M1027: Community - Game Thread

[heartthrob24909]

I'd rather get sweet, but open to switching to ghug.

I don't love this. Monarch reminds me of someone who either
- Isn't paying enough attention to do much other than vote for the most low-hanging fruit of the moment, or
- Is scum looking for plausible votes

I wish she'd chime in a little more. Monarch, what do you think of Sweet's recent conversation with Just? What makes Ghug an OK alternative to Sweet?

##vote TheMadMonarch

[heartthrob24909]

Well, the night result was pretty good, one clear and one possible miskill NKed, if Investigator keeps hidden and we catch scum today we can probably win this one.

I think both Ghug and Sweet are good wagons. Ghug because he is being Ghug but with less teeth and Sweet is just being all over the place but can't really see where he is coming from.

Bozo is a bad wagon, at least for today, if he is alive later and not Investigated we can worry about him.

I will ##vote Hamilton right now as I still think he is just floating around. His interaction with Bozo was the first time he showed up but it's NAI at most as they approach the game in opposite ways no matter alignment.

Other then Dargo, my town core includes Heart, MM and Will. Won't vote those. Probably Jamiet too.

I think I disagree that Sweet is a good wagon... will def eat my words if I'm wrong but I'm reading him more as someone who just has trouble articulating his points and has to flounder while they keep getting misinterpreted.

Sweet's antics basically guarantee that he'll be a DK at SOME point, whether bc he's actually scum or bc he ends up being a miskill, so I'd almost prefer we save that for later and focus on other people right now. Lmk if this is completely off base though... I'm open to being told to shut up about this lol

[heartthrob24909]

That was D1 not N1.

no?

I was talking about this post:

Last game, you were scum. You KNEW who was on your scumteam. You knew whether or not Will was your team mate, the GM literally told you when the game began. So it was not a legitimate read.

This is basic shit.

Oh, that exchange. Yes, I see.

##Vote Sweetandcool

These quotes from Sweet certainly don't feel credible but I don't think that necessarily makes them scummy.

[heartthrob24909]

Sweet and Jamie had an altercation last night that I, in a very surprising turn of events, sided with Jamie on.

Then sweet has been weird again this morning.

I really wish bunny was in this game, he would understand.

Have you read his notes in the godthread for other Mafia games? He frequently reads people's alignment, ignoring the fact as Mafia or spectator he would know it.

I am baffled so many people on this website think it is impossible to make alignment reads as Mafia.

It is impossible to make genuine ones because as Mafia you already know the fucking answer.

Making a "read" involves deduction. It is not possible to deduce an answer you were handed in writing at the outset of the game!

This is a valid point to make, and one I agree with, but I can't get behind it being justification for voting for Sweet right now in this game

[dargorygel]

no?

I was talking about this post:

Oh, that exchange. Yes, I see.

##Vote Sweetandcool

These quotes from Sweet certainly don't feel credible but I don't think that necessarily makes them scummy.

where do you quote something from Sweet here?

[heartthrob24909]

Oh, that exchange. Yes, I see.

##Vote Sweetandcool

These quotes from Sweet certainly don't feel credible but I don't think that necessarily makes them scummy.

where do you quote something from Sweet here?

Oh, I need to use that Preview feature more. The Monarch post which I quoted includes quotes from Sweet

[heartthrob24909]

Just has only played 2 games previously, and you were mafia in both, so I don't think you have had the opportunity to constantly scum reading him. Last game when I pointed out something like this you said you read players even when you are mafia, but it turned out you were mafia, so it looks like that was a fabricated explanation.

How many games have you played with Kakarroto?

Probably 4, idk.

That explanation was true. I don't care what you think, I am perfectly capable of scum reading players as any alignment.

Like last game I scumread Will and consequently voted him. If I didn't scumread him, I wouldn't have voted him. It's that simple.

Last game, you were scum. You KNEW who was on your scumteam. You knew whether or not Will was your team mate, the GM literally told you when the game began. So it was not a legitimate read.

This is basic shit.

@darg

[dargorygel]

Would scum divide up townies to buddy?

[Jamiet99uk]

I think it should be Sweet'n'kewl or Hamilton'n'Brian today.

Can you succinctly declare why? thanks

Sweet based partly on yesterday, and partly for his absurd claims about having genuine authentic scumreads as scum. Feels like it comes from a scum mindset.

Hamilton because of his buddying / pocketing yesterday, and because he was a viable counterwagon to you or Kak but faded away at EoD.

[Jamiet99uk]

Would scum divide up townies to buddy?

They don't get a N0 chat.

[dargorygel]

Would scum divide up townies to buddy?

They don't get a N0 chat.

But they could observe what is happening

[ghug]

Would scum divide up townies to buddy?

They don't get a N0 chat.

But they could observe what is happening

At least for myself, this has never been a consideration.

[Jamiet99uk]

They don't get a N0 chat.

But they could observe what is happening

At least for myself, this has never been a consideration.

Ghug has not been co-ordinating his buddying with the other scum, got it.

[dargorygel]

They don't get a N0 chat.

But they could observe what is happening

At least for myself, this has never been a consideration.

I have not either. Butbwhen looking for it, it seems like a lot in this game. Maybe everyone is just nice because of Christmas...

[ghug]

Do the people voting sweet right now really think he'd be bold enough to draw attention to his having read into the softing that got damo killed?

[Jamiet99uk]

Do the people voting sweet right now really think he'd be bold enough to draw attention to his having read into the softing that got damo killed?

He seems to have a habit of saying things that a sensible person would not say.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why are people voting for Bozo?

[ghug]

I think Heart is scum.

No I will not be explaining why.

Not yet....

I think heart is town.

Sweet, what happened to this?

[ghug]

Do the people voting sweet right now really think he'd be bold enough to draw attention to his having read into the softing that got damo killed?

He seems to have a habit of saying things that a sensible person would not say.

Someday I hope you'll stop scumreading people for this.

[heartthrob24909]

Do the people voting sweet right now really think he'd be bold enough to draw attention to his having read into the softing that got damo killed?

He seems to have a habit of saying things that a sensible person would not say.

Don't think this is the same as being scummy though