Mafia round 93: hot potato! (game thread)

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I never had a potato btw

[DreamTrawler]

Ok so the couch potato only moves EoD. So whoever has it now has it tomorrow.

[DreamTrawler]

I never had a potato btw

I did :)

I don't mind revealing who I threw it to since it's unlikely to do anything at this point. Or not, it's kinda just extraneous info

[DreamTrawler]

Mimi should announce at EON. Especially as she is known to no longer have SP (assuming she was telling the truth) and is a prime NK target (if she isn't scum).

i am also a prime mk target atp so it's entirely possible that scum just chooses someone else

O dear. Highly suss post from Mimi. Perhaps I was wrong.

Sus how?

[BunnyGo]

Also we shoulda killed bunny tbh

Ehhh…what’s up, doc?

Its rabbit season

Just season

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ehhh…what’s up, doc?

Its rabbit season

Just season

Rabbit season

[BunnyGo]

Its rabbit season

Just season

Rabbit season

Just season

[miminena]

Mimi should announce at EON. Especially as she is known to no longer have SP (assuming she was telling the truth) and is a prime NK target (if she isn't scum).

i am also a prime mk target atp so it's entirely possible that scum just chooses someone else

O dear. Highly suss post from Mimi. Perhaps I was wrong.

if i'm scum though you'll know though by eon if i don't die except for a few edge cases

if i'm scum and i didn't have the sweet potato i'll likely incorrectly guess who correctly has it, and if i did have the sweet potato from what i understand i'm generally incentivized to target whoever I passed it to to ensure it isn't around late game

[damo666]

miminena has already done what needs to happen so far (unless someone is going to counter claim). The current holder should stay hidden until D2.

Why not at EON?

EON is better if they are available to do it in the last minute, if not, I think it is better to wait until D2.

She might not make D2!

[Kakarroto]

hmm, thinking about it, maybe EoN is still too soon to reveal. Like, if everyone knows whose vote doesn't count, then that player doesn't have a reason to try, right?

But is it worth losing track of the couch potato for that? I wanna hear some opinions, if I should reveal at EoN, during the day or at like EoD? What are the pro's and con's you think about here.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

hmm, thinking about it, maybe EoN is still too soon to reveal. Like, if everyone knows whose vote doesn't count, then that player doesn't have a reason to try, right?

But is it worth losing track of the couch potato for that? I wanna hear some opinions, if I should reveal at EoN, during the day or at like EoD? What are the pro's and con's you think about here.

actually nope
this is no longer a good idea - only reason I thought it was is that I didn't understand how couch potato works (see my previous posts)

[bozotheclown]

I think it is worth tracking the HPs the same as the SP, since otherwise the mafia would have more information about them, although it probably doesn't matter much. I did not have an HP D1.

[damo666]

i am also a prime mk target atp so it's entirely possible that scum just chooses someone else

O dear. Highly suss post from Mimi. Perhaps I was wrong.

Sus how?

It's like she's explaining why she won't be the nk because she knows she won't be.

[damo666]

Just season

Rabbit season

Just season

What with?

[miminena]

Just season

Rabbit season

Just season

darg season >:3

[damo666]

i am also a prime mk target atp so it's entirely possible that scum just chooses someone else

O dear. Highly suss post from Mimi. Perhaps I was wrong.

if i'm scum though you'll know though by eon if i don't die except for a few edge cases

if i'm scum and i didn't have the sweet potato i'll likely incorrectly guess who correctly has it, and if i did have the sweet potato from what i understand i'm generally incentivized to target whoever I passed it to to ensure it isn't around late game

So, if your'e scum you simply don't target who you passed it to and claim that townclears you. Doesn't work. I'm not saying you're scum but your less strong town than you were.

[damo666]

I think it is worth tracking the HPs the same as the SP, since otherwise the mafia would have more information about them, although it probably doesn't matter much. I did not have an HP D1.

I did have a potato of any description day 1

[bozotheclown]

hmm, thinking about it, maybe EoN is still too soon to reveal. Like, if everyone knows whose vote doesn't count, then that player doesn't have a reason to try, right?

But is it worth losing track of the couch potato for that? I wanna hear some opinions, if I should reveal at EoN, during the day or at like EoD? What are the pro's and con's you think about here.

I think the CP should be tracked the same way as the SP and HPs, I don't see why we would want to lose track of it.

[damo666]

I think it is worth tracking the HPs the same as the SP, since otherwise the mafia would have more information about them, although it probably doesn't matter much. I did not have an HP D1.

I did have a potato of any description day 1

whoops I did NOT have a potato of any description day 1

[rdrivera2005]

Well, missed EOD.
Not a great outcome but I would have voted for ND so I won't pretend I would have made better.

Less sure about Bo now, pushing a town ND would have been a lot easier then pushing me.

Weird Damo move.