M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Fluminator]

What's flum's question to me again?

And what question are you referring to, Dip?

I could see Dip and Bunny bussing Hamilton. I guess the question is, with a daychat, does Hamilton agree to be bussed?

Are you ever going to be surprised if I flip.

Or maybe not.

But then it becomes "guess the mafia who jumped on to Brian to save damo."

If you flipping town means Damo is scum, why aren't you assuming you're town here.

[Fluminator]

This really strikes me as scum pretending to give analysis on the game state to blend in, but not actually believing it.

[Hamilton Brian]

What's flum's question to me again?

And what question are you referring to, Dip?

When you wrote that post (on page 16), were you aware I and others had already asked it?

Of course I wasn't aware. If I had read where it had been asked and there was a reasonable answer, I wouldn't have wasted my time typing that up.

[sweetandcool]

Im calling it, unless something changes Fluminator gotta go for what he said here
##vote Fluminator

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

From this point I got several cases against people;

Those who bandwagoned Jamie right out of the gate are super sus, they jumped on an easy target for his attitude, and even voted for him! Like that's not even playing the game seriously.

Kak super defended himself against that troll thing he did in the beginning with the no-vote people D1, like sure explain yourself and move on but he KEPT ON TALKING ABOUT IT. That isnt normal

Vecna & HamiltonBrian both asked about how many mafia there are, so either they didnt pay attention at ALL to the signup thread(mega DOUBT!) or their asking a mafia type useless question...clearly no one is going with my Flum catch so Im voting HamiltonBrian since he's the only one I have on my suspicions lists...but im still reading so I might flip ##VOTE HamiltonBrian

I also suspect D&W slightly for putting me as Lawful Good, but need more

Suspicious you jump off of Flum right when I jump back on the wagon.

Come back and prove yourself!

[Hamilton Brian]

What's flum's question to me again?

And what question are you referring to, Dip?

I could see Dip and Bunny bussing Hamilton. I guess the question is, with a daychat, does Hamilton agree to be bussed?

Are you ever going to be surprised if I flip.

Or maybe not.

But then it becomes "guess the mafia who jumped on to Brian to save damo."

If you flipping town means Damo is scum, why aren't you assuming you're town here.

How is your question related to my statement? And I am not being snarky; I am not seeing the connection.

[FlaviusAetius]

Jamie did you actually hard claim because you were the top wagon and felt you needed to do so to save yourself? Or do you have some other strange reason?

FACTS. Jamie what on earth were you thinking its sitll so early and if you read literally anything people were just voting you because they didnt like your attitude, thats so easy to fix and you didnt need to give up something so early for basically NO REASON AT ALL

[Vecna]

Im calling it, unless something changes Fluminator gotta go for what he said here
##vote Fluminator

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

From this point I got several cases against people;

Those who bandwagoned Jamie right out of the gate are super sus, they jumped on an easy target for his attitude, and even voted for him! Like that's not even playing the game seriously.

Kak super defended himself against that troll thing he did in the beginning with the no-vote people D1, like sure explain yourself and move on but he KEPT ON TALKING ABOUT IT. That isnt normal

Vecna & HamiltonBrian both asked about how many mafia there are, so either they didnt pay attention at ALL to the signup thread(mega DOUBT!) or their asking a mafia type useless question...clearly no one is going with my Flum catch so Im voting HamiltonBrian since he's the only one I have on my suspicions lists...but im still reading so I might flip ##VOTE HamiltonBrian

I also suspect D&W slightly for putting me as Lawful Good, but need more

what is happening in these signup threads that people are so willing to read 17 or however many pages of it there were?

Its customary the setup is in the gamethread. Noting a rather important detail is not there (even if most of us understand full well itll probably be noted in the signup thread) is noteworthy.

Its nai, especially the later people stating it, but putting so much weight on that sole fact to scumread people is rather lazy. Especially when said people have provided plenty of content since (well in some cases).

[FlaviusAetius]

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

From this point I got several cases against people;

Those who bandwagoned Jamie right out of the gate are super sus, they jumped on an easy target for his attitude, and even voted for him! Like that's not even playing the game seriously.

Kak super defended himself against that troll thing he did in the beginning with the no-vote people D1, like sure explain yourself and move on but he KEPT ON TALKING ABOUT IT. That isnt normal

Vecna & HamiltonBrian both asked about how many mafia there are, so either they didnt pay attention at ALL to the signup thread(mega DOUBT!) or their asking a mafia type useless question...clearly no one is going with my Flum catch so Im voting HamiltonBrian since he's the only one I have on my suspicions lists...but im still reading so I might flip ##VOTE HamiltonBrian

I also suspect D&W slightly for putting me as Lawful Good, but need more

Suspicious you jump off of Flum right when I jump back on the wagon.

Come back and prove yourself!

DEAL(i didnt know you jumped back on)
##vote fluminator

THE CASE FOR FLUMINATOR;
Is him suspecting sweetandcool because sweetandcool would accept a tadpole, so he THINKS sweetandcool is a TOWN, yet wants him out anyways! This is a trait half of the people here would do, most people are accepting that tadpole if you want to admit it yourself or not.
Also asking the question is not only useless(cause most people would do it), but ALSO if you are a PR thats pretty much the ONLY REASON you wouldnt accept the tadpole so thats a roundabout way of finding people who are PR and who are not. Its just so CRAZY to even ask this question and then continue to PUSH and DEFEND IT!!

