one of the ones you're less sure on if the game slows down and telling us not to vote there just to stoke discussion.

[worcej]

The only way I can see for a tracker to catch multiple scum members is if she tracked the Smuggler & knows they're scum because they performed the kill as well. But unless she was sitting on a guilty for the entirety of D2, I don't see how she can have caught three...

Player A visits player B N1
Player A visits player C and Nephthys (or HB, I suppose) N2

A is smuggler, B and C both scum. Or A is rb, B and C both town.

Though that would make me pretty certain it's three. The way she suggests that Neph's role matters makes me think she saw someone she thinks is the investigator visit Neph N1, and then saw someone else visit Neph and a third player N2.

This is the best explanation for seeing 3.

[Hellenic Riot]

HR not even going to pretend he looked at EoD2 votes like he said he would. Was fully expecting him to claim his damo stuff was a reaction test after he the way he was talking to Flum about it. And he’s scumreading worcej because of the TvT thing and not damo?

I don’t like half of his reads/reasons and I didn’t feel that way at all when we were town together in M60.

Also why does balki have no read of me? Seriously dude?

Didn't I? You'll notice that I've now got scumreads on 2 of the 3 people who jumped between the main wagons (Flum & Maniac) and a distinct lack of a townread on the third (Vecna). Of the people who stayed on HB and were present, celaph was the only one of note and I actually really liked his explanation at the time of why he'd consider jumping but was staying on HB.

And worcej was much more vocal on the TvT thing, so it looks much worse from him. Indeed damo made only one post during the EoD, which was to quote & agree with worcej... And I see zero reason whatsoever for a scum member who is happy with both wagons being on town to announce their presence and draw attention like that.

Anything else?

So how does this not apply to worcej then??

Because worcej made a hell of a lot more posts and seemed determined to gain the moral high ground no matter the outcome?

[aarodactyl]

Naw but it'll help me. Plus it's not like I know them all? No reason not to continue scum hunting

Won't knowing some confirmed scum help with figuring out who else is scum?

[Hellenic Riot]

##unvote

[worcej]

Naw but it'll help me. Plus it's not like I know them all? No reason not to continue scum hunting

I think you've heard enough reasons why this is a bad play.

Whoever you say you saw is going to be day killed to confirm what you saw and if they were just normal players, then you're next.

[kgray]

This is a good reason for her not to tell us, or at least not tell us everything for about half of the day.

Yeah, I think it'll be interesting to see how scum play this phase. I'll probably reveal an hour before EoD

Don’t do that. I don’t want to waste my time reading the game if we already have some answers.

Okay don’t reread then, just tell me what your read of me now is. I actually can’t believe you have me as null.

[worcej]

Didn't I? You'll notice that I've now got scumreads on 2 of the 3 people who jumped between the main wagons (Flum & Maniac) and a distinct lack of a townread on the third (Vecna). Of the people who stayed on HB and were present, celaph was the only one of note and I actually really liked his explanation at the time of why he'd consider jumping but was staying on HB.

And worcej was much more vocal on the TvT thing, so it looks much worse from him. Indeed damo made only one post during the EoD, which was to quote & agree with worcej... And I see zero reason whatsoever for a scum member who is happy with both wagons being on town to announce their presence and draw attention like that.

Anything else?

So how does this not apply to worcej then??

Because worcej made a hell of a lot more posts and seemed determined to gain the moral high ground no matter the outcome?

You seem to forget that I always rub poo in the face of people who are wrong and I was right.