M55: The Last Party - Game Thread

[xorxes]

summit: as close to a mechanical clear as we will ever get. Rules and Mafia roles imply there's a Town Alignment Cop and a Mafia Lawyer or equivalent. If this was put there just to lead town astray, bad worcej.

bozo: not clear, but not a high chance of being scum based on my info. If it turns out that there's a fifth scum, then maybe he could be that fifth columnist.

Chaqa: similar to bozo. He joked at one point he might be a Traitor Neighborizer and jokes must always be taken seriously.

foodcoats: many towny moments. His role, on the other hand, looks so much like it could be part of a JOAT that it gives me pause.

Neph: I was scumreading him early on, then townreading him, then doubting, then townreading him again. Rollercoaster of reads. Just on the right side of the divide.

damo: too laid back to be scum? Maybe.

Bunny: too many indications that he is scum. I'm curious to find out how he figured out my role. Also, dargo was my first vote because Chaqa told me he was scum.

Vecna: too scummy to be scum just doesn't apply to him.

[bozotheclown]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

[Nephthys]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

That requires three remaining scum AND specifically Chaqa and food.

That really doesn't make sense

[Chaqa]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

Eh, I slipped up in one of my many times playing this game after smoking.

StonedChaqa is not nearly as competent as DrunkBunny, unfortunately.

[BunnyGo]

@xorxes. I don’t know why you’re curious. And I don’t know why you’re not listening more to bozo. A lot of your reads of me and logic are based on chaqa being Town.

[BunnyGo]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

Eh, I slipped up in one of my many times playing this game after smoking.

StonedChaqa is not nearly as competent as DrunkBunny, unfortunately.

Are you scum slipping here?!

[bozotheclown]

BunnyGo, Chaqa, and foodcoats all voted END on Squigs after Vecna, damo, and summit made their cases to vote for Temasek over Squigs, but all ended up voting for Temasek after Jamie made a mislynch of Temasek feasible.

[BunnyGo]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

That requires three remaining scum AND specifically Chaqa and food.

That really doesn't make sense

One could be scum and the other err.

[bozotheclown]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

That requires three remaining scum AND specifically Chaqa and food.

That really doesn't make sense

It could be just one of them, or there could be 3 scum.

[foodcoats]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

I may have missed that. Sorry. But from my perspective - being town - it has helped me solve the game.

We don't need to pussyfoot any longer. We know the scum. BunnyGo and damo.

If you have good reasoning that leads to a different set of scum, by all means I would like to hear it. But a lot of what I have heard today is, "if the scum were clever, then that would not be the case!" But that is not adequate, and as town it is up to us to now win this with good reasoning. We have to work on evidence and an evaluation of possible scum strategies, not on wondering how clever or not scum are.

[Chaqa]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

Eh, I slipped up in one of my many times playing this game after smoking.

StonedChaqa is not nearly as competent as DrunkBunny, unfortunately.

Are you scum slipping here?!

I do not understand the conclusions you make. I slipped up by revealing Bozo was in the QT.

[foodcoats]

BunnyGo, Chaqa, and foodcoats all voted END on Squigs after Vecna, damo, and summit made their cases to vote for Temasek over Squigs, but all ended up voting for Temasek after Jamie made a mislynch of Temasek feasible.

I was very confident Squigs was scum and I am sad we missed him that day. I moved because I was checking intermittently - 5 p.m. EST is always intermittent for me - and I saw it was tied 6-6. I hemmed and hawed and finally swore and put in the Temasek vote, because I did feel confident that he was probably scum, too, and I worried I was being vain in demanding we lynch Squigs.

But I was right.

And that.

Is why.

I will.

Lynch.

Bunny.

Tomorrow.

And then.

I will lynch.

damo the next day.

GOT'EM

[BunnyGo]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

I may have missed that. Sorry. But from my perspective - being town - it has helped me solve the game.

We don't need to pussyfoot any longer. We know the scum. BunnyGo and damo.

If you have good reasoning that leads to a different set of scum, by all means I would like to hear it. But a lot of what I have heard today is, "if the scum were clever, then that would not be the case!" But that is not adequate, and as town it is up to us to now win this with good reasoning. We have to work on evidence and an evaluation of possible scum strategies, not on wondering how clever or not scum are.