[FlaviusAetius]

I can forgive an obviously weak case at the beginning when we're all grasping at straws but surely something else has come up since then in the last 20 pages

From this point I got several cases against people;

Those who bandwagoned Jamie right out of the gate are super sus, they jumped on an easy target for his attitude, and even voted for him! Like that's not even playing the game seriously.

Kak super defended himself against that troll thing he did in the beginning with the no-vote people D1, like sure explain yourself and move on but he KEPT ON TALKING ABOUT IT. That isnt normal

Vecna & HamiltonBrian both asked about how many mafia there are, so either they didnt pay attention at ALL to the signup thread(mega DOUBT!) or their asking a mafia type useless question...clearly no one is going with my Flum catch so Im voting HamiltonBrian since he's the only one I have on my suspicions lists...but im still reading so I might flip ##VOTE HamiltonBrian

I also suspect D&W slightly for putting me as Lawful Good, but need more

what is happening in these signup threads that people are so willing to read 17 or however many pages of it there were?

Its customary the setup is in the gamethread. Noting a rather important detail is not there (even if most of us understand full well itll probably be noted in the signup thread) is noteworthy.

Its nai, especially the later people stating it, but putting so much weight on that sole fact to scumread people is rather lazy. Especially when said people have provided plenty of content since (well in some cases).

FINE, but you arent going to find one singular thing most likely thats going to say "this person is 100% a mafia" its a bunch of little things together that bring the case on someone, where you gotta vote for them. You cant deny that this is something that makes someone more likely a mafia than not. SURE there are other things that it should be based on, AGREED.

[DemonRHK]

Ya know, I was looking for a spicy vote just to make waves, but the day's been pretty shotgun with the vote spread. I don't see anything that stands out. I mean I could suicide vote, but No Kill isn't a hill I wanna do because death is a good thing in mafia.

Sadface.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

This really strikes me as scum pretending to give analysis on the game state to blend in, but not actually believing it.

What does?

[sweetandcool]

What's with the quick Jamie wagon right out of the gate? That's absurd.

Vecna, Sweet, Squigs...giving you three the hairy eyeball.

Why is it absurd?

Why is any fast wagon absurd in a 24h game?

Do you think the reason of jamiet potentially faking anger is not a good one?

Why make this statement and point at all 3 people?

None of this feels like a natural towny thought.

Because its not even based on anything :facepalm: jamie being unpleasant is not indicative of ANYTHING! Not him being a mafia not him being a townie. Its just how Jamie is, the fact that so many people JUMPED on him RIGHT AWAY is what is ridiculous

I find it hurtful for you to claim that is just how Jamiet is.

#NotmyJamiet

[FlaviusAetius]

Alr I'm caught up on the thread again.
New alignment chart:
7x7_blank - with names - Copy.jpg
A few notes:
ghug feels like he is powerwolfing
Bunny seems to be playing as town but is doing it an extremely messy fashion (ChatGPT), so he is Anarchic Good
Hamilton has not made a single good post this game
Fluminator

I'm also going to ##VOTE HAMILTONBRIAN

Ok now I agree with tht other dude there is no way you are going to post this chart every so often without any context, your few notes are not good enough

[FlaviusAetius]

Ya know, I was looking for a spicy vote just to make waves, but the day's been pretty shotgun with the vote spread. I don't see anything that stands out. I mean I could suicide vote, but No Kill isn't a hill I wanna do because death is a good thing in mafia.

Sadface.

NO we need to decide on SOMEONE thats the WHOLE REASON we said that voting no one is a BAD IDEA. We NEED to see where people land and for what reasons people land on to be able to compare later with later info we get.

[aarodactyl]

Work is super busy. I’m trying to read here and there but am only up to page 41. I’m be on lunch break soon and will read up then. I’ll be missing eod due to a meeting that starts 30 minutes before it.

[sweetandcool]

Screw it. I don't care that it's non-competitive at this point.

##VOTE DiplomacyandWarfare

You're trying to act like angry town, but I don't think you are.

Doesn't sound angry to me.

Sounds like an authentic scumread.

[DemonRHK]

Ya know, I was looking for a spicy vote just to make waves, but the day's been pretty shotgun with the vote spread. I don't see anything that stands out. I mean I could suicide vote, but No Kill isn't a hill I wanna do because death is a good thing in mafia.

Sadface.

NO we need to decide on SOMEONE thats the WHOLE REASON we said that voting no one is a BAD IDEA. We NEED to see where people land and for what reasons people land on to be able to compare later with later info we get.

Gamer, find the meds. I said that No kill sucks. It's a game of info. We need info, good or bad.

Plus my 30 second skim of the setup post looks like there is a recruit mechanic, pool narrowing is key.

[DemonRHK]

Self note when backsearching:

Discovered leadswap, if HB does flip red chk more.

[DemonRHK]

So.

3.5, 4th, or 5th?

I'm one of the few fans of 4th myself.

[Bonatogether]

anything interesting happenijg