I don’t know why you’re not listening to bozo. I know why you discount what I say.

[bozotheclown]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

I may have missed that. Sorry. But from my perspective - being town - it has helped me solve the game.

We don't need to pussyfoot any longer. We know the scum. BunnyGo and damo.

If you have good reasoning that leads to a different set of scum, by all means I would like to hear it. But a lot of what I have heard today is, "if the scum were clever, then that would not be the case!" But that is not adequate, and as town it is up to us to now win this with good reasoning. We have to work on evidence and an evaluation of possible scum strategies, not on wondering how clever or not scum are.

BunnyGo and damo is possible. It is also possible there are more than 2 scum. It is also possible there is an inquisitor left. If damo is mafia, he took a big chance going for the Temasek mislynch when Squigs was up 10-2.

[BunnyGo]

Eh, I slipped up in one of my many times playing this game after smoking.

StonedChaqa is not nearly as competent as DrunkBunny, unfortunately.

Are you scum slipping here?!

I do not understand the conclusions you make. I slipped up by revealing Bozo was in the QT.

You’re saying bozo caught you because you slipped up.

[bozotheclown]

BunnyGo, Chaqa, and foodcoats all voted END on Squigs after Vecna, damo, and summit made their cases to vote for Temasek over Squigs, but all ended up voting for Temasek after Jamie made a mislynch of Temasek feasible.

I was very confident Squigs was scum and I am sad we missed him that day. I moved because I was checking intermittently - 5 p.m. EST is always intermittent for me - and I saw it was tied 6-6. I hemmed and hawed and finally swore and put in the Temasek vote, because I did feel confident that he was probably scum, too, and I worried I was being vain in demanding we lynch Squigs.

But I was right.

And that.

Is why.

I will.

Lynch.

Bunny.

Tomorrow.

And then.

I will lynch.

damo the next day.

GOT'EM

That is believable, but according to the bot, Chaqa had already broken the tie 2 minutes before your vote.

[Chaqa]

Are you scum slipping here?!

I do not understand the conclusions you make. I slipped up by revealing Bozo was in the QT.

You’re saying bozo caught you because you slipped up.

No, I'm saying I slipped up in revealing Bozo was in our QT.

Sometimes I wonder if the two of us live in fundamentally different realities.

[foodcoats]

BunnyGo, Chaqa, and foodcoats all voted END on Squigs after Vecna, damo, and summit made their cases to vote for Temasek over Squigs, but all ended up voting for Temasek after Jamie made a mislynch of Temasek feasible.

I was very confident Squigs was scum and I am sad we missed him that day. I moved because I was checking intermittently - 5 p.m. EST is always intermittent for me - and I saw it was tied 6-6. I hemmed and hawed and finally swore and put in the Temasek vote, because I did feel confident that he was probably scum, too, and I worried I was being vain in demanding we lynch Squigs.

But I was right.

And that.

Is why.

I will.

Lynch.

Bunny.

Tomorrow.

And then.

I will lynch.

damo the next day.

GOT'EM

That is believable, but according to the bot, Chaqa had already broken the tie 2 minutes before your vote.

Again, I can only check intermittently at this EOD due to the current situation moving some responsibilities around. I am not glued to the EOD vote count. I saw, I pondered, I punched it.

Normally I never vote naked but I did that time.

[BunnyGo]

I do not understand the conclusions you make. I slipped up by revealing Bozo was in the QT.

You’re saying bozo caught you because you slipped up.

No, I'm saying I slipped up in revealing Bozo was in our QT.

Sometimes I wonder if the two of us live in fundamentally different realities.

I don’t. I think you’re covering. I also think you’re stoned...simple same reality.

[Chaqa]

It concerns me that Chaqa and foodcoats went out of their way to make sure it was public knowledge I was in Chaqa's QT despite xorxes telling them not to, it could be because they were concerned a scum teammate might let it slip that they knew.

Eh, I slipped up in one of my many times playing this game after smoking.

StonedChaqa is not nearly as competent as DrunkBunny, unfortunately.

@Bunny - this is what this chain of posts was in response to.

I feel like you're conflating two different discussions